49ers Undrafted Free Agent Signings: Do You Believe In Miracles?
Editor's Update 8:27am: Indeed Gary Guyton has officially signed with the Patriots, so I changed the poll and crossed out his info.
First off, big thanks to Saint from Silver and Black Pride for the FanPost with the undrafted free agents signed by the 49ers. Who says 49ers fans and Raiders fans can't get along? Well I suppose in the offseason it's easier. But big thanks nonetheless.
And maybe calling it miracles is a bit overdone. Plenty of undrafted free agents have made a name for themselves in the NFL and I'm certainly rooting for these guys. We all want to see the 49ers sign the next Tony Romo, Kurt Warner or Priest Holmes. While the odds are quite slim, it's still worth checking out who we signed and what kind of impact they might make. Additionally, I know people have mentioned how they have heard stuff about certain guys, so I want this to be considered a sort of open thread/link dump for info on the undrafted free agents the 49ers appear to have signed.
Robert Jordan, WR, California - Obviously many folks around here are fans of the Golden Bears. Jordan was wildly overshadowed by Desean Jackson and Lavelle Hawkins. If Jackson was the sizzle and Hawkins was the steak of the Cal receiving corp, Jordan would be the mashed potatoes (not sure how that analogy works, but whatever). He had a consistent but quiet regular before exploding for 6 catches, 148 yards and a touchdown in Cal's Armed Forces Bowl victory. He had a better senior season and career than Josh Morgan AND he hasn't been taken down with pepper spray. Morgan is a bigger guy, but I'm gonna go on record as saying Jordan makes the team and Morgan does not.
Gary Guyton, OLB, Georgia Tech - Guyton's intriguing because he was projected to actually get drafted somewhere between Round 4-6. I've checked out some mock drafts and reviews and the general consensus is that he looks to be a super special teams guy, with the upside of being a contributing every down linebacker. Scout's Inc ranked him 14th among outside linebackers and says:
While he wowed front offices with his impressive combine, it's clear on film that Guyton needs to develop a mean streak and work on his man-to-man cover skills. That said, numbers don't like and there's no question he's got a great deal of upside because of his blend of size, speed and athletic ability. At the very least Guyton projects as an excellent special teams' player and at best he emerges as a productive every-down outside linebacker.
He sounds like Larry Grant but with more every down upside. Assuming Guyton and Grant both make it to training camp and the preseason, we could see a very interesting battle between them.
Ezra Butler, OLB, Nevada - Like Guyton, Butler was projected to be drafted as well, but for some reason or another, teams passed on him. Any info would certainly be appreciated by everyone. Apparently he was suspended for the Wolfpack season opener for "rules violations." Scout's Inc ranked him 18th among outside linebackers and said:
Butler doesn't have great cover skills and he needs to work on his technique but he has the size, burst and toughness to develop into an effective reserve or adequate starter in a 3-4 scheme so he projects as a mid-to-late round pick.
Throw him in with Guyton and Grant and we might have some decent competition for OLB depth. I don't see why 2 of the 3 can't make the team.
This is going a little longer than I thought, so the remaining guys are going to be discussed after the jump.
Joe Jon Finley, TE, Oklahoma - Boomer Sooner anybody? Scout's Inc ranked him 12th among tight ends and a possible 5th or 6th round pick:
Finley isn't a dominant drive blocker or an explosive receiver and his lack of overall strength may make him a better fit for a team that uses H-Backs. However, he's a tenacious drive blocker and adequate short-to-intermediate receiver so he projects as a late fifth or early sixth round pick.
While it sounds like Finley is a pretty solid talent coming out of college, he also has to deal with competing with Vernon Davis, Billy Bajema and Delanie Walker. Needless to say, I'm not holding my breath to see him on the roster.
Louis Holmes, DE, Arizona - A little research told me that Holmes entered Arizona as the nation's top junior college player but never lived up to his potential in spite of impressive size. And it sounds like he's our SECOND player to get pepper sprayed in college just prior to being arrested for the second time in two years (the pepper spray was a random guy, not the cops). AWE-SOME. Surprisingly, Scout's Inc does not include a notation for character issues:
Holmes has the frame, tenacity and upper body strength to provide adequate depth in the NFL. However, his technique needs work and his upside is limited by his lack of initial quickness as well as poor closing speed. In addition, questions still linger about his 2007 arrest and whether or not it was an uncharacteristic mistake so Holmes projects as a seventh round pick.
I'd like to see him make the team just to see what he can do to get arrested for a 3rd time. Apparently one of his arrests surrounded an incident where he knocked out an Arizona State player (and not on the field of play). That's taking the rivalry seriously.
Brian De La Puente, OL, California - Ok, I'm struggling finding information about De La Puente. Any Cal fans out there with info on him?
Cameron Colvin, WR, Oregon - He appeared in 5 games this season (missed the last 7 games) and showed up at the 49ers Pro Day 10 days ago. Not seeing much else out there so feel free to contribute any knowledge.
I think that's everybody but I'm sure others will get signed between now and training camp. Feel free to vote on who you think has the best chance of making the regular season roster.
0 recs |
25 comments
Comments
do some research
Cameron colvin is a local kid out of Pittsburgh CA and former standout receiver from local De la salle high school. Just because Jordan went to Kal doesn’t mean we should know more about him then Colvin.
by Ninerkrazy08 on Apr 29, 2008 1:01 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
To be fair
Cal is a little more high profile. The institution of De La Salle H. S. is extremely high profile, yes, but I’d be surprised if very many people could even name their coach, much less any of their players, much less any of their players from five years ago. Cal is high profile in a way that people know the names of the people who are involved in the success (or, as last year would tell us all, lack thereof).
My Dave Righetti is better than your Dave Righetti.
by howtheyscored on Apr 29, 2008 12:20 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Good point.
Unless you have consistent access to the Contra Costa Times or other local (to Concord) paper, you don’t really see/hear any mention of De La Salle in the news (that includes television news) except during the HS playoffs.
by sfgfan on Apr 29, 2008 12:24 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
You know what’s awesome? Using the letter ‘k’ in place of ‘c’. It’s the koolest.
Neglectful father of David Quinowski
by marcello on Apr 29, 2008 1:43 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Ayyyy
what do you know markello?
"To know clearly what pleases the world is but a brief dream." --Machiavelli
by jfainsf49 on Apr 29, 2008 1:47 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
the kewlest
especially if youre a 12 year old girl
by sam23 on Apr 29, 2008 2:13 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
LOL4RLZ!
Neglectful father of David Quinowski
by marcello on Apr 29, 2008 5:57 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I'm stoked...
about Jordan. I really hope he makes the team. I watched every Cal game this last season, even the blunders, and I distinctly remember Jordan. In fact, I am flat out shocked he didn’t go in one of the late rounds. I mean I know it wasn’t a receiver’s draft, but sheesh! Every receiver was underrated because the top receivers were nothing special. We should be lucky that he wanted to try out for our Niners.
Anyway, Jordan was integral to some of the limited success that Cal experienced last season. Jordan made big chain-moving catches and he really scrapped for every YAC. If Cal didn’t have Jackson or The Hawk last year, Jordan could have easily racked up huge numbers IMO. He lacks some size, which is probably why he went undrafted. But keep an eye on him in training camp.
I wouldn’t even mind one bit if we cut Lelie so that we can keep this kid.
I think I pulled my swagger muscle...
by BawLa on Apr 29, 2008 1:23 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I always thought of Jordan
As a sort of Hawkins/Jackson cross. Jordan has better all around skills than Jackson (like Hawkins), but doesn’t approach Jackson’s level of gamebreakeryness (speed, separation, open field running). By the same coin, though, he always seemed to be a little more dynamic than Hawkins, but not nearly as polished in the overall game.
And he has terrible hands. Jordan was one of the more frustrating players for me to watch from the student section, because 7/10 times when a ball was dropped I could guess who it was before I saw the number. He brings a lot of skills to the table, but I think the reasons he went undrafted are kind of detailed in my description of him. He has a little bit of everything. He’s relatively well rounded, but doesn’t really excell in any one aspect of the game. He’s not as dynamic as a gamebreaker, and not as polished as a reliable randy (God help me, sometimes I just can’t turn a good phrase). And I think his hands hurt him, too.
But also by that same coin, he has things in his game that Jackson doesn’t have, and he has things in his game that Hawkins doesn’t have. By virtue of having more all around skills, he could conceivably succeed where Jackson is most likely to fail, and by virtue of being somewhat more dynamic, he could conceivably succeed where Hawkins is most likely to fail. OR, by virtue of being less good at the things that make Jackson great, and less good at the things that make Hawkins great, he could get stuck in the no man’s land of tweener island.
My Dave Righetti is better than your Dave Righetti.
by howtheyscored on Apr 29, 2008 12:31 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Guyton....
according to Scout.com..The Boston Globe reported Monday night that Guyton had signed with the New England Patriots.
http://sfo.scout.com/2/751029.html
I haven’t been on the Globe site to verify this, but more than likely is true. Unless their name is on paper, it’s not a done deal.
I think Butler will push to make the team and don’t be surprised if they play him at WIL Backer
by RJ49erFan on Apr 29, 2008 6:03 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I absolutely love
mashed potatoes.
Sorry guys, I got nothing.
"To know clearly what pleases the world is but a brief dream." --Machiavelli
by jfainsf49 on Apr 29, 2008 6:09 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Cam Colvin
I think Cameron Colvin might have the most upside potentia. If youre unfamiliar with him here is a great article from ESPN
Go Niners.
by MarcDC on Apr 29, 2008 6:29 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Ezra Butler
I decided to google, the UDFA that I’m most excited about and my google toolbar came up with the suggestion of “Ezra Butler marijana”. And apparently it was reported that Ezra said something along the lines of “marijana is part of my diet”. He denied the report but was suspened one game for testing positive. This is what led a bunch of teams to take him off their draft boards. I still like the kid and he’s going to make the team over Robert Jordan and has a decent chance of beating out TBC.
by methodrampage on Apr 29, 2008 8:18 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I hope fooch is right about
jordan (or colvin) making the squad over Morgan. I hate the Morgan draft pick, and wouldve rather seen Colvin and Jordan have a realistic shot of both beeing on the roster, plus another O-lineman, a project QB or another pass rush linebacker project from the 6th round. I guess its not that big of a deal but its really bothering me that we blew a pick on that bum Morgan. I’d like to see Butler and both the receivers make the team. And a guy named Joe John would be fun to have as a 3rd TE/ H-back even though he’s a long shot against Walker and Bajema. I dont remember much of De La Puente from Cal games, but thats a good thing for O-linemen, and we still need depth so I think he’s got a good shot.
by sam23 on Apr 29, 2008 11:08 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Beef?
Just out of curiosity what’s your beef with Morgan? on the field issues? off the field issues? I don’t know anything about the guy except for what has been reported on NN. So what gives bro?
"To know clearly what pleases the world is but a brief dream." --Machiavelli
by jfainsf49 on Apr 29, 2008 11:30 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Nevermind
I took another look at the post about Morgan. Now, I can see why you call him a bum. I figure if a guy is obstructing the cops and getting pepper sprayed then he must have some issues with authority figures. This doesn’t bode well.
"To know clearly what pleases the world is but a brief dream." --Machiavelli
by jfainsf49 on Apr 29, 2008 11:45 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
incidents
Although it sounds like this was a one-time thing with Morgan. I’d rather see Jordan make the squad as a local guy, but I don’t think Morgan is necessarily a bad guy…that could change, but it was only once….
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!
by Fooch on Apr 29, 2008 12:12 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
plus
Morgan is a Hokie. Ugh.
Still defending Rich Aurilia, and the Niners classic Unis
by wjackalope on Apr 29, 2008 12:18 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
second chance
You know now that I think about it, maybe this ain’t such a big deal.
On a personal note, I have a buddy that once ran from the cops. Well, he didn’t actually run, he drove. And he isn’t really a bad guy. I would trust him with my kid, if I had one. This same buddy of mine was also a bad ass linebacker in high school. He signed a letter of intent to play with Iowa, I think. But he blew out his knee and the docters botched his surgery, I think it got infected, not a good situation.
But anyways, I guess my point is that the kid should get a second chance.
"To know clearly what pleases the world is but a brief dream." --Machiavelli
by jfainsf49 on Apr 29, 2008 12:41 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
yea
But he just doesnt sound like someone who has the talent to outweigh even the slightest character questions. IMO if youre gonna draft a 6 foot wideout with poor speed, he better have real good hands, run routes well, and not have any question marks with work ethic or off field issues. poor size-strike one, poor speed-strike two, character issues-strike three. I just think there was still a good deal of talent on the board in the 6th round this year.
by sam23 on Apr 29, 2008 2:28 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
yea to be fair,
I havent seen him play AT ALL. But I see a guy with a lack of height, a lack of game breaking speed, and, even if it was just one incident, serious character issues. I just dont get why you’d blow a pick on a guy like that. Obviously McNolanartz saw something they liked on film, but this sounds like a guy you maybe grab as an UFA. If they wanted a wideout in the 6th why not take a guy like Marcus Monk who has good size and speed? He has Marques Colston written all over him. Fooch it was ONE incident, but the police dont really going around pepper spraying everyone. If we cut Antonio Bryant for being and idiot and not cooperating with the police after his DUI then why blow a pick on a guy who is way less talented but similar police issues?
by sam23 on Apr 29, 2008 2:24 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
McNolanartz
That’s a new one.
"To know clearly what pleases the world is but a brief dream." --Machiavelli
by jfainsf49 on Apr 29, 2008 2:35 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 



















