Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: PHOTOS: Mike Moser's Dunk Face Is Spectacular

Is this man the league's MVP?

I'll be the first to admit that Ladanian Tomlinson is CLEARLY the Offensive Player of the Year in the NFL.  He leads the NFL in rushing with 1,749 yards and set the single-season touchdown record with 31 so far (and that doesn't even include his 2 passing TDs).

I can also admit that Drew Brees has been a great story for a Saints team that is clearly America's team this year.  Brees leads the NFL in passing yards and is 3rd in passer rating after more or less being forced out of San Diego.  I'm sure we can all agree Miami is regretting choosing Daunte Culpepper over Brees.

However, I think a very legitimate argument can be made for Frank Gore butting into the MVP race.  He's got the numbers and the impact that said numbers might not show.

Statistics
Frank Gore currently leads the NFC and is third in the NFL in rushing yards.  A drawback to that is that he only has 8 rushing touchdowns to LT's 28.  What Gore does have going for him is that his 1542 rushing yards ranks as a higher percentage of the team's total rushing yards than Tomlinson 77% to 72%.

Impact
I'll be the first to admit that what I'm about to argue is not scientific or based directly in statistics.  Rather it's just a gut feeling I get when looking at the various aspects of the 3 major MVP candidates' teams (San Diego, New Orleans, San Francisco).  In baseball, the MVP race often eliminates certain candidates because they play for a losing team.  The argument is brought up that an MVP leads their team to the playoffs.  If you have to make the playoffs then obviously it comes down to Tomlinson and Brees.

And yet I would argue that Frank Gore has in fact carried this team much further than they would have gotten otherwise and kept them legitimately competitive to the end.  Alex Smith certainly showed signs of improvement, but really Frank Gore carried this team to the precipice of the playoffs.  If Kevan Barlow and Frank Gore were splitting carries this year, I think this is a 4-12 team at best yet again.  Or if Frank Frank Gore put up these numbers in garbage time and the team finished 4-12 or 3-13, then clearly he's not the MVP.  Yet this team was competitive week in and week out (for the most part) and a few bounces the other way and they're in the playoffs this year and not talking about the playoffs for next year.

I'm not here to argue that LT and Drew Brees shouldn't win the MVP.  Rather, I simply am arguing that Frank Gore should at least be included more prominently in the conversation.  This 49ers team is on the verge of turning things completely around and I think he's a big part of the reason why they took such a big step this year.

Comment 10 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

certainly the TEAM MVP
you make a valid argument.  But there's no way that Gore gets serious consideration.  Whether fair or not, the fact of the matter is, unless you're on a winning team, you have next to no chance of getting the MVP.  

In my eyes the MVP goes to a player that completely changes the look of a team, puts a good team over the top, or so totally dominates the league that he can't be ignored.  Gore didn't do those.  He dominated at times, but like you said, his lack of touchdowns diminishes a great season.  Brees I think deserves the award, because from what I can see, he was the key acquisition for a team that went from awful to one of the best in their conference.  LT was brilliant, but he was brilliant for SD the last several years.  I don't think it was him stepping up more that made SD so much better this year (he was a big part, but not all of it).

Gore should deserve consideration, but I don't think he deserves to win.  

Bring back the classic Uni's!

by wjackalope on Dec 26, 2006 1:59 PM PST reply actions  

MVP ballot
Very good point.  I think that a way to reward him for carrying this team's offense is at least placing him in the top 5 of the MVP balloting.  It's not as recognized as winning the award but it shows that he's considered an elite player in the league this season.
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!

by David Fucillo on Dec 26, 2006 2:03 PM PST reply actions  

Sorry
Not to be a brat, but doesn't the Pro Bowl invite kind of do that?

MVP is an interesting thought, but I think he reached the endzone too few times, his other stats aside, to be a nice fit for the running. And I really really hate to say it, but there is something to be said for being on a winning (not even necessarily playoff) team, even if being on a losing team is often a sad case of circumstance.

It's this never ending argument about what makes value for individual players... just ask Albert Pujols about it....

I keep reliving the moment when Steve Young almost fell down... over and over...

by howtheyscored on Dec 26, 2006 3:07 PM PST up reply actions  

Pro Bowl
Good point on the Pro Bowl selection, particularly that he'll be starting.

The individual value of a given player can be so subjective at times.  You could conceivably argue for Steven Jackson as the league's MVP.  I think my point in suggesting Frank Gore will hopefully stir some debate on the true value of players.  When I was writing the post I thought to myself that if I was going to argue for Gore I could conceivably make an argument for Larry Allen, or the 49ers offensive line as a whole.  When healthy, the line has dominated in the running game.  You then look at this past weekend, injuries ravaged the line, Smith was worried and Gore finished with 51 yards (of course on only 11 carries).

This is a particular argument that can be both fun and frustrating because you can argue for anybody you want, but there isn't a completely 100% accurate answer (beyond Ladainian Tomlinson of course!)

Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!

by David Fucillo on Dec 26, 2006 3:15 PM PST up reply actions  

If Gore is in the top 5
Gore was outstanding this year but if he's in the top 5 he's 5th.  LT and Brees are miles ahead of him, these are teams that didn't even make the playoffs last year and both have first round byes this year.  Peyton being the NFL's golden will always be in the running.  And my forth is Steve McNair.  The Ravens have already doubled their win total from last year with a game to go with the only major addition being McNair.
Gore might done more for his team but the Niners still only have six wins, although the future looks bright, and it would hard to consider a guy on a 6 or 7 win team as the leagues MVP.

by methodrampage on Dec 26, 2006 2:24 PM PST reply actions  

LT
I've watched four Chargers games this season where they didn't have a hope in the world of winning if LT didn't decide that he's got to get it done himself. The opposing defenses really tried to make Rivers beat him by eliminating LT, but they couldn't even do that. He's the closest thing to an unstoppable player that there's been in quite a while.

by cheno on Dec 26, 2006 5:50 PM PST reply actions  

I think it has to go to LT
But Gore definitely deserves consideration

by reppin the bay @ Niners Nation on Dec 26, 2006 8:15 PM PST reply actions  

Brees
I'd vote Brees.  The Chargers are where they're at because of LT and Merriman (Defensive Player of the Year?).  Brees took a team that won like 2 games last year to the playoffs while compiling some gaudy numbers.

by methodrampage on Dec 27, 2006 7:12 AM PST reply actions  

Fumbles
His fumbles alone would knock him out of my top 5.
  1. LT
  2. Brees
  3. Manning
  4. Larry Johnson (QB woes all season)
  5. Steven Jackson
If Gore didn't fumble so much (especially at the goal line), he'd supplant Jackson, but Jackson's receiving #s are pretty ridiculous.

by RunRickeyRun on Dec 27, 2006 3:22 PM PST reply actions  

Excellent points
Very good points raised.  The fumbles are definitely a drawback.  LT has been great for the last few years and Brees has certainly been the single most important acquisition.

Also, I had mentioned the percentage of total rushing yards for LT and Gore, but Larry Johnson rushed for like 85% of his teams rushing yards.  He's carried that offense given the QB issues.

I hadn't been a big Steven Jackson fan, but I actually had him in fantasy football this year so I got a better chance to consider him week to week and he did so much for the Rams this year both rushing and receiving.

Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!

by David Fucillo on Dec 27, 2006 4:25 PM PST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Media Requests please email ninersnation@gmail.com

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Niners 3rd Downs: It ain't pretty any way you slice it
Images_small
Official Community Thread [2/9/2012] I hate pet peeves
Ohmygoshilovemiguelxd-1_small
What the 49ers Should Do This Offseason
Frog_small
Official Draft NN Draft Thread

Recent FanPosts

119588-192027-glenn-quagmire_large_small
Season Highlight Videos
Take_no_shit_small
Free Agency, the Draft, and Kendall Hunter
Small
Not fussed about No Hawk and no Rogers aint no stress
Small
On Dashon Goldson
Small
We didn't suck, so we don't need Luck.
Small
Have not heard this QB scenario

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Head Ball Coach

Dave_small David Fucillo

Howtheyscoredcat_small howtheyscored

313483_2054510893373_1562580382_31984672_1965025_n_small James Brady

Coordinator

Pirates_small smileyman

Bowman_avi_sm_small Tre9er

Assistant Coach

Pixies_logo_small (Florida) Danny Tuccitto

Memento-lies_small urnext

Me_on_beach_small WesHanson

P_willy_america_small Dylan DeSimone

Officiating Crew

Jackalope_card_small wjackalope

These3words_small these3words

San-francisco-49ers-helmet-logo-©photofile_small LondonNiner

Joe_and_bill_small twolfe2

Images_small mcwagner

Thecatch3_small mikeinsp