Niners Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Anquan Boldin Asks Arizona Cardinals for Trade.....Again Bar-right-arrows



My 49ers Mock Draft 1.0

[EDITOR'S NOTE] - I really like where this discussion is going. Although enut21 is going with Alan Branch, the consensus towards Patrick Willis has increased considerably. I tried to find an Ole Miss blog to get a scouting report, but no responses. If anyone can find a solid blog to give us a scouting report I'd appreciate it.

Here we go.

11. Alan Branch, DT -The odds that he could fall to us is looking more and more like a possiblity. Branch is the ideal guy to fill the middle of the d-line in our 3-4.

We trade #42,76,124 to NY Jets for #25.

  1. Dwayne Jarrett, WR - I think that WR is a much bigger need then people here believe. I would not be surprised to see Nolan move up from the 2nd round to grab Jarrett with the amount of picks we have this year. After the signing of Lelie, Jarrett makes a ton of sense as a compliment to Lelie's speed as a big possession  receiver who has shown he can make big plays in big games.
  2. Michael Bush, RB - Assuming he is falling this far due to his injury, it would be a steal to get this guy, this late. If He doesn't fall this far I see us grabbing Wynn, Walker, or Booker in the 4th.
  3. Ryan Harris, OT - He can play Tackle and Guard on both sides with huge potential. I'd love to see us draft this Harris so we can slide the other Harris on the bench for good.
  4. Zak DeOssie, OLB - He's a tall big guy who could play on the inside or on the outside in our scheme. He would be ideal subbing for Banta-Cain, as his strength is against the run as opposed to out in coverage like Banta-Cain. NFL.com compares him to Mike Vrabel.
  5. John Wendling, S -  Wendling would add more depth at safety. He has good coverage skills  and would be a great compliment to the big hitters we already have.
  6. Derek Landri, DT-DE - Local guy who went to De La Salle, would best be suited as a DE in the 3-4. Wouuld need to add some weight, Good Depth.
  7. Syvelle Newton, WR? - Another project player on offense. Has played QB,WR,RB,FB,FS in college. He is a big guy(6-2, 217) with decent 40 speed (4.4-4.5). Could fight for a spot as a WR or TE and is good on special teams.

This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Niners Nation's writers or editors. It does reflect the views of this particular fan though, which is as important as the views of Niners Nation's writers or editors.

0 recs | Comment 32 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

whoops
DeOssie @ 110

by enut21 on Mar 29, 2007 1:41 PM PDT   0 recs

49ers 2007 draft
I'm not going to break down the draft pick by pick but i'm going to comment on what should be important to us.

Trade Up?:  The only two players worth trading up for are Calvin Johnson or Laron Landry.  I think if Johnson falls to the Bucs, they would trade away the pick.  I've seen postings in support of us trading with the vikings.  That would be great bc we could get Landry and that, in my opinion, might give us a top five secondary in the NFL. With Clements, Spencer, Lewis, and Landry good luck throwing on us and that would be great against other good receiving teams in our league.  Also, Lewis and Landry have both been great blitzers and bringing pressure from the secondary means we wouldnt have to rely on the aging D line as much.  

Staying at 11:  1)Obviously I am a huge supporter of taking Landry if he's there but i think there is no way he still will be.  He would make our secondary almost equivalent to the 1994 team. 2)Patrick Willis is my second option.  This is a kid that is just an overall great person.  He has strong passion and great work ethic.  He also flourished as the nation's top linebacker in what most would consider the best conference.  Also, in a 3-4 defense your playmakers are your linebackers.  They have to make the plays.  3)Alan Branch is third because it is the NT's job to tie up blockers so that the LBs can make plays.  Branch has the best size of the DTs but Paul Soliai comes at a much cheaper price (maybe 4th round) and also has great size.  My problem with Branch is he lacks intensity and, to me, seems like he was always the fat kid that was just bigger and therefore better than everyone.  He won't be that in the NFL.

Trading Down: Maybe catch Willis but I doubt we could trade down too far after the results from his pro day.  I also like Reggie Nelson or Brandon Meriweather.

Not in 1st round:  Adam Carriker.....granted he has the size but his playmaking ability is questionable.  A big DE is what we need but a first round pick is a high price to pay.  DEs in a 3-4 just hold their ground and let the LBs make tackles....that's their job and i'm not willing to spend first round on that.  We can get that in later rounds.  I like Alama-Francis, Abiamiri, Atkins, Jay Moore, Pittman, and Bruce because of their size.

2nd round: Has to be reserved for a WR.  It is a huge need and any other yr i would take a WR in the first round when our need is this bad  but the class is so deep at the position that the 2nd round could bring us a number one WR.  My vote is to get Sidney Rice at all costs, even if it means trading with the Raiders for the fist pick in the second round. I'll be honest. I'm a senior at South Carolina but Sidney Rice is amazing and he will be a great player.  I watched him spank Chris Houston and Chris Houston i thought would be a first rounder before his combine bc he was all over sidney rice but rice was just taller than him. Rice has hands that are the best in the draft and his size will be a good compliment to lelie's speed.  I also like Laurent Robinson in the later rounds for WR.

OT has to be addressed with one of the fourth picks at the latestround picks bc Kwame Harris is equivalent to jj stokes as far as what pick we spent on him and what he has done for us.  We have snyder but he isnt proven yet.

From this draft: We need 2DEs, 2WRs, OT, C, FS, ILB, then either a FB or G

ILB could change to OLB depending on opposite of what Brandon Moore plays, considering he can play both

by Qbgetter13 on Mar 31, 2007 9:27 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Also
I would like to add that i hope the 49ers do not draft a DE to play OLB....i think LaMarr Woodley could do it bc he has great speed and want to but id rather have someone thats played the position....i also see some people like Zak DeOssie. Has great size but he is an ex QB that played in the ivy league.  I find it hard to imagine that an ex Qb developed a killer instinct that i think is an essential characteristic of a ILB that plays for me

by Qbgetter13 on Mar 31, 2007 9:35 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

WR
Why not potentially grab a receiver with their second round pick?  One of the more name receivers should be there high in the 2nd...they could deal up in 2nd and give up less to still get a solid WR.
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!

by Fooch on Mar 29, 2007 3:48 PM PDT   0 recs

True
I'm a big fan of Jarrett and I don't think he will make it past the 1st round if hes even there at 25 like I suggest.  I don't know if a guy like Rice or Meachem is going to fall to 42.  If we are going to trade up to get a WR, personally I think it would be worth it to add a 4th rounder to a deal to move up to the mid 20's as opposed to the start of the 2nd round. It all depends on what the board looks like obviously.

by enut21 on Mar 29, 2007 4:42 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Anyone else...
wanna take a crack at a complete 49ers mock draft? I'd like to see what others think.

by enut21 on Mar 29, 2007 4:46 PM PDT   0 recs

mock draft
I'll see what I can come up with over the next couple days for sure.
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!

by Fooch on Mar 29, 2007 4:54 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

My mock draft 1.0
My thoughts on taking Branch at #11 would be ok, but in this mock I have us taking the speedy ILB.

#11 Patrick Willis ILB 6-1 242 4.37

(trade 42,76,and 125) for the 25th pick

#25 Dawayne Bowe WR 6-2 222 4.49

#97 Doug Free OT 6-6 324 5.19 (Kwaime Harris)

#104 Kelvin Payne FS 6-0 220 4.44

#110 Zak DeOssie OLB/IBL 6-5 271 4.58

#135 Antonio Johnson DT 6-3 310 5.15

#147 Laurent Robinson WR 6-2 199 4.38

#186 Kieth Jackson DT 6-0 305 5.05

I picked Willis first in this mock draft because I think it is more important to have the leader (your most dominant player) in the 3-4 set be your inside LB ie Ray Lewis, and Brian Urlacher. The front three need to be big, quick and able to eat up blockes. I don't recall Baltimore or Pittsburgh having big named high draft picks on the D-line. They have space eaters.

Willis can run with TE's and RB's in passing situations as well! Defense wins championships

I love the moves this off season and we are sitting in a great position in this year draft. (numerous extra picks)

by alliyah1122 on Mar 29, 2007 5:17 PM PDT   0 recs

Those teams are built on their D-lines
Pittsburgh: NT Casey Hampton 19th Overall 2001

Baltimore: NT Haloti Ngata 12th Overall 2006

also

New England: DE Richard Seymore 6th Overall 2001, NT Vince Wilfork 21st Overall 2004, DE Ty Warren 13th Overall 2003

San Diego Chargers: NT Jamal Williams 32nd Overall 1998, DE Luis Casrillo 28th Overall 2005, DE Igor Olhansky 35th Overall 2004

The best 3-4 schemes in football are as good as they are because they are anchored by top flight first round defensive linemen. "Space eaters" are first round picks. They are one of the most saught after things in the draft. Alan Branch is a "space eater."

I'm not saying that linebackers aren't important, or that Ray Lewis isn't the best defensive player in Baltimore. I am saying that I'd build a defense around Tommie Harris before Brian Urlacher. I'm saying that Willis doesn't do us much good if we don't have anyone to keep blockers off him and unfortunately, that is the weakest and thinnest part of our defense. I don't see how the niners can go any way other than DL in the 1st round.  

Steve Wallace finishes his blocks. Bubba Paris finishes his plate.-Bill Walsh

by nothinlikethetown on Mar 31, 2007 2:35 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

WR
I too think that WR is a HUGE need for the team, I just don't think this year's draft is a good place to get one, unless they can trade way up to get Johnson (highly doubtful), or trade back a bit to get Bowe. I don't particularly like any other WR in the draft.
"You gotta bring ass, to get ass." --EDDIE DeBARTOLO JR.

by Josh from Hollywood on Mar 29, 2007 5:46 PM PDT   0 recs

Braek This
Here's my mock draft based on who'd be available per Draft Tek.

I made one trade, picks 107 & 124 for 93, and you'll see why.  I just had to do it and I think it would make sense from the Niners point.

  1.  Patrick Willis - ILB (I'm over Branch)
  2.  Arron Sears - OT
  3.  Quentin Moses - DE/OLB (OLB in a 3-4)
  4.  Michael Bush - RB (Draft Tek says he be there at 97 but I'm not taking a chance)
  5.  Marshall Yanda - OG
  6. Paul Williams - WR
  7. John Wendling - FS
  8. Ryan Smith - CB
  9. Steve Breaston - WR
This was kind of rushed but I think I like the end result.  Although I upgraded ILB and OLB I left the DL alone.  And I think if it comes down to it we can get through this year with the line as is and address it next year.  It's also tough looking for DE that are big enough for a 3-4 DE and I didn't want to waste my time trying to find them.

by methodrampage on Mar 30, 2007 8:36 AM PDT   0 recs

Not enough 3-4 DE for the whole season
If you look at our roster, we may have enough 3-4 NT in Sopoaga & Franklin, but we don't have enough 3-4 DE for the whole season.  At the moment, we only have Marques Douglas, Melvin Oliver, and a converted 3-4 DE in Bryant Young.  At best, you have a rotate of 3 DE for the season with no depth.  But if one of them gets hurt.... What are your options?  We need to add 3-4 DE.
1st Round Option: Jamaal Anderson and Adam Carriker.
2nd Round Option: Charles Johnson and Ika Alama-Francis
Later Rounds: Baraka Atkins, Ryan McBean
But we need to add someone in that position.

by ALottOfSense on Mar 30, 2007 10:40 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Franklin
Has and can play DE in a 3-4.

I really don't expect Jamaal Anderson to be around for the 11 pick.  I'd take Willis over Carriker in a lickidy split second.

Charles Johnson is too small to play a 3-4 DE.  Ika Alama-Francis is a viable option.

Baraka Atkins has the frame to put on some necessary weight to play DE in a 3-4 but he doens't excite me.  McBean interests me but is pretty raw.

So maybe I rethink my trade and HOPE Bush falls to me at 97 (which DraftTek does have him doing) and I take McBean at 124.  I might post an updated version of my mock a little later.

by methodrampage on Mar 30, 2007 11:03 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

But
They also have Ronald Fields, who the 49ers regard rather highly at RE.  Thats a four man rotation (at the very least), so depth at DE isn't necessarily going to be an issue.  

As for NT, between Sopoaga and Franklin, they should be able to take up 80% of the snaps (at the very least).  The remaining number of snaps could easily be spread between Damane Duckett and Ronald Fields (shifting inside from the outside for a few plays).

Honestly, I think Anderson and Carriker are definately viable options in the first round.  It's just that Anderson well be most likely gone by #11 and Braekneck probably ranks Willis higher on his board (like I do).

Similarly, in the second round, some project Johnson to go really early so he may be gone by the 49ers' pick.  He is also on the small-side, at least when considering a 3-4 DE.  Alama-Francis is an extreme stretch at where the 49ers pick in the second.  If they trade into the bottom of the second, he could be a possiblity.

There are definately a few options late in the draft, I just don't know how they'll rank in comparison to other players available when the 49ers pick.  Definately, a reach in the 4th and 5th rounds isn't too bad compared to a reach in the 2nd or 3rd.

by sfgfan on Mar 30, 2007 11:10 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Good Point
I didn't include Ronald Field in the equation, since  I thought they played him because they had no other options last year.  I didn't know they like him that much as a RE.
As for Charles Johnson, he is small for 3-4 DE, at 270lbs.  But he is one of the stronger DE in the draft, benching 33 times in the combine.  That's why I think he could be an option as a 3-4 DE.

by ALottOfSense on Mar 30, 2007 11:42 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Braek This V2.0
  1.  Patrick Willis, ILB, Ole Miss
  2.  Arron Sears, OT, Tennesse
  3.  Quentin Moses, OLB, Georgia
  4.  Michael Bush, RB, Louisville
  5. Paul Williams, WR, Fresno St.
  6. Paul Soliai, DT, Utah
  7. Ryan McBean, DE, Oklahoma St.
  8. John Wendling, FS, Wyoming
  9. Ryan Smith, CB, Florida
  10. Steve Breaston, WR, Michigan
After a little more research and such this is my new and improved mock draft.

By taking Willis and Moses to compliment Lawson and the other LB we have an awesome core of young LBs to develope.  Willis could be SF's version of Ray Lewis, and I really like the idea of that.  Moses was a DE in college but has the size and explosiveness to play a OLB in a 3-4.  Moses is a natural pass rusher and makes a lot of plays behind the line of scrimmage.

The DL gets addressed with Soliai and McBean, both guys that could benifit from BY being around.  Soliai has incredible size and is a pretty good athlete for being 344lbs.  McBean is raw but has a lot of potential and has good measurables.

WR is a pretty big offensive need.  Paul Williams has good size and speed and could delevope into a solid WR.  Breaston is a good return guy.

I just kind of like Wendling and Smith adds some CB depth.  Safety coverage is a concern and Wendling is probably more a SS but whatever, we'll just smash the shit of people.

by methodrampage on Mar 30, 2007 11:42 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

V2.1
DraftTek has Jacoby Jones being take at 146, and I'm going to say he falls to us at 147, so screw Steve Breaston my last two picks are as follows.
  1. Jacoby Jones, WR, Lane
  2. DeAndre Jackson, CB, Iowa St.
There you have it.  I definately prefer Jone and Jackson to Smith and Breaston.

Why is this so much more interesting than work?  And I'm out.

by methodrampage on Mar 30, 2007 11:57 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

I like Smith as well.
After you pointed him out earlier, I went on a research spree.  His scouting reports remind me a little bit of Walt Harris.  Not the fastest guy, but tough and physical.  He isn't afraid to play the run, and is very smart.  He could definately give BJ Tucker a run for his money and maybe even Donald Strickland.

by sfgfan on Mar 30, 2007 11:59 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

My turn.
Similar to Braekneck, I'm going off of what DraftTek has available at each position.

First round
#11: Patrick Willis, ILB, Ole Miss

Second round
#42: Arron Sears, OT, Tennessee

Third round
#76: Michael Bush, RB, Louisville
#97: Marshall Yanda, OG, Iowa

Fourth round
#104: Dashon Goldson, CB/S, Washington
#110: Paul Soliai, DT, Utah
#124: Tavarous Bain, CB, Hampton
#135: Quincy Black, OLB, New Mexico

Fifth round
#147: Rheema McKnight, WR, Notre Dame

Sixth round
#186: Steve Breaston, WR, Michigan

Comments:
Similar to Braekneck, I feel the defensive line's starters are solid enough, at least for this year.  With the extra depth from Soliai, who should be better than Sopoaga, the team's NT position is pretty much set.  Fields, Young, Douglas, and Oliver should be able to hold the ends off pretty well.

My draft does upgrade a few positions, notably ILB and HB, but also OLB and OL depth.  My favorite picks are Willis, Sears, Bush, and Black.  

I think Willis will have no trouble ousting Derek Smith from the starting lineup.  I'm looking forward to him and Manny Lawson teaming up to become two of the leaders on defense on and off the field.

Sears is as balanced a tackle as there is in this draft (ability wise).  He is regarded as one of those guys that do a lot of things well, but nothing great.  He has tons of upside and can play either OG or OT.

Bush.  6'1", 244.  Quick, agile, powerful.  Nuff said.

Quincy Black is an absolute physical specimen.  Has great speed and agility.  Supposedly he's great in coverage, in blitzes, and has a nose for the ball (always in the play).  He does have questionable run-support skills and isn't particularly physical, which is probably why he's available this late.

by sfgfan on Mar 30, 2007 9:52 AM PDT   0 recs

With a few exceptions
I like your mock better.  It looks good up until the 4th.  I take Paul Williams at 104 and Wendling 124 and Smith at 147.  I'm not a big McKnight fan and would prefer Williams.  But with those three tweaks, all the same positions are addressed as yours.  But overall, nicely done on the mock.

by methodrampage on Mar 30, 2007 10:29 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

My turn (V.1.1)
Thanks for your comments.  I actually like your changes, especially Wendling at #124 instead of Goldson #104.  Williams is also someone I've previously considered but completely slipped my mind when I did my mock.

First round
#11: Patrick Willis, ILB, Ole Miss

Second round
#42: Arron Sears, OT, Tennessee

Third round
#76: Michael Bush, RB, Louisville
#97: Marshall Yanda, OG, Iowa

Fourth round
#104: Paul Williams, WR, Fresno State
#110: Paul Soliai, DT, Utah
#124: John Wendling, S, Wyoming
#135: Quincy Black, OLB, New Mexico

Fifth round
#147: Ryan Smith, CB, Florida

Sixth round
#186: Steve Breaston, WR, Michigan

by sfgfan on Mar 30, 2007 11:27 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

I'm confused.
Why would the niners draft a RB before a WR when RB isn't a glaring weekness. Same goes for drafting a offensive tackle and guard before bolstering the defensive line. Niners have Adam Snyder waiting to take a starting job, same goes for Baas and Wragge. We need someone big up front to take the heat off the LB's and we need a #1 or #2 wideout.

by jjham15 on Mar 31, 2007 10:19 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Easy.
You just can't pass on Bush that late in the draft.  Similarly, the Saints couldn't pass on Reggie Bush last season.

As for OL over DL.  Smiley and Harris are both rumored to be on their way out.  Smiley and the 49ers haven't started on an extention and rumor has it he's being shopped around in trade talks.  Kwame is a no-brainer to be gone in some-way-shape or form by the end of next season.

by sfgfan on Apr 1, 2007 12:11 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

My Mock
  1. Patrick Willis ILB, Mississippi
  2. Tank Tyler NT, NC State
  3. Kenny Irons RB, Auburn
  4. Ryan Harris OT, Notre Dame
  5. Josh Beekman G/C, Boston College
  6. Zach DeOssie ILB/OLB, Brown
  7. Ryan McBean DE, Oklahoma State
  8. Brian Robinson OLB, Texas
  9. Rhema McKnight WR, Notre Dame
  10. Laurent Robinson WR, Illinois State
We get a starter at ILB and NT in the first two rounds, and solid backup for Gore(although I'd be ok with Bush there too) in the third with a potential starting tackle in Harris.  De Ossie and Robinson provide great linebacking depth, and McBean should transition well to a 3-4 end spot.  McKnight and Robinson are very good WR talents late in the draft.

by gatling on Mar 30, 2007 10:43 AM PDT   0 recs

Another Version
  Another version from Draft Tek database.
  1. Patrick Willis ILB, Mississippi
  2. Justin Blalock OG, Texas
  3. Antonio Johnson DT, Mississippi St
  4. Ryan Harris OT, Notre Dame
  5. Earl Everett OLB, Florida
  6. Baraka Atkins DE, Miami
  7. Ryan McBean DT, Oklahoma St
  8. John Wendling FS, Wyoming
  9. Brandon Myles WR, West Virginia
  10. Brandon Sharp FS, Louisville
  If James John WR, San Jose State is available as FA after the draft, sign him too.

by ALottOfSense on Mar 30, 2007 11:09 AM PDT   0 recs

Hmmm
You put tons of emphasis on the defensive line, when there are at least some obvious backups and depth there but you completely ignore running back.  Even if Mo' Hicks re-signs, do you really think he is a viable #2 back?  Or do you think that Michael Robinson is ready to make the jump up to #2?

Also, do they really need two safeties from this draft?  They're pretty deep in fresh contracts back there with M. Lewis, K. Lewis, and M. Roman.  Not to mention Nolan really wants Marcus Hudson to move back to safety as well.

Just a couple of thoughts.

by sfgfan on Mar 30, 2007 11:18 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

If Hicks resigns before the draft...
I highly doubt we will take a RB before our last 2 picks in the 4th round, if at all.

by enut21 on Mar 30, 2007 11:23 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Michael Robinson is a stud
Love Michael Robinson.  I think if he was a college running back, we would have put up the same number, if not better, than those of Tony Hunt.  I think he will be a great #2 back.  On top, I do think Hicks will sign with us again.
On the safety, I think Roman was a disappointment last year.  Nolan gave him the job, but he just couldn't do it.  So I wouldn't count on him being here for too long, hence the Sharp pick.

by ALottOfSense on Mar 30, 2007 11:34 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

With Hicks we will have 3 backs.
I don't see us drafting another back until late. We can't go into the season with Gilmore as our #3 or Branden Williams unless he takes a huge leap.

by jjham15 on Mar 31, 2007 10:23 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

robinson
michael robinson has a long way to go..... he runs too high and i wish the 9ers would lay off drafting players for positions they didnt play in college.  Hick is our number two and i love his intesity and determination....it is asking a lot of someone to play tailback at the nfl level when they've never done it

by Qbgetter13 on Mar 31, 2007 6:43 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Battle
The 49ers drafted Arnaz Battle to convert to WR and he seems to be making the transition fairly well.  He's developing into an excellent 2/3 receiver for us.
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!

by Fooch on Apr 1, 2007 7:33 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

correction
James Jones WR, San Jose State

by ALottOfSense on Mar 30, 2007 11:10 AM PDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Where Josh Morgan fever is reaching unhealthy levels!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Niners trade for Boldin PLEASE!!!
Dixon_small
My All-Time 49ers Team
Small
Double Whammy
Small
unsigned WR with massive potentential that no one is talking about
S
O' Boy
Dixon_small
Colvin?
Dixon_small
New Here
Ab_small
Shaun Hill?
Small
Niners Nation Madden League Interest
Small
The Quarterback 3-Way Battle, or Is It?

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Head Ball Coach

Dave_small Fooch

Assistant Coaches

Untitled_small howtheyscored

Mattforweb_small MattMiller

ad

Site Meter