49ers OL/DL Rankings
I like to poke around the various SB Nation football sites to see what's going on in the rest of the NFL world, and more specifically, to drum up ideas for posts. Over at Dawgs by Nature, they had a post discussing a semi-regular feature over at cbs.sportsline.com. Pete Prisco is doing a feature ranking the different offensive and defensive units around the NFL. While it is just as random as the next guy, I was curious to see what he had to say about the 49ers. While he had some positive points, the rankings are not quite so positive, which shouldn't come as much of a surprise. One drawback to his rankings is that he ranked the teams alphabetically, so it requires a little bit of work to clear things up. Rather than consider all the teams, I'll just throw up the NFC West rankings.
Rating: 30
Best player: LT Joe Staley. Weak link: C Eric Heitmann.
The skinny: They will move Staley from right tackle to the left side. He played the right side as a rookie, but is more of a left tackle. Look for rookie Chilo Rachal to start at guard, although he has worked some at right tackle. The inside people are average at best. Rookie Cody Wallace could challenge Heitmann.
The OL rankings were published on June 2 and he still has Chilo Rachal slated to potentially start at guard. The end of the OTAs will get that whole G/T business cleared up.
NFC West
Seattle: 11
Arizona: 20
St. Louis: 28
Rating: 29
Best player: RE Justin Smith. Weak link: LE Kentwan Balmer or Ron Fields.
The skinny: The 49ers paid a lot for Smith, especially since he had two sacks last season. But they like his toughness. Balmer, the team's first-round pick, should be the starter at the other end spot. Fields will try to fend him off. Nose tackle will be a battle between Aubrayo Franklin and Isaac Sopoaga, who showed well when Franklin was hurt last season. The 49ers need to get more from outside linebacker Manny Lawson, who missed most of last season with an injury. Tully Banta-Cain has quickness on the other side.
Smith has been getting a lot of work at outside linebacker, which would certainly shake this up a little bit. This breakdown was posted today and Prisco is under the impression that Sopoaga will be the nose tackle. And of course there's no mention at all of Ray McDonald, who I see as a sleeper off the bench.
NFC West
Seattle: 7
Arizona: 20
St. Louis: 19
Obviously these are the random rankings of somebody with "insider access." Unfortunately there are enough oversights by Prisco to leave them wide open to questioning. Considering how poorly the units performed at times last year, it's easy to see that carrying over to preseason rankings this year. The offensive line has as much to prove as anybody on this team. The defensive line may take a little time to gell, but I think there is sufficient talent to make them a very interesting unit worth paying attention to going forward.
0 recs |
13
comments
Read Related
Comments
I need to be a sportswriter...
So I can point out that an unheralded rookie will probably be a weak spot for the team, and so that I can include linebackers in my discussion of the D-line.
It’s not that I disagree with his assessment per se, but the methods are shoddy at best.
"Rapport? You mean like, 'You run as fast as you can, and I'll throw it as far as I can'?"
-Jeff Kemp, 49ers quarterback, when asked about his rapport with wide receiver Jerry Rice
by Exhibit G on Jun 4, 2008 11:33 AM PDT 0 recs
Prisco
Good ol’ Prisco, showing that in America, you don’t have to be a good writer to cover sports. CBS Sportsline probably has one of the poorest “analyst” lineups that are available today, at least IMHO.
by sfgfan on Jun 4, 2008 11:48 AM PDT 0 recs
I agree with both of you
I’m sure he thought through some of the higher rankings, but I wonder at what point he did just slow teams in based on record or offensive/defensive rankings and just say “the hell with it” ?
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!
by Fooch on Jun 4, 2008 12:08 PM PDT 0 recs
Practice Speed v. Game Speed
The analysis on rankings is pure speculation based on information Prisco had, and anybody can have good practices or be a good practice player, but we can only gauge the barometer on game days and the end results of each game. I am more interested in rankings over the course of the regular NFL season.
Sometimes we might get suprises as teams contradict individual writers’ rankings on line ups on both sides of the ball, offensive and defensive.
by 16to80endzone on Jun 4, 2008 12:24 PM PDT 0 recs
Prisco and information?
It’s hard to say that Prisco has any “information” to begin with. The guy constantly makes broad assumptions and then draws conclusions based on those assumptions. For example, Balmer and Fields competing as if Fields is the incumbent? Everything a quick Google search away would imply that Fields may be spending more time in the middle while Sopoaga is on the outside with his new shiny contract.
Similarly, general knowledge of the offensive line and how the center position works would tell a person that a first year center drafted in the fourth round has VERY little chance of starting. There’s just too much for a center to know to jump right into the fire. While physically, Heitmann may be (physically) on the decline, but his experience at center is invaluable compared to Wallace’s. It’ll probably be at least a year (or injury) before Wallace will step into the starting lineup.
by sfgfan on
Jun 4, 2008 1:57 PM PDT
up
0 recs
Shoddy
This is the same site currently dedicating the lion’s share of their NFL page to a battle of the mascots. (Which is a totally original idea.)
Speaking of shoddy reporting, did anyone catch NFL.com’s Pat Kirwan reporting on “Offensive Camp Battles”? Apparently, Adam Snyder is fighting for a starting spot against Chilo Rachal (?).
by Nineraguan on Jun 4, 2008 2:50 PM PDT 0 recs
Where's the Smith/Hill/O'Sullivan Offensive Camp Battle?
Doesn’t Kirwin know that there is a 49er offensive camp battle between the three quarterbacks, Smith, Hill, and O’Sullivan? Or he thinks it’s a no-brainer that Smith will win the job, thus it’s not an offensive camp battle?
Nineraguan, maybe you can interpret Kirwin’s thinking?
by 16to80endzone on
Jun 4, 2008 3:13 PM PDT
up
0 recs
I think it's a no-brainer
Like it or not, it’s basically Smith’s job to lose.
by methodrampage on
Jun 4, 2008 3:45 PM PDT
up
0 recs
Much Ado About Nothing
Method, it’s a no brainer then, that it’s Smith’s job to lose, so it’s much ado for nothing over all the talk about the Smith-Hill-O’Sullivan debacle, right?
by 16to80endzone on
Jun 4, 2008 5:05 PM PDT
up
0 recs
I would love to see
KC Joyner’s statistical analysis of how OLs performed last year.
by rufio on Jun 5, 2008 6:41 AM PDT 0 recs















