Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Miikka Kiprusoff Wins 300th Game, Buffalo Crushes Boston

49ers-Packers: Mike Singletary/Alex Smith post-practice trascripts

The 49ers returned to practice today, and as usual we had post-practice press conferences.  There's nothing too shocking to report, although a few notable comments worth at least discussing.

On the injury front, Glen Coffee will be back.  I'm not sure how big a difference that will make, but it's at least worth mentioning.  Also, Takeo Spikes remains day-to-day, and if he can't go on Sunday Matt Wilhelm would start at the Ted linebacker position.  Spikes had to leave Thursday's game and Wilhelm was quite solid as his replacement, finishing with 5 tackles, including 1 for a loss.

In terms of playing time, it sounds like Isaac Bruce will be playing, but he's definitely fallen down the depth chart.  It sounds like Bruce is now the #4 receivers, although that's not 100% clear.  He's definitely not the 1 or 2 though.  Singletary spoke with Bruce about this and Bruce seemed reasonable about it:

On how Bruce reacted:
"When I talked to Isaac about the change, he was very positive about it. He said, ‘I feel that Josh Morgan is ready. He's ready for this.' He's been working hard, and Isaac has been working with him to get better. I didn't expect anything different from Isaac. He's a class individual, and he's all about the team."

Given his play, I guess there wasn't much else Bruce could do in the situation, but at least he's handling it with a certain level of class.  He has to realize his playing days are quickly coming to an end.  He's a free agent after this season, and while I don't think the 49ers will be re-signing him, I'm curious if he gets any other interest around the league.

The transcript is after the jump...

Star-divide

Head Coach Mike Singletary
Post-Walk Thru - November 17, 2009

San Francisco 49ers

Opening statements:

"As far as the injuries are concerned, [CB] Nate Clements will be out, [LT] Joe Staley will be out. [DT] Demetric Evans will be up. [LB] Takeo Spikes is still day-to-day, and if Takeo can't go, [LB] Matt Wilhelm will start. As you know, [WR] Isaac Bruce will not start. [WR] Josh Morgan will start. So, that's what we're doing there going forward.

[QB] Alex Smith, in terms of our offense right now, I think through everything that our offense has been through, the loss of the tackles, loss of [RB] Frank [Gore] for three-and-a-half weeks and just trying to settle in, Alex Smith playing 14 quarters - I think the offense is continuing to come together, continuing to find its identity right now. You're asking a guy, Alex Smith with 14 quarters, to come out and execute the offense, get the timing down, know the receivers, know the offensive line and then be successful - as well as deal with some of the other things. It's not like he's a rookie. He's been here before to deal with some of negative tone or whatever. Going forward, I think he's handled everything well. I think he's just continuing to take steps forward. I think [offensive coordinator] Jimmy Raye and [quarterbacks coach] Mike Johnson continue to work with him, and good communication and good dialogue going forward. I'm very excited about Alex Smith and what he brings to our offense, and I think going forward, he's going to do just fine.

When you look at the Packers offensively, they're a smart football team. They're a tough football team. They're offensive line is tough. Their running back is a downhill guy, runs tough, and they've got good receivers. The quarterback is playing well, playing smart football. They don't have many turnovers. He hasn't thrown many interceptions - I think five so far. They're doing some good things on offense.

On the defensive side of the ball, it's a very aggressive defense. They really do a good job with the turnovers. I think they're No. 1 in the league with turnovers. Their d-line is very active and come off the ball. Their linebackers are very active. The DBs do a good job. They blitz. [CB] Charles Woodson is having a great year creating turnovers and harassing quarterbacks. It should be a great challenge for us. I'm very excited for the opportunity to go to Lambeau. I'm looking forward to the opportunity."

On whether RB Glen Coffee will be available for the game:

"Yes."

On whether WR Isaac Bruce will be the No. 3 receiver behind Jason Hill:

"As of right now, it depends on what type of package starts. It depends on the package that goes in. We'll see. I know he's not starting. Whether he's No. 3, No. 4 or No. 5, I don't know right now. It just depends on the package."

On whether he's talked to Bruce about the change:

"Yes."

On how Bruce reacted:

"When I talked to Isaac about the change, he was very positive about it. He said, ‘I feel that Josh Morgan is ready. He's ready for this.' He's been working hard, and Isaac has been working with him to get better. I didn't expect anything different from Isaac. He's a class individual, and he's all about the team."

On QB Aaron Rodgers being able to pick apart a defense if given time:

"You're exactly right. He will pick you apart if he has the time, most quarterbacks will. Hopefully, he doesn't have that much time. We're just going to have to continue to play better on the back end, and I think continue to try and put pressure on the quarterback."

On whether the 49ers starting outside linebackers having only 2.5 sacks bothers him or whether he's more interested in pressures:

"I always want to get sacks. You settle for pressures. Sometimes, pressures can be very effective as well. But, I just think those things will come in time. I think, more and more, offenses are doing more max protecting. I just think we just have to continue to have to do a better job there."

On whether he's ever considered starting LB Ahmad Brooks:

"No, not at this point. Ahmad Brooks is continuing to learn the system, continuing to learn how to be a consistent pass rusher. I just think that he's still getting his feet underneath him, but he's coming in and he's coming fast."

On the benefit of having a couple extra days following the Thursday night game:

"I think any time you have an extra day or two for guys to get their legs back underneath them, some of the pounding that they've taken, to heal and use it wisely, I think it can do nothing but help us."

On whether he's talked to the team about playing at Lambeau Field:

"I think the biggest thing that I told our team is we're going on the road, once again, to play a very good football team. It is a tough place to play, but we control some of that. I think it's very important for us to really focus on executing, focus on doing the things that we need to do and let everything else take care of itself. I didn't really talk a whole lot about Lambeau."

On how long he thinks it will take before QB Alex Smith is comfortable:

"I think he's comfortable right now, I really do. I think he's comfortable right now. I just think that the nice thing about where he's at is, first of all, he's a bright guy. Second of all, it's one of those things where the system that we're running is not so different. I think Norv Turner had a lot of similarities to the system that we're running now, so it's not totally different than the Turner system he had good success in. But, I think the thing that's really good for Alex is he's stepping in. He never really got out of the groove, and what I mean by that is he just continued to work. He just continued to work on his own, so when he did get the chance, it's not like he had to shake a lot of rust off. I'm excited about where he's at and the conversations that I have with him going forward are just continuing to ask him what does he need in order to be successful and trying to surround him with those things, whether it's more time, whether it's more detail, whether it's more meeting time, whether it's more route running out here with the wide receivers - just making sure he gets all of the things he needs so that he can feel as comfortable as he can during the game."

On whether he has everything he needs to be successful:

"I don't think you're ever going to have everything you need and you want and all of the other things, but I think that we're listening and trying to provide him with those things. I think he's being very reasonable about what he's asking for. Some of those things you kind of have to pull out of him because he doesn't want to change the offense. He doesn't want to change things around, but at the same time, I continue to reassure him that when I'm asking these questions, I really want the answers so that we can help him all we can."

On the things Smith has asked for:

"First is just a little more detail, getting into the offense and really just going back through some of the things that - we've gone forward here with [QB] Shaun Hill and some of those things. So, it's going back and kind of looking at some of the detail of those things and how that looks for him because when you have one quarterback, you're working with some of the changes that they need, when another quarterback may not need those changes, but they may need something else. So, it's just making sure that you kind of backtrack over those things and make sure that's cleaned up going forward. So, little things like that."

On how he would assess the play of LT Barry Sims:

"Outstanding. It's a pleasant surprise. I think he's done a great job. I'm really excited about what he has been able to bring to that position. I think he's done a phenomenal job."

On whether he would consider leaving Sims in the starting lineup when LT Joe Staley comes back:

"I may consider it, but I don't think it would happen because I think Joe Staley is our left tackle. Unless he comes back, and he's just really not ready or something like that, but Joe Staley is our left tackle."

On whether he would switch Sims to the right side:

"Probably not. [RT Adam] Snyder is doing a good job on that side."

On WR Josh Morgan's play:

"I talked to Josh Morgan the other day and just let him know that I liked what he's doing. I like the progression. I just want to see it faster. I want to see when Josh Morgan and [WR] Michael Crabtree line up, the [the defense] has issues on both sides. It's not, ‘We'll take away one, and you deal with the lesser' because I think Josh Morgan is extremely talented. He's extremely physical. There are just a lot of things that he can do and present a lot of issues for a defense. So, I'm just looking for the time that, and hopefully soon, where he presents a lot of issues over there."

On whether a lack of experience in a passing offense in college is part of Morgan's development;

"Yes it is. It's a difference in being a receiver and being in an offense where you have to be really detailed. Some offenses, the receivers don't have to be as detailed. They're not asked to run specific routes, and I think in our offense, [wide receivers coach] Jerry Sullivan really stresses that. It's extremely important for receivers to be exactly where they're supposed to be because it makes the quarterback better."

QB Alex Smith
Post-Walk Thru November 17, 2009
San Francisco 49ers

On having time off over the weekend:

"Yeah it was kind of nice. I got kind of a mini second bye week."

On what he did with the time off:

"Nothing real eventful. When you are this busy and you finally get your time off, you find that doing nothing sometimes is the most enjoyable thing."

On whether there was any work to be done over the weekend:

"We came in here, but I think for the most part just recovery - getting fresh. We got a jump start on Friday, just to recover and get back to it."

On what he tells the coaches he needs:

"There are different things, little things here and there, things I might think I need or we need. It just kind of depends on the situation. We talk pretty often, so it has been a lot of different things. Nothing real major though. Usually it is small things, whether it be a little extra time this week with the receivers or whatever it might be."

On whether he has ever had a coach ask him what he needs before:

"Not like that, no. I've never had that question posed to me before as far as a quarterback. It kind of makes you think a little bit."

On whether he looks forward to facing QB Aaron Rodgers:

"I do look forward to it. Yeah I have gotten to know Aaron since then. I got to know him throughout that whole year with the college stuff, the awards and the draft process. I have stayed in touch with him since then. I had the opportunity to play them a couple of times in preseason and the regular season. Yeah, I look forward to it. Through all that process, Aaron was a great guy. I appreciated that when we were going through all that competition and things got hyped up and worked up, he never seemed liked it ever got to him. It didn't change him."

On playing at Lambeau Field:

"This is my first time going, so I look forward to it. There is a handful of places now I have never been and this is one of them. I look forward to it and I am excited for it. I have heard a lot about it."

On Rodgers' career:

"I think he is doing a great job there. I think he has done some really good things. I look at their offense and what they are doing. I think they give a lot of problems to defenses. They spread people out, they have a lot of weapons and he takes advantage of it. So of the little I've seen, you don't get to study many offenses, I think he is playing well."

On whether he knew how far Rodgers slipped on Draft Day in 2005:

"I didn't find out until a little later what was going on. It's a long process, the first round takes forever. So you are kind of doing the circuit then getting filled in about what was going on, who went where. So yeah, a little bit."

On whether he felt bad for Rodgers:

"No question, to be back there in the green room is uncomfortable. Every single pick, there is a camera sitting on you seeing your reaction, and to have to sit there that long would be really difficult I would imagine."

On whether he feels that in some way he is competing with Rodgers:

"I don't. I understand that we will forever be connected because of that. But I don't at all feel like I am competing with him in that sense. I am competing with him to win the game on Sunday. But I put the statistics and all that stuff aside, I'm not paying any attention to it."

On whether he thinks about how things would have turned out if the 49ers selected Rodgers:

"Who knows what would have happened? I don't really think about that. There are a million different scenarios you could probably play out that could have happened if things went differently. But this is the way it went and here we are meeting up five years later. We have both taken different routes, but I look forward to it."

On the differences between his and Rodgers' journey:

"I haven't spoken to him about that. The few times I have had to see him and talk to him over the years has been pretty quick. It would be interesting to talk to him about it. We both have taken very different routes to get to where we are now."

On whether Rodgers has told him what it was like to play behind Brett Favre:

"I haven't talked to him about that. I haven't. Most of our conversations have been pretty quick, a little, ‘How are you doing?' I didn't get into things like that."

On Green Bay's defense:

"They are playing really well. They played really well on Sunday against the good offense that Dallas has. I think they are a good test for us. I think they are strong across the board. I don't think there is a standout position group that is playing better than others, I think they are all playing well. They are stout up front, the linebacking corps is playing really well, they have a lot of depth there, and they are a really veteran group in the secondary. They make a lot of plays. I think they lead the NFL in takeaways, so I think it will be a really good test for us."

On whether he has to focus extra on his accuracy this week:

"I guess you always hope to be precise and accurate. I think it goes more into the decision making, if that makes sense. You have to be very sharp about your decision making, where you are going with the football, what you are doing against what they present, because they do present a lot of different looks. You have to be able to make decisions and then it comes down to throwing the ball."

On WR Josh Morgan starting:

"It is a great opportunity for Josh and I am excited for him. He always works extremely hard. He worked extremely hard this offseason and worked hard last year to get to where he is. I think he has improved a tremendous amount. This is a big opportunity for him and it's a big opportunity for us. I feel really good about Josh being out there."

On how much time he has spent throwing to Morgan:

"Not a ton of time. I missed last year, but all this offseason he was here and we worked out quite a bit. We went through camp together, and obviously now we are in whatever week we are in the season. So we had a little bit of work."

On the importance of chemistry with the receivers:

"It is crucial. I think it is crucial to any offense to have that trust between each other that he is going to be where he is supposed to be and I am going to put that ball where it is supposed to be and that it is going to work out. You have to have that trust and you have to be accountable to each other. I think that is vital to any passing game."

On the development of WR Michael Crabtree:

"He just continues to keep working. I think every week he is here he is just going to keep getting better and better. He has still only been here a short time when you think about it, but he has so many tools. I think he is a very gifted player. I think he has a very natural feel for the game. So I think it is just going to get better and better for him."

On whether he feels comfortable throwing jump balls to Crabtree and Morgan:

"I feel real good with all our guys, but those two have a great feel for the ball. They are competitive when the ball is in the air. They are both big-body guys who catch the ball with their hands. So yeah, I definitely feel good about that."

On developing an identity on offense:

"I think it will always be like that over the course of a season. You are going to have cycles and go through things - things you are doing well and things you aren't - when you are finding out who you are. You want to set that identity to a certain extent, but it kind of evolves as you go along. You continue to adjust it to the personnel you have and the things we are doing well."

On the advantages of running out of the shotgun:

"I think it helps us at least present a balanced formation to the defense. Traditionally thinking, when you line up in the shotgun, it is predominantly pass, so to be able to run the ball out of the shotgun at least allows us to stay balanced."

On his input to the coaches during games:

"If something came to me, I would definitely have the freedom to say it. Usually, I don't really think like that though. I am busy playing. I don't really think like a coordinator, per se, or something like that. I don't always have the best view. Sometimes when you are out there, things look differently. If I do see things I definitely say them. I don't hesitate to say them, but I don't know how much of that actually goes on."

On the play of T Barry Sims and how coach Singletary has said he's playing outstanding:

"I think just that, he stepped right in and hasn't missed a beat. He has played really well. That's hard to do, come in and play left tackle in this league where you are getting matched up every week against big-time pass rushers, and to play the way he has, has been great. I don't think twice back there, I trust those guys up front."

Comment 29 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Coach must not be watching the same games we are
On whether he would switch Sims to the right side:

“Probably not. [RT Adam] Snyder is doing a good job on that side.”

I don’t think Bruce comes back. It was my understanding that he wanted to retire at the end of last year but we asked him to stay for one more year. Is that not correct?

by smileyman on Nov 17, 2009 4:18 PM PST reply actions  

Team invited Bruce back if he wanted to come back.

by bignerd on Nov 17, 2009 4:21 PM PST up reply actions  

Bruce, at this time in his career...

Can still make a play or two and is great to have on the sidelines helping the young guys.

by Natural Red on Nov 17, 2009 4:36 PM PST reply actions  

Bruce's Mentoring Sessions

Reportedly consist of watch me and do what I do (supposedly because that’s what he did). He did not seem interested in passing out sage advice to the Baby-niners.

Looking to put San Fran*six-o* here some time soon!

by dartdart on Nov 18, 2009 1:11 PM PST up reply actions  

If Bruce doesn't retire

I could see him trying one more time with New England. Their Joey Galloway experiment didn’t work out but they really like bringing in vets to play roles and with Bruce’s reliable route running he’d actually compliment Moss and Welker really well, plus he’d get a shot at a super bowl over there.

by foosball4949 on Nov 17, 2009 4:56 PM PST reply actions  

Come on Alex.. !! We are not naive!!

“I don’t think twice back there, I trust those guys up front.” Yea? Then why are you always running for your life or throwing the ball either out of bounds or to the dump off guy in the flat? If you are that comfortable, sit back there and throw a dart downfield and get the team moving (I’m kidding of coarse, you will get KILLED if you stand back there too long).

I just hope for week to week improvements in the Offensive Line. That is where the Niners win or lose games. We have a good defense. We have good talent at receiver, running back, and even a serviceable QB. But the Offensive Line will either play well or play badly. There doesn’t seem to be any in between for this unit. And lately it has been more poor play than good play. The 5 linemen that go out there on Sunday really have to give it their ALL for the Niners to have a shot at winning the game. If Alex gets sacked or pressured too often, that will be the difference. I have confidence in our defense as long as they are not put into bad positions with turnovers or poor special teams play. We need the offense to move the ball and let the defense catch their breath!!! We need to keep Green Bay’s offense off the field as much as possible because they will score if given enough attempts. We can WIN this game in Green Bay, but it all depends on the 5 guys in the trench for the Offense. They will be the reason, whether it is victory or failure. I know there are no all stars or pro bowlers on our offensive line. But we need them to play like a cohesive unit. They need to do their JOBS! If they don’t , then the Niners lose and the rest of the season will be talent evaluation time…

Another year, another chance to hope for the team !!

by FaStRmAn on Nov 17, 2009 5:22 PM PST reply actions  

Yeah its pretty much do or die right about now for us

49ers Al Grito De Guerra!!! hahaha

by 49erSalvatrucha on Nov 17, 2009 5:26 PM PST up reply actions  

rec'd

Yes rlott#42, Crabtree...needs to hold onto the ball

by 10forTech on Nov 17, 2009 9:22 PM PST up reply actions  

Yea, it's do or die

But you have to admit that they are playing better than last year by FAR! I went to the Titan’s game with my son and you could just feel the air getting SUCKED out of the stadium. The FANS were so hyped before the game and it just slipped away…. This is a young team with a patchwork offensive line. If they are going to make a run, this is where they have to draw a line in the sand. The Packers are not world beaters. The Niners need to shock the world and just go into Lambeau and WIN. It’s as simple as that. If they win, they earn the right to have hope for one more week. If they lose, no excuses are necessary. It will be over. Many think the Titan’s game was the end, but I saw no quit in the team. They just ran into a buzzsaw in Vince Young, who played great and continues to play great. The Niners need to just line up and smash Green Bay in the Mouth. Dominate them PHYSICALLY. Impose their will on them, whatever cliche you want to use. Our Defense can throw haymakers. The offense has to be willing to FIGHT for survival. Not maintain ball security or manage the game well! The need to take shots! They need to try halfback options.

   They need to let it all hang out on Sunday and get a win any way they can. There are no shameful victories in the NFL. There are "W"’s and "L"’s. The NINERS NEED A “W” at the end of the day on Sunday or the whole season becomes a “L”. The Offensive line, who has taken most of the season off, has to earn their checks on Sunday, no matter how they do it. Just do their job and no penalties or turnovers. Even if we win by one point, the Niners will shock the world if they win that game in Minnesota. Every analyst has written them off. The talking heads at ESPN and CBS have written them OFF. Everyone has written them off but Singletary, and those 5 guys in the trench on the offensive line Sunday. They need to play like they want to win the game. There are no pro bowlers or allstars on that unit. AS a UNIT, they have to come up with the game of the YEAR on offense. Smith can throw, Gore can run. Crabtree, Morgan, Davis, and Hill can catch. The only question mark is those 5 guys that most of us cant even name because of all the injuries. They have to find a way to get their JOB DONE. Give Smith time to throw the medium out pattern. Open Holes for Gore to sprint thru. Do the Job they signed up for!

  To this point, The Offensive line has been stealing. They must have had to back up to the pay window or hide their faces on payday. On SUNDAY, they have to go out there in the Frozen Tundra that is Green Bay in November and play that one game as a cohesive, effective, and even a little angry group of men. Real men that live up to their promises. Real Men that do their jobs to the best of their abilities! It’s all or nothing baby! Leave it on the field Sunday, or dont even suit up.

  I contend if the Offensive Line can play a mediocre game, the Niners will WIN. They are backed into a corner. The players at the talent positions are all healthy. The Defense is ready to have something to DEFEND. HOW ABOUT A LEAD! How about the Offense puts up early points! Doesn’t matter HOW they do it. Screens, smoke routes, hook and ladders, I DONT CARE! GIVE that Defense a LEAD to protect!! They will play like the unit that held Minnesota down and the unit that kept Paton Manning out of the endzone! It is all up to those 5 guys in front of the QB. Are they MAN ENOUGH? Can they step up for even ONE GAME? Can they play for an entire game without giving up a SACK! There are offensive lines that do that you know! Can Alex Smith have one afternoon where he is NOT running for his life? Where he is looking downfield for the big play instead of looking straight up into the sky lying on his back again? Can the Niners passing game start clicking by giving the QB the time to do his JOB?

5 MEN. I bet you cant even name them. I am a fan and I cant. Those 5 men are the difference between a win and another lost season. GO DOWN FIGHTING! We need to see 5 guys helping each other get the job done! LEAVE IT ON THE FIELD OR DONT SUIT UP!! I’m rooting for ya !!

Another year, another chance to hope for the team !!

by FaStRmAn on Nov 17, 2009 5:59 PM PST reply actions  

Fasterman:
You can’t even name the 5 starting O linemen for the Niners???
I call that a casual fan,not a diehard fan.
But anyway,it takes two to tango. Even if the O line plays great it still takes a QB that won’t turn the ball over and who can take advantage of the time he gets from the line. So far Alex has NOT been that guy. Here’s hoping he can get a bunch better real fast !

by TOP_CAT on Nov 17, 2009 7:03 PM PST reply actions  

My Statements

There is some substance to giving a veteran and future hall of famer a longer leash but with the way Bruce has been playing it has just hurt our team too much. Not just on his lack of separation on routes and dropped passes but also his blocking, which is incredibly surprising.

          I am also surprised with the way Barry Sims has been playing since taking over for Joe Staley. Starting with containing Dwight Freeney against Indianapolis and then up against Chicago last week. Green Bay and Jacksonville’s pass rush is decent but nothing really to write home about so i think he will continue it. This is a big change considering many of us wondered why he was on the roster just a couple weeks ago.

           Regarding Crabtree i am happy that the 49ers have made a major attempt to make him a true #1 receiver this early, but they cannot forget about Vernon Davis either. Both must be a focal point in the passing game with Gore, Morgan and Hill becoming secondary targets. I do like Josh Morgan over Isaac Bruce at this point, i also like Jason Hill over him as well. But lets be honest the two best targets are Crabs and VD. I look for a breakout game from the rookie receiver soon if not against Green Bay then next week against Jacksonville.

           I am also glad they took my opinion and ran out of the shotgun more. Gore had some nice runs in the formation and if we continue it this will not only give Smith more time to pass and make him more comfortable but it will allow our offensive formations to confuse the defense with that run/pass option

"Cannot play with them. Cannot win with them. Cannot coach with them. Can't do it. I want winners. I want people that want to win!!!"

by nocal81(Vincent) on Nov 17, 2009 7:14 PM PST reply actions  

On Bruce

He has to realize his playing days are quickly coming to an end

Is this really a product of his deteriorating skills/abilities, or is it just a product of not having a QB that can deliver him the ball? The last time I checked, which was early in the season, Matt Maiocco pointed out that Bruce can still run all the routes. I don’t have all the game film in front of me, but I’m willing to say that there’s a lot of truth to this. Is he the fastest/strongest/most athletic guy on the team? No. It’s not even close. Is his body slowing down due to age? Sure. But does that necessarily take away from his ability to run precise routes and actually catch the ball with consistency (I’m still waiting Josh….)? Many fans would probably say, no. If this is more about blocking, well… I can’t see how you can make a strong argument there considering the o-line is the main reason why the run game has suffered.

Looking at this from a different perspective, however, it sure looks as though Singletary has caught on to this “youth movement” thingy. You would think that after the miscues from Morgan this season (e.g. the dropped deep ball from Shaun Hill against St. Louis, which he claimed was coming down like a punt… all excuses of course; the poor effort in taking it to the house against Atlanta after the missed tackle; the dropped balls thrown right at him, one of which bounced off his hands and into a defenders’) he’d be leaning more towards the saavy veteran, Bruce.

If Singletary wants to make a change to the receiving depth, how about upgrading Jason Hill to the #2 spot? The man has been great on special teams, and he has produced when given the opportunity. He gets playing time against Tennessee, and he scores 2 TDs. And this isn’t even taking into consideration what he was able to do at the end of last season. Perhaps Singletary forgot that he was the recipient of many Shaun Hill passes? It sure seems like a no brainer at this point: Crabtree at the 1, Hill at the 2. Force Morgan to ‘step’ up his game…

Still, I have a better one! How ’bout giving this Brandon Jones guy a snap or two? Where the hell is that guy anyway? Before he even gets a shot at running routes on consecutive plays, the guy is out there returning punts? Good thinking Singletary. Great way to use the guy you and your staff signed during the offseason. What was the reasoning behind that signing? Oh right, it was to provide that “deep threat”.

Can you guys tell I’m disappointed in Morgan? Y’all should be disappointed as well. I just hope he produces. There are no excuses this time.

by Waiting4JoshMorgan on Nov 17, 2009 9:30 PM PST reply actions  

Blocking From A Receiver Is Different Then The O-Line

Usually receivers are blocking on the outside or further down the field. On occasions i have seen Bruce miss blocks that would have sprung Gore on a screen or other receivers down field. The has nothing to do with the o-line

"Cannot play with them. Cannot win with them. Cannot coach with them. Can't do it. I want winners. I want people that want to win!!!"

by nocal81(Vincent) on Nov 17, 2009 10:07 PM PST up reply actions  

I understand fully

Blocking is “different” for receivers and the o-line. I guess the point I was just trying to make there was that Bruce’s so-called inability to put up a decent block, or at least get the in way, should not be “a” reason for benching him over Morgan. The line is the first wall that backs have to get through, and if you can’t get through it consistently (which has been the case for the 49ers all season), than the issue shouldn’t be with the wideout’s inability to block.

On occasions i have seen Bruce miss blocks that would have sprung Gore on a screen or other receivers down field

Fans make these statements all the time, but they don’t provide visual evidence. I’m a sucker for visual evidence here. I’m sure you’re right about that, but there also were occasions where Bruce did a good job springing Gore for a big run. See the two big runs he had against Seattle at NFL.com. Under search engine. Type Frank Gore and click on the video. If he didn’t pick up his man on both occasions, Gore’s big runs would not have happened, and the 49ers probably lose…

thanks for the response.

by Waiting4JoshMorgan on Nov 18, 2009 5:51 PM PST up reply actions  

Bruce is done

His numbers are much worse than Morgan’s this year, and it’s not like Morgan has been a stud so far.

by Brendan Scolari on Nov 18, 2009 2:51 AM PST up reply actions  

Holy smokes.

I enjoy reading the posts that you contribute to 49ersnation, but man oh-man, you couldn’t be more wrong about this.

Numbers?

Morgan: 9 games, 23 catches for 300 yards, 1TD (could have been three if not for the drop against St. Louis and the horrible effort of running after the catch against Atlanta… sure makes you question his abilities and focus?)
Bruce: 8 games, 20 catches for 244 yards, 0TD

Unless my eyes are deceiving me, or there’s some sort of glitch on yahoo sports, I’d say there numbers are very similar.

by Waiting4JoshMorgan on Nov 18, 2009 5:58 PM PST up reply actions  

I was talking more about their advanced numbers, rather than just raw statistics

Morgan is 47th out of 82 qualifying WR’s in DVOA, Bruce is 75th. Morgan has a decent 58% catch rate while Bruce has a 44% catch rate, one of the worst in the league. Morgan has been a decent receiver when the ball has been thrown his way, Bruce has been awful.

by Brendan Scolari on Nov 18, 2009 6:33 PM PST up reply actions  

And Crabtree is ranked even lower

Never mind he is by far the 49ers best WR.

by bignerd on Nov 18, 2009 7:28 PM PST up reply actions  

Actually, your wrong

Crabtree is ahead of Bruce in DVOA and ahead of both Bruce and Morgan in catch rate, so I’m not sure what your talking about. He’s also had a pretty small sample size compared to Bruce and Morgan and his numbers are inordinately affected by the fact that he fumbled in that small sample size. So if this was another attempt to make a jab at any advanced statistic someone brings up, you failed.

by Brendan Scolari on Nov 18, 2009 9:01 PM PST up reply actions  

Maybe I’m reading their tables wrong but Crabtree is ranked 43rd out the 50 WR ranked with 6 – 31 passes? His DOVA score is -26.2%, slightly ahead of Bruce at -30.1%.

by bignerd on Nov 19, 2009 12:09 AM PST up reply actions  

I'm not sure what "6" your referring to

But he does have a -26.2% DVOA so far, which is of course better than Bruce’s -30.1%.

by Brendan Scolari on Nov 19, 2009 2:14 AM PST up reply actions  

DVOA

You may be reading too much into that DVOA thing, especially in evaluating a wideout. Comparing Bruce and Morgan using this system might not be the most effective. I’d much rather make the comparison based on what I’ve seen on gameday, and from what I’ve seen, Bruce is still the better route runner and catcher.

Often times, those percentages presented to football outsiders, or fans, don’t tell the whole story. Kinda like that quarterback rating thingy. Does the “catch rate” also take into account the accuracy of the ball being thrown? Or is it one of those things where ANY ball thrown that lands, say 5 yards, from the receiver is counted as part of the catch rate?

If there is A LOT of truth to this DVOA thing, than I suppose you’re right, Bruce has been awful. I don’t, however, give this system of grading wide receivers a whole lot of credibility and legitimacy.

Some fans have been clamoring for more Jason Hill. I wonder what his DVOA is.

Thanks for the response, and sorry for the late response. School is always in front of me.

by Waiting4JoshMorgan on Nov 28, 2009 1:29 AM PST up reply actions  

Hopefully play Hill some more. I think he can be really good would be a nice three wr set with Crabtree, Morgan, and Hill

49ers Al Grito De Guerra!!! hahaha

by 49erSalvatrucha on Nov 18, 2009 9:14 AM PST up reply actions  

Does anyone else kinda DISagree

that Snyder has “done a good job at right tackle”?

Is it that Simms can’t play RT as well or what is between the lines here? The kid has a big confidence boost handling guys at LT. If he can play RT…put him in. Lord knows we need it. Then we can go back to seeing if Rachal or Snyder does better at RG. IIRC Snyder told Sing that he was confident he could handle the spot if given the chance to own it all to himself.

by Tre9er on Nov 18, 2009 7:11 AM PST reply actions  

Kinda disagree?

I think only Adam Snyder and his mom agree.

by bignerd on Nov 18, 2009 3:26 PM PST up reply actions  

Props to Bruce...

…for such a classy reaction.

by Bigmouth on Nov 18, 2009 11:01 AM PST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Media Requests please email ninersnation@gmail.com

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Ohmygoshilovemiguelxd-1_small
What the 49ers Should Do This Offseason
Frog_small
Official Draft NN Draft Thread

Recent FanPosts

Small
On Dashon Goldson
Images_small
Official Community Thread [2/9/2012] I hate pet peeves
Small
We didn't suck, so we don't need Luck.
Small
Have not heard this QB scenario
Small
49ers Season in a nutshell
Riceprofile_small
Where is the faith in Chilo Rachal?
Small
If Peyton Manning is a free agent, do the 49ers go after him?
Small
Potential QB Draft Targets

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Head Ball Coach

Dave_small David Fucillo

Howtheyscoredcat_small howtheyscored

313483_2054510893373_1562580382_31984672_1965025_n_small James Brady

Coordinator

Pirates_small smileyman

Bowman_avi_sm_small Tre9er

Assistant Coach

Pixies_logo_small (Florida) Danny Tuccitto

Memento-lies_small urnext

Me_on_beach_small WesHanson

P_willy_america_small Dylan DeSimone

Officiating Crew

Jackalope_card_small wjackalope

These3words_small these3words

San-francisco-49ers-helmet-logo-©photofile_small LondonNiner

Joe_and_bill_small twolfe2

Images_small mcwagner

Thecatch3_small mikeinsp