As the 49ers OC Search Turns
While the 49ers search for an offensive coordinator hasn't quite been a soap opera, it's certainly taken a strange turn. As discussed yesterday, Scott Linehan formally turned down the offer to be the 49ers offensive coordinator. As PFT put it, apparently beggars CAN be choosers.
While I understood the personal reasons for not taking the job, I'd imagine his actions confused the 49ers a little bit. If he decided he didn't want to uproot his family I'm surprised he went through two interviews. While it bugs me a little, there's nothing we can do about it.
Following that disclosure, Mike Singletary released a statement:
"I believe and have faith in the process we have set forth in our search for an offensive coordinator," Singletary said. "While we'd like to fill this position sooner than later, we will remain patient in our approach. The right person for the 49ers is out there."
Seeing as I thought Linehan would have been a great fit (maybe even the "best" fit), I'm feeling a bit conflicted now. When Singletary says the right person is out there, I assume he means that in the sense of who is meant to be in a fate/destiny sort of way. I really don't know if I buy that or not, but clearly the 49ers OC is somewhere out there.
MM indicated that he had no idea what Plan B is. Barrows pointed out that either Clyde Christensen or Rob Chudzinski would be seen as a Plan B, or maybe the team could try to interview someone at the Senior Bowl.
In hiring an offensive coordinator I don't necessarily think a Plan B option will take deep personal offense. They've been through the interview process and sometimes that's how it plays out. In fact, it's possible they would be motivated by such a decision timeline. I know I had at least one experience where I wasn't the first choice, but ended up with the position eventually. At first it seems a little weird, but a job is a job and if a good opportunity comes along, you take it.
As we go forward, there is always the chance of some candidate sitting behind door #3 that we don't know about yet. For now, we'll look at what's left. In the middle of last week, Barrows did a solid run down of the 4 original candidates. Of our remaining two candidates, he said:
Rob Chudzinski
Age: 40
Last/current job: Browns' offensive coordinator
Pros:
- Up-and-coming offensive coordinator who helped resurrect Cleveland's offense in 2007.
- Former tight ends coach whose protégés have flourished in his system
- Might give the 49ers an inside edge on landing a quarterback, Derek Anderson, who can push Hill.
- 49ers could hire Rip Scherer, who worked under Chudzinski as quarterbacks coach.
Cons:
- One-year wonder? Browns faltered badly last season as Chudzinski stuck with Anderson, who was a disappointment.
- System appears to lean heavily on the passing game
- Not a lot of experience as offensive coordinator.
Clyde Christensen
Age: 52
Last/current job: Colts receivers coach
Pros:
- Been a component of a consistently excellent passing attack for the last eight seasons.
- Would mesh well with offensive line coach Chris Foerster; They worked together for eight seasons, first in Tampa Bay and later in Indianapolis.
Cons:
- Spent only one season, 2001 in Tampa, as an offensive coordinator.
- Does not come from a smash-mouth system; Indianapolis ranked 31st in rushing this past season.
The team clearly has no problem taking their time figuring this out, so it's hard to tell how soon we'll have any new info. Could be today, could be next week. One potential mystery candidate (based on pure speculation) is Eagles QB coach Pat Shurmur. His time just freed up quite a bit. Barrows mentioned Shurmur, and a Philly newspaper suggested maybe Steve Spagnuolo would bring him to St. Louis to be the offensive coordinator. So just one more option to ponder.
FOOCH'S NOTE 11:30AM - Apparently Linehan might have turned down the 49ers job for more than just personal reasons. A St. Louis newspaper is reporting he's in the mix for the Buccaneers OC position and possibly the Jets position as well. Glad he was up front about that.
Also, Barrows is indicating the 49ers will expand their search with more interviews in Mobile, Al, during Senior Bowl week.
0 recs |
18 comments
|
Comments
I dont like either of them!
Keeping fingers crossed that they dont SETTLE on either of these guys. Anyone else out there?
by cuse7284 on Jan 19, 2009 12:11 PM PST reply actions 0 recs
How bout a return to the west coast offense
Jon Gruden anyone?
Joe and Steve were under the same system for years... don't expect Smith to be super so soon.
by bayboy on Jan 19, 2009 12:44 PM PST up reply actions 0 recs
Unrealistic List
Here is the unrealistic list for OC’s. If they are on THIS list, DO NOT SUGGEST AS OC AS THERE IS A .0000001 % it actually happens
1. Jon Gruden
2. Mike Shanahan
3. Mike Holmgren
Feel free to add to this list…
by cuse7284 on Jan 19, 2009 1:49 PM PST up reply actions 0 recs
Really unrealistic?
What other coaching positions do you see opening up for Gruden? I doubt the Raiders would consider him.
Joe and Steve were under the same system for years... don't expect Smith to be super so soon.
by bayboy on Jan 19, 2009 2:45 PM PST up reply actions 0 recs
he will take time off
then either coach for some high profile college team or eventually some nfl team
by cuse7284 on Jan 19, 2009 3:06 PM PST up reply actions 0 recs
hahaha
coach for some high profile college team or eventually some nfl team
I can’t see Gruden go backwards, coaching a college team, I think if an NFL position is out there he would probably would like to be considered.
Joe and Steve were under the same system for years... don't expect Smith to be super so soon.
by bayboy on Jan 19, 2009 5:18 PM PST up reply actions 0 recs
rumor has it
notre dame is going to fire weis and hire gruden who has some connects to south bend. Not saying its going to happen but I could see gruden being lured to a major major college program (ie: notre dame)
by cuse7284 on Jan 19, 2009 8:43 PM PST up reply actions 0 recs
oh and by the way
no way he goes backwards and becomes an offensive coordinator. Sorry kid
by cuse7284 on Jan 19, 2009 8:43 PM PST up reply actions 0 recs
The right person is out there.
I think it’s time for desperate measures.
by Rocktopus on Jan 19, 2009 12:33 PM PST reply actions 0 recs
so funny you make that analogy...
in one of my fantasy leagues, there was this huge rules disagreement between two owner clics (about kicker scoring) that turned kind of personal on the league message board. as a way to mediate the matter, the commish put division names up for a league-wide vote. our divisions are now “The eHarmony Division” and the “Match.com Division.”
by Florida Danny on Jan 19, 2009 1:27 PM PST up reply actions 0 recs
of chud and christensen...
…i’d choose neither…though both are obviously accomplished coaches, i don’t think either one has the overall offensive philosophy that singletary is looking for. i suppose if it HAD to be one of the two, the following case could be made for chud:
1) in his first season, CLE’s offense improved from 31st to 11th in offensive efficiency.
2) in ‘07, CLE was actually ranked higher in rush offense efficiency (10th) than pass offense efficiency (13th).
3) most of all — and i haven’t really read this discussed anywhere — he was frank gore’s OC at UM from 2001-2003. in ‘02, he chose gore as the starter over willis mcgahee, but gore blew out his knee in the spring. point is, it would be great if the niners’ OC actually has a time-tested, positive relationship with their best offensive player. i’m guess that gore would be ecstatic with a chud hiring.
finally, i don’t really buy the “chud can make VD better” argument because VD’s best season came under hostler, his worst OC by far. also, with the exception of singletary, VD seems like the only person that can get VD’s head out of VD’s ass. oh, and one other reason…as i alluded to in a comment elsewhere, i’m not much in favor of these guys moonlighting as OC/position coach (OC/QB coach is the only exception). chud would be being hired as the niners’ OC, not TE coach. seeing as how any real effect on the TEs would require a lot of chud’s position-specific coaching time and effort, i’d rather he focus on his jobs as OC and play-caller. i’d prefer the offense to be great overall with a sucking VD than suck overall with a great VD.
by Florida Danny on Jan 19, 2009 1:59 PM PST reply actions 0 recs
is there anyone within the organization that is worth taking a look at for the OC spot
by sundaysfinest on Jan 19, 2009 6:18 PM PST reply actions 0 recs
Heard it on Murph and Mac this a.m.
So I’ll repeat it. Although he’s not a big fan of the way the Yorks run the Niners, and has a number of questions about the current regime, Ira Miller in the wee hours this morning said that when they chose Mike Shanahan as OC back in the nineties, he was their FIFTH choice. Point being that there’s no guarantee that the top pick works out to be the best pick.
Anyway, I was hoping Linehan was chosen just to get the process over with, but Linehan is striking me as a weasel now. If he goes to Tampa or NY his kids are going to have long bus rides if they’re going to stay in the same St. Louis schools.
by Bob On The Coast on Jan 19, 2009 7:53 PM PST reply actions 0 recs

by 





















