Dolphins 14 - 49ers 9: A Look Back
I decided to give the game a few hours before taking a more thorough look back at today's game. When you lose a game the way the 49ers did today, there's plenty of mixed feelings. There's obviously disappoint, as with any loss. Of course the disappointment comes more from the fact that as bad as the team played they had chances to win this game. While it's good to know they can hang in there in ugly games, they need to pull these ones out more often. So let's get to the good, the bad and the ugly.
The Good
DeShaun Foster - Foster wasn't spectacular, but given the low expectations I think he more than exceeded most people's. After some early struggles he seemed to settle into a groove and brought the Frank Gore style of fighting for extra yards. He turned potential 2nd and 7 or 8 into 2nd and 4 or 5, which is always a bonus. I caught some of "The Point After" on Fox and they were talking about how the team missed Gore in the red zone. That's certainly possible, but I don't know if Gore really would have done any better than Foster. Do you?
Bryant Johnson - He wasn't spectacular, but quietly had another solid game, making a couple big catches for the team. I don't know if he'll be back next year, but I would like him back. He's finding his groove and if he can stay healthy through training camp next year, I think he could be a real impact player.
Aubrayo Franklin - Franklin continues to impress in the second half of the season. I still think the team needs to bring a big fat nose tackle for the 3-4, but for now Franklin is doing the trick. Do others see him as a long term answer, or more just a quality backup in the future?
Second Half Defense - After getting burned by Pennington and his tight ends, the defense stepped up in the second half and kept the 49ers in the game. The biggest stop may have been when they stopped Ronnie Brown for a loss of 2 yards on 3rd and 4. Dan Carpenter's field goal hit the corner of the upright and very well would have been good otherwise.
Isaac Bruce - Bruuuuuuuuce continues his late season resurgence with another solid game. It seemed like every catch he made was for a first down or close to one. He's really stepped up his game when the team has needed it most. At the same time...
The Bad
Isaac Bruce - That illegal formation penalty was absolutely brutal. The 49ers had successfully converted a 2nd and 11, but instead were backed up to the 34. A sack and incompletion later and it was 4th and 23 at the Miami 41. If Bruce doesn't get that penalty, there's a good chance they at least get 3 points, which we all know would have been useful at the end of the game.
Late game offensive play-calling - This covers the lack of rushing on the second to last 49ers drive and the decision to spike the ball on the last drive. The running game had been solid to that point and with over seven minutes left to start that drive, there was plenty of time to run your normal offense. That probably falls on Martz. The spike falls on either Martz, Shaun Hill or Mike Singletary. I'd lean towards Hill because it was the second play in a row in the hurry up, following the two-minute warning. The spike occurred at 1:20 left in the 4th at the Miami 21. I understand you want to make sure things don't get out of hand, but there was plenty of time to run the normal hurry-up offense without absolutely rushing things. Maybe they never get that touchdown, but that play did not help matters (and neither did the jackass who ran on the field earlier).
The Ugly
Mark Roman - It's just about reached the point of concluding that Mark Roman should not be the starting free safety for the San Francisco 49ers. Ok, maybe it's more reaching it's zenith. I might try and give him a pass on that Martin touchdown, but he probably should not have been spun around on that. However, he looked really bad on the Ronnie Brown run late in the game when Brown just blew past him with ease. The good news for the 49ers is they've got Dashon Goldson waiting in the wings. The bad news is he's been banged up most of the year, which can't be helping his progress. However, if Singletary is coach next season, I fully expect Goldson to win the starting free safety spot. Roman benefited from being one of "Nolan's guys." That won't happen again.
Red Zone offense - The 49ers offense replicated the Bills offense from two weeks ago, minus the huge rushing performance of Marshawn Lynch. The offense moved the ball quite well between the 20s, but then crapped out in the red zone. I'm not wildly concerned about this because they've proven they can score in the red zone. I just hope they don't lose the confidence required to punch in the ball.
Looking Forward
The 49ers head into St. Louis next week with the Rams in a dogfight for draft positioning. The good news, at least as far as I'm concerned, is that there's no way Jim Haslett doesn't do his best at getting his guys up for the game. He's coaching for a chance to be the full-time guy next season so the Rams shouldn't taking a dive.
The 49ers should expect to win this game. That's fine, as long as they don't go in expecting the Rams to roll over. I expect Mike Singletary to be fired up following this rather poor performance and have his guys fired up accordingly. I should take any kind of win possible, but I'm at a point where I think this team should be beating down a team like the Rams. Let's hope our boys bring their A-game next week.
Comments
The bad – Barry Simms
The ugly- Barry Simms
Rafael Rodriguez: Your number 8 organizational prospect before stepping a foot on American soil and has "looked just super so far," according to Felipe Alou...according to Baggs.
by BrianBokake on
Dec 14, 2008 7:01 PM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
Totally forgot him
He was not a pretty sight today. Wonder if Snyder would’ve picked up Porter?
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!
by Fooch on
Dec 14, 2008 7:13 PM PST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
I feel like
yeah we didn’t win, and we played a pretty ugly game, but we held our own against a pretty good team. We were the Bills from last week. We got in the red zone and our guys just didn’t make plays while their guys did. I think we will be OK. I’m still giving Singletary a thumbs up and I really hope at the end of the season he is named HC. Did anyone notice 0 turnovers? The man sees mistakes and he corrects them. Imagine what could be if you give him a full offseason to mold this team.
As for Bryant Johnson, i’m with you Fooch, I hope he sticks around as well. He’s had some nice grabs the past couple weeks. I think him, Bruce, JHill, Morgan, Ziegs and Battle is a pretty nice little group of receivers to have. I think Bruce might be the best FA acquisition this off-season.
And about Mark Roman, I think you meant to say
Mark Roman should not be athestarting free safetyfor the San Francisco 49ersin the NFL
Simply by pulling on both ends, Patrick Willis can stretch diamonds back into coal
by 49erLou on
Dec 14, 2008 7:19 PM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
I think he really meant..
Mark Roman shouldnotbethe startingfreesafetyfor the San Francisco 49ers.
"We'd like to think that tickets will be hard to come by." Bill Walsh
by TripTheNinja on
Dec 14, 2008 7:38 PM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
A few other things
There were a couple of pass plays, one that clanked off Vernon’s hands and another that hit him on the butt, that make me start doubting that Davis will ever be an offensive weapon. You have to catch, and if you’re running a route, especially a hot route, you’ve got to be expecting the ball from the snap. Not sure why VD was on the sideline on the last Niner offensive play, but he could have been helpful in stopping Porter.
I know everyone loves Michael Robinson, but five carries, eight yards, a 1.6 average. This is every week. He’s fine catching the ball but he doesn’t seem to run from the backfield very well.
I was half joking that they should use Davis as a fullback, where he could lead block and occasionally get a handoff. But if they do that, then maybe use Robinson as a tight end. Maybe not big enough, but he isn’t a running back. Sorry. I don’t think he makes the squad next year.
I think I said it during the game, but the Niners definitely need an upgrade at free safety. I think most of us agree on that.
Foster was the equal to what Gore has been able to do the last month or so. What I think was missing was the respect for the Niners’ run game that they had with Gore in there. In passing downs it seemed like the Dolphins were putting in six DBs, their version of the “big sub” I guess. With Gore in there they have to put more people in the box. And that gives more space for receivers downfield.
I don’t think that the Niners played a bad game. I don’t even think it was a particularly ugly game. It was hard fought, I thought the defense adjusted in the second half and if Gore and Rossum were playing they would have won. One reason they had such long drives was because they started with such lousy field position which was because they didn’t have a decent return game.
And speaking of a shopping list, the Niners still need a fast, deep threat.
by Bob On The Coast on
Dec 14, 2008 7:47 PM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
What I saw was..
..The 49ers defense simply did not start this game like the Jets game. It took Singletary comming in, and calling a time out , in the second half. With him jumping up and down, to get that intensity back, it came back.. ..but too late. Willis, got fooled by Brown Too many times, thus Brown is highly underrated in my book, Williams, they were all over. The ealry broken coverages for TD’s were embarrasing at best.
Roman is a leftover from Nolan, and it really concerns me, Singletary hasn’t addressed it yet. He needs to try somone else. Not that he’s (Roman) not good, at getting the defensive unit on the same play, but he is definitely one of our weekest links every game.
As far as the rest of the Secondary, Strickland continues to impress, #22 was still nursing his thumb and it showed, even though, I am sure he would of made that interception, if it was not for Roman.. ..hard to blame Roman too much on that one though.. what if somehow, it did make it in the phins hands? so I think he was just doing his job.. ..but it shows me that, while he may be good at getting everyone else on the same page, he is not good at getting himself on the same page..
He just does not mesh, with the other guys, maybe in the locker room, but not on the feild.
Heitman was terrific, he was getting off the ball so quick, I thought for sure he was going to get a false start, it was awesome! best player out there today, aside from Bruce!
Rachal is continuing to impress as well. Shaun was really good in the begining, just as Soon as Snyder went down, things got ugly though. I have to say, VD would have done a better job at Tackle, especially on that last play. And when Snyder went down, thats when the commication started breaking down with the young guys, the vets (Bruce, Johnson) were doing much better at reading the game, and the extra pressure that was coming, shows me Snyder is pretty good, but now he’s injured?
Bruuuce was phenom, unfortunately, it was very soon understood, he was the only grown up for Hill to throw too, and double teams followed.. ..the kids, looked liked kids.
..Especially Zig Dog on punts, I mean c’mon, put Bruuce back there at least, or even Walker, who muffed one, but he’s ok.
Ziggy looked like he was back in High school..
.. I still think that all 3 of the young guys will be good though, and should stay, on this team. I was bummed Morgan didn’t get one, he was so good, untill he got hurt..
However, it was obvious, the only one Hill could count on was Bruce, however, Sean Ryan Showed some nice hands, looked like Rathman, I’d like to see more of him..
At the end of the game I was wondering why, my guy Hill ws struggling so much after, he was getting the best of Will Allen all day, but my conclusion was, they started double teaming Bruuce, and Hill was having a hard time getting the other 3 to do what he wanted, especially once Sims was in and He was getting the ball out early, cuz the pass rush was so overwhelming, and the inexperienced guys, just weren’t ready, not getting their head around, dropping balls, e.t.c.
Johnson was good, but his and Davis’ back to back drops, killed that drive.
Davis’ definitely needs more practice on his hands, but he did a good job of running the ball, LOL, and like expected, he got the best of Porter, and should have gotten more of him.
I am not sure Martz is the guy, I think he is good at what he does, but I think Singletary Might have a better fit, floating out there.
Even though too late.. ..the fact the team responded so well after his called Time out/ Toung lashing of his unfocused defense, shows Singletary IS the guy, and will do much better, when he is not finishing the season with someone elses team, and starting it with is own. Manusky has gotten better, I think he has improved, I think he will stay.
Coaching.. other than what I already addressed? Most SIGNIFICANT!?!
..I would have only taken 2 of our time outs before the 2 minute warning, and I think, it proved my point, when Bruce stepped out of bounds at the 2 minute warning. It also seems to me that Martz doesn not have enough plays available, because most of his starters, probably only know half of them or less. I also wonder why his trick plays have seemed to fool no one all year?
Coaching.. other than what I already addressed? Most SIGNIFICANT!?!
..I would have only taken 2 of our time outs before the 2 minute warning, and I think, it proved my point, when Bruce stepped out of bounds at the 2 minute warning. It also seems to me that Martz doesn not have enough plays available, because most of his starters, probably only know half of them or less. I also wonder why his trick plays have seemed to fool no one all year?The Miami D was good, and without Frank Gore, it really showed that we need a star on the other side of Bruuce.. hopefully the kids will be ready soon, but we seriously, need a quality WR, Saftey or corner (Harris would be a decent free saftey, he has a great nose for the ball..) a Pass Rusher, and of course.. Tackle. I was much more bummed Clayton did not get a snap, as opposed to Brooks, Shame we didn’t have Green this game.
Coaching.. other than what I already addressed? Most SIGNIFICANT!?!
..I would have only taken 2 of our time outs before the 2 minute warning, and I think, it proved my point, when Bruce stepped out of bounds at the 2 minute warning. It also seems to me that Martz doesn not have enough plays available, because most of his starters, probably only know half of them or less. I also wonder why his trick plays have seemed to fool no one all year?The Miami D was good, and without Frank Gore, it really showed that we need a star on the other side of Bruuce.. hopefully the kids will be ready soon, but we seriously, need a quality WR, Saftey or corner (Harris would be a decent free saftey, he has a great nose for the ball..) a Pass Rusher, and of course.. Tackle. I was much more bummed Clayton did not get a snap, as opposed to Brooks, Shame we didn’t have Green this game.Give Singletary the power, to put the people he wants, where he wants, let him make it his team, and most of our plauging issues, keeping us from championship glory, I firmly believe, will be gone, next year.. ..ask Tony Sparano what he thinks? After todays, last minute victory, I’ll bet he is happy he doesn’t have to see a team built by Singletary until 2012..
by Josh G and the Shaun Hill band wagon on
Dec 14, 2008 7:53 PM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
Sorry..
for the bad edit at the end don’t know what I pressed..lol
by Josh G and the Shaun Hill band wagon on
Dec 14, 2008 7:54 PM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
add Barry Sims and Adam Syner to the ugly. Seriously, I can understand giving up sacks when JTO is QB, but shaun hill, really. I mean, shaun hill has been sacked something like 18 times in 7 games. Not bad, but unfortunately, im guess 12-14 have come from the right tackle. I know today 4 of 5 where from that. I like the rest of our o-line. A very solid C, a up and rising LT, and two aggressive young Gs, but we need to complete the line before we can be a ligit team.
According to the comminsioner of the nfl, 104 people retired last year. 7 due to age, and the rest because of Patrick Willis
by montasmob69 on
Dec 14, 2008 8:40 PM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
Right Tackle
Sims was responsible for most of that as Snyder went down early in the first quarter. One sack came by him and it looked like a blown assignment I think. He and Rachal blocked the same defensive end and Roth, the OLB, blew right by them. Foster had moved in front and to the left of Hill to protect there. Hard to tell who was at fault, although Snyder should’ve seen Roth getting jumpy near the line.
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!
by Fooch on
Dec 14, 2008 8:47 PM PST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Some random thoughts...
Foster played pretty poorly. He ran with little to no strength, it’s obvious he can’t make any kind of cut back. I’d much rather give Clayton a shot.
I liked the option pass play, but why don’t they ever run that with Michael Robinson, the guy who actually used to play QB?? It baffles me that they don’t try to take advantage of his multiple skills.
VD…HUGE dropped pass that went right to his hands. He even watched it the whole way, he just seems to have hands of steel. If he’s coming back on a new contract, it better be for a much reduced price that reflects that of a good blocking TE.
I really wish Singletary would have gone for it on that last FG they scored. It was only 5 yards or so to go (IIRC). The chances they took at the Jets all seemed to go away for yesterday’s game. Whatever. This loss sucked because they could have won, which describes many of this year’s losses.
STEVE HOLM! refuses to be the odd man out.
by UnleashTheGore on
Dec 15, 2008 9:45 AM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
Foster
He went 18 carries for 76 yards and 5 catches for 25. Not too shaby i thought. and no strength…did u watch the game, because from what i saw he was pushing piles for extra yards multiple times. Not an outstanding game, but pretty damn good.
VD i couldnt agree more. he has some of the worst hands since TO. thats why ive been a little surprised the last few weeks that hes been catching the ball. but he showed his true self in this one.
by good as gold on
Dec 15, 2008 11:52 AM PST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
yeah, i watched the game
18 for 76 isn’t much…4 yards per carry. Yeah, it may not be as horrible as my comment made it out to be, but it certainly isn’t acceptable for a running back. I don’t recall many times he pushed for extra yards. I guess I could have missed those moments, but it seemed to me that most rushes were just running straight at the defensive players rather than trying to find holes and hitting them hard.
STEVE HOLM! refuses to be the odd man out.
by UnleashTheGore on
Dec 15, 2008 1:08 PM PST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Not acceptable?
Considering that Frank Gore is averaging 4.3 yards per carry on the season, 4.2 yards per carry by Foster yesterday really shouldn’t be considered bad at all.
by sfgfan on
Dec 15, 2008 2:21 PM PST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Late-game spike
I think the 49ers went into that sequence with two plays called in the huddle. After the gain by Robinson, the 49ers have already eaten up a huge chunk of field while running both plays called.
It’s one of those situations where you can criticize it if things go wrong, or praise it if it goes right. It could be argued that the 49ers needed time to regroup (and breathe) and call a new set of plays for the redzone area (which is where they were, almost). It could also be argued that they gave the defense time to regroup, as well.
by sfgfan on
Dec 15, 2008 10:22 AM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
fooch...i'm back from the cruise...
ended up watching the game at a local bar instead of atlantis because we had to be back on the ship by 4:30 EST. anyway, four quick things:
1) i believe i’ve said this before, but PLEASE GET THE (SITE DECORUM) RID OF MARK (SITE DECORUM) ROMAN!!!!! it was hilarious. i was explaining to the dolphin fans that were watching the game with me how mark roman has gotten 3 turnovers as the 49ers FS over the past 3 seasons, and how he’s a general waste of space on the field. each time i mentioned it, he low and behold showed his ineptitude. the funniest one was when he blew up nate clements to break up the easy INT. what a joke that guy…excuse me, that “nolan guy.”
2) i believe someone mentioned in their preview on friday something about the red zone deciding the game. wonder if my comment nemesis is going to make his way online to congratulate me on a spot-on statistical prognostication. :-)
3) barry “the turnstile” sims makes me wish reminisce fondly of the days of jennings/harris at RT.
4) i’m pretty sure that haslett has ::in starkey voice:: “no chance, no chance” to be retained as rams head coach next season. i’m also sure that he knows it. hence, their 8th loss in a row yesterday. i can’t really see a team retaining an interim coach who just captained their worst losing streak since 1995. i’d expect an unbelievably flat, unmotivated, despondent, helpless Lambs team next week. ripe for the slaughter.
by Florida Danny on
Dec 15, 2008 11:29 AM PST
reply
actions
0 recs
ripeness
The problem is then it becomes a virtual no-win situation for the 49ers. Expected to win and win big. I’ve got a post for tomorrow discussing these last two games in the bigger picture…
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!
by Fooch on
Dec 15, 2008 12:03 PM PST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
although...
when you’re 5-9 it’s not quite so win to win any games I suppose.
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!
by Fooch on
Dec 15, 2008 12:03 PM PST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
About Abrayo
I would like to see a young DT picked up but the key to any D-line is to have a quality rotation in effect and I think Abrayo would be even better if he were kept fresher (like the Falcons are doing with AbBraham this season). He’s capable of getting a good push, but not consistently enough for a good DT, he’s simply above average as far as I see it right now.
by foosball4949 on
Dec 15, 2008 9:33 PM PST
reply
actions
0 recs


















