Mike Singletary Approval Rating, Week 12
We return for week 12 of the Mike Singletary Approval Ratings, which have been zig-zagging quite a bit lately. If the 49ers can't find some consistency soon, we might just finish out the year up and down in the ratings. After putting up 88% in week 10, following the win over Chicago, Singletary's rating dropped to 61% last week after an abysmal loss to the Packers. Over at ESPN, Coach Singletary's rating has risen from 72% last week to 87% this week. What I continue to find so amazing is that Mike Singletary has garnered more total votes (18,372 yeas and nays) than the other three NFC West coaches combined (16,283). I wonder if it's name recognition, or just the passion of 49ers fans?
In last week's approval rating post I asked whether Mike Singletary was driving the offensive philosophy and how that was going to play out in terms of the smash mouth football and opening things up offensively. We certainly got an answer Sunday on the field, then again after the game, and one more in Mike Singletary's press conference yesterday. After last week's lost at Green Bay, we heard comments by Vernon Davis and Michael Crabtree about putting more of a spread look into the offense. They felt this gave the team the most success. Yesterday, I think we learned a lot about the way this team operates, and also the way Mike Singletary really runs things.
Singletary mentioned how some of the players had approached them about ideas for the offense. Singletary listened to them and then told them to tell that to Jimmy Raye because Raye was the man with ownership over the offense as a whole. As Singletary put it in his press conference:
The guys just basically said, ‘Coach, this is what we like. I think this would help.' The thing that I have been talking about all year is ownership. When you talk about ownership, that is a huge word, it comes with a lot of responsibility. If you are willing to ask for something, if you are willing to come up with a solution, then it is on you to make sure that you carry through with that. That's what leadership is.
...
"I have always believed all of my life that if someone has something to say, be man enough to convey it. Don't come to me and tell me, ‘Coach, I don't like this; I don't like that. Jimmy is doing this; he is doing that.' That's not going to fly. All that is going to do is get me upset because that concerns me that you are not man enough to do that. The most important thing to me is we have 53 men, not a bunch of boys, not a bunch of guys sitting in there waiting for something to happen.
Just reading Singletary's words does not always convey the meaning behind them. If you have never watched a Mike Singletary press conference, I recommend checking out yesterday's. Every week I hear that man speak, I am simply amazed. I'm convinced he could convince players to walk through fire for him. While he may have his issues with Xs and Os and game management, Singletary seems to have the leadership aspect of coaching down fairly well.
96 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Voted yes!!
I don’t know who voted no but damn come on now were playing better over all. Big improvement, bring on the chicken hawks!!!
For the first time in his tenure
I give Singletary a vote of approval.
by whistlingmountain on Dec 1, 2009 7:35 AM PST reply actions
though I should say
I still don’t think Singletary is a good long-term coach, but the way he coached the past two weeks, I approve of.
by whistlingmountain on Dec 1, 2009 8:43 AM PST up reply actions
I support Sing
but I can see where some people might be concerned.
No doubt he’s a great motivator, but his game planning skills have yet to be proven. The team played horribly after its 2 bye weeks (vs ATL and the half-bye against GB) and some people have pointed to lack of game-planning.
If it’s actually that or just execution, who knows?
Another point can be made that he doesn’t seem to know his personnel very well (the very knock on Martz last year) by insisting on a smash-mouth running team when the team isn’t talented enough to run consistently.
But I think Singletary will be a good head coach because he’s shown flexibility. For all the talk of sticking to the run and “not changing,” Singletary has not been afraid to change.
He will be a very successful coach if he can surround himself with talented game-planners (can Raye and Manusky be that? We will see.)
If Sing showed flexiblity...
During the OC search, the offense may not have been a problem to begin with.
Well, we're waiting....
something else to consider
who other than Gore had ANY measurable success in the NFL prior to this season? The guys who are speaking up now are guys who are making a lot of positive plays, and in Alex and VD’s case, getting the ball into the end zone.
Why would the coaches have listened much to the guys who haven’t been successful?
Flexibility will get you Nolaned
He was able to watch that process closer than a coach from the outside looking in. He will not let his long term plan out in the media, we still don’t know if Sing just wants to use the digit system and have M Johnson be the long term OC during his tenure. If he can get these ladies to want to win this badly and have a better season than last with the same team, I am all for it. I guess your pessimism is ridonculous.
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
WAT..
Wasn’t Raye like the 7th OC to interview for the job after the other candidates said “No thanks” due to Singletary’s idea of what the offense should be?
That’s why you hire an HC who knows offense.
Well, we're waiting....
Singletary aced a few candidates because he was looking for an OC, not a guy looking for a quick transition to HC.
I’m not disappointed in the Singletary hire. Offensive coaches like to bring in “their guys”, like JTO. Singletary isn’t going to win the X’s and O’s but he has manged to pull all those meager 49ers 1st rounds picks up by the boot straps and turn then into somewhat functional football players. Really that had to happen before this team was going anywhere.
We would have already started Jeff Garcia 3 games beginning in Week 4 and he’d also already be cut from the team. Also, the team would be 5 games away from the Tebow era.
What was that?...
I hear that Raiders going to the playoff’s and Tampa’s first Super Bowl win thingy against the team he built in the Raiders.
Do you hear that too, or is that out of your earshot?
Well, we're waiting....
Gruden..
had success but that crap he pulled last year was just ridiculous…
Tampa issues are bigger than Gruden. Yes, I was referencing above that Gruden was getting a bit weird there at the end.
Yeah when you have 3 to 5 seasons to get one there should have at least been one in place
Especially if you are suppose to be a qb COACH
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
Gruden won a Super Bowl...
with Brad Johnson at QB.
BTW, the Raiders haven’t down anything since he left, and TAM is a cool 1-10 this season.
Well, we're waiting....
Tampa’s 1-10 because of an FO decision to dismantle the whole ship. Gruden left as part of that.
It’s a little weird, I guess… but Gruden was sent packing so the team could be horrible (i.e. rebuild). The team isn’t horrible because Gruden is gone.
I don't know about that, to the groin.
by howtheyscored on Dec 2, 2009 8:19 AM PST up reply actions
A HC with no QB that has the authority to get one is a good HC?
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
They were plummiting with him
He was fired, he didn’t quit
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
Gruden took over a team on the cusp of a Superbowl
Added a veteran QB and got a Superbowl, then that team went spiraling down into oblivion.
You don’t know jack
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
Makes no sense
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
What is spelled with an h after the W and before the a.
Funny thing is you don’t have a clue as to what Singletary’s idea of an offense is. You hire the best man for the job each job is different. I bet you’d love to have Shanahan!!
(setup)
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
I don't think coaches who do not scheme at least one side of the ball
Are good long-term coaches. Too much coordinator turnover in the league.
by whistlingmountain on Dec 1, 2009 2:25 PM PST up reply actions
Your comments are just clueless pessimism
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
Hey look...
riot thinks he is trolling a different SBNation blog.
BTW, I can’t get too excited over Singletary getting out of the way and not meddling in the offense, after a win. That kind of means what he wanted to do wasn’t working.
Well, we're waiting....
It appears as though
Sing was able to suck up some pride and let the Niners be who are and not forcing them to be something they are not, all is good for now
With regard to the offensive philosophy
While I think they decided to open it up a little more, I don’t think this was the beginning of a full-on spread attack every game. I think that for once they decided to aggressively go after the opponent’s weakness rather than cautiously play to not lose.
That was the change. Not passing, running, but being aggressive and not playing scared.
I have to say:
I’m extremely glad that you used the word “regard” correctly. You get, like, 25 Howie points for that.
I don't know about that, to the groin.
by howtheyscored on Dec 1, 2009 8:59 AM PST up reply actions
You are.
I don't know about that, to the groin.
by howtheyscored on Dec 1, 2009 9:24 AM PST up reply actions
No, but I do like the cut of your jib.
I don't know about that, to the groin.
by howtheyscored on Dec 1, 2009 9:25 AM PST up reply actions
off topic
i just ordered a crabtree jersey but then my friend told me he doesn’t think crabtree will be a niner next season. Is that possible? I thought he signed a 6 year deal?
It’s not possible. Your friend is screwing with you.
I don't know about that, to the groin.
by howtheyscored on Dec 1, 2009 9:16 AM PST up reply actions
Loophole?
I heard that after 2 or 3 years he could technically get out of his contract, which seems to be common in the NFL.
5 years
If he makes the probowl twice before his contract is up the 6th year is voided.
There are some other conditions, but only the 6th year can be voided.
He’ll be a 49er for at least 5 years (unless he holds out for a new contract)
Personally I’m more concerned with Vernon Davis’ contract situation.
It seems as if he wants to be in SF, but how much would it cost to keep him here?
This is especially troubling since they still have to sign 2 first round draft picks next year plus they have to extend Patrick Willis too.
What we've got here is a failure to communicate.
by SportsChicken on Dec 1, 2009 9:50 AM PST up reply actions
I don't see why VD would leave
he seems to love playing for Singletary, and the Niners have been very good about paying their players. Plus, he’s getting a big role in the offense.
For all the fuss about the front office, I think Scot M. has been very good about cap space.
I guess, though, an enormous contract from another team can change all that.
I understand
however I totally get why players do it because they don’t have any job security whatsoever. A team can dump them just about whenever they want, so the only guarantees they really have is their signing bonuses and any guaranteed money on their contract.
Me first?
Hey give your body up for this contract to play with my team, hey they want me to do the same but will pay me more GUARANTEED money. So if I get hurt for my career I will get more from them. WOW some fans don’t get it.
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
why do we celebrate players who take paycuts?
or “restructure” their deals? we call them real team players and such. that’s my point. I get where they are coming from. I’m just saying if it’s ALL about the money…that’s a little selfish…especially if it’s close.
Besides, tell me that the millions already in the bank aren’t enough to survive on? It’s not about “securing their future” it’s about maintaining a posh lifestyle in many cases…
To play with his brother
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
Eagles just came to an agreement with TE Brent Celek
33 million over 6 years, 11 million guaranteed.
Davis will be along those numbers and as valuable as he is to our offense I’d say that’s reasonable.
I would have resigned him for 7 years already
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
I'm glad...
… the coaching staff is finally showing a bit of openmindedness. For a while, as I stated somewhere before, I was beginning to believe that Singletary/Raye were going to continue to force the run issue. I’m glad they showed this past weekend that they have the confidence in Alex Smith to try to put the game on his shoulders some, instead of placing it all on Gore.
Last week may be an aberration (as the Jags pass defense is pretty bad), but I’m hoping the coaching staff continues to spread the burden of winning a game to the QB and WRs more.
Whatever it takes
I think Sing, Raye and pretty much the core of the coaching staff and even the players are apparently getting on the same page now and adopting a common objective to use what they have in the best way possible (isn’t this what is commonly called “gelling”?) The next two weeks are going to be the biggest tests of the season, so we should know by then if things have truly come together.
Air Raye approval rating?
If it is not created I just want to say that I now approve of Air Raye.
What we've got here is a failure to communicate.
A little early but...
Is NN going to start going into contracts and stuff for our playmakers? Only been on the site for a few months so am not sure when you start talking about it. Or if you have and i just missed it. I would like an in depth list of who we could possibly loose this year if we dont pay them enough. Oh by the way I have and and still support Mike.
I think...
…. contracts, free agents, and draft stuff will come in full force once the season is over. Some discussion has already started in the FanPost section with “official” NN posts, but nothing like it’ll be once the offseason starts. I can definitely see more discussion about those topics creeping in if the 49ers are eliminated from playoff contention, too.
Singeltary's coaching career is much like his playing one
He (by his own admission) was never the greatest athlete or the most talented player on the field. He earned his way through hard work and determination and that thing they call heart. He’s clearly doing the exact same thing as a coach. As a rookie coach right now he seems to be a bit a of a mid-round rookie who shows a lot of promise but clearly hasn’t polished his game to NFL levels yet. I’m intrigued to see where he goes…
This.
When discussions happen about how difficult it is for great players to become great coaches, largely due to their inability to realtet o players who have to work hard to just be good, I think people forget that Sing was not some natural where everything came easy to him. He was a very good talent who made himself into a great HOF player through hard work on and off teh field. That workman mentality is one reason he was such a good position coach and why he relates well to players setting high goals for themselves and working toward those goals. I think he’s better at coaching than gets acknowledged, due to his known motivating abilities. He can get better and if his playing career is a model, he will.
You gotta bring ass to get ass.
Singletary essentially admitted that three young guys on the team understood what type of offense the 49ers would succeed with better than he did, and he was still hesitant towards trying it. How did this cause such a big jump in his approval rating?
Maybe I am doing this wrong. Are we supposed to vote only by what we saw in the last game? Because in these votes I’ve been factoring in all the games I think we could have won if Singletary didn’t have a misguided philosophy on offense at the time. I’m just a casual fan and I’ve read much of the research proving that good passing and pass defense correlates more closely to winning in the NFL than good running and run defense does. Is too much to expect a head coach to have a fact-based understanding of what works in the NFL?
I think...
… the jump was due to the fact that Singletary showed that he IS willing to listen, contrary to the assumptions that many fans were beginning to make about him.
Not too much
No it’s not too much to expect a head coach to have a fact-based understanding of what works in the NFL. But this is Sing’s first job as a head coach. He’s still learning how to be a head coach and may very well be learning for quite some time. I say if it takes a 2nd, 3rd, 4th set of eyes (young and less experienced ones no less) to help him understand what is and isn’t working, so be it. He did also say this morning on Murph and Mac (not being able to quote verbatim) that being a leader means knowing when to listen to those around you and when to stick to your convictions. Sing is a very intelligent man, he’s figuring it out, and it’s good to know that he’s not too proud to do that even with the input of those who are not as experienced as him. The two can’t be compared, but Sing being 10-10 as head coach to this point is not bad. Remember, Walsh was 8-24 after two full seasons. I think he figured it out pretty well, I think Sing has the potential to do so too.
I think he knew
And also thought they weren’t ready to do this a few weeks ago. With all the lineup changes, doing a complete 180 on philosophy in the time span of a week with changes to QB, WR, LT & RT can cause huge mistakes, thus things getting much worse before they get better. Considering that he’s trying to rebuild the confidence of his QB, it was better to stretch that 180 turnaround over one month instead of one week. He also, obviously, wanted the players to take the lead in that change and not have it just be about the coaches. We can speculate that they would’ve won an extra game or two by making these changes sooner but they could’ve also had the same win/loss results but with bigger losses and more damage done to the psyche of the QB and team.
You gotta bring ass to get ass.
In stark contrast to the previous weeks' comments
I am hoping we can keep the consistancy thru these learning weeks. As the coaches are learning the talents they have, they will come out on top if they and the team on the field don’t make too many mistakes. 2-3 weeks ago several comments were made as Singletary is a coach that will be out soon. Seriously? amazing what a win will do to the amnesia factor.
Sando has good article about the 49ers
In essence he says the 49ers have been going this direction on offense for awhile:
Wow
They get hostile on that blog don’t they? :)
GIVE ME MY CREDIT,,,
I said it first… spread the D wide and sacks will me minimal… the whole off season we talked about how deep we were at the reciever position yet, we wanted to pound the ball… i said it first! thank you thank you you can send donations to my address at 4949 I Bleed 49ersRed&Gold, Long Beach CA
"Be more concerned with your character than your reputation, because your character is what you really are, while your reputation is merely what others think you are"
It's the fact that he realized what was working and went with it
He proved that he’s all about winning and is not a stubborn coach.
What we've got here is a failure to communicate.
by SportsChicken on Dec 1, 2009 5:41 PM PST up reply actions
Sing is a Good Coach
As long as he manages the other coaches, his biggest job is to get the players in the best position he can for them to play their game. If he’s doing that, how can you fault him? He can’t be on the field (aside from that one play). They have to perform. It’s his job to make the tough decisions and be accountable. That was a great play on 4th down, and I appreciate the testicular fortitude required to execute it. I assume we’d all still be standing by his side had VD displayed his usual Game Time hands… I know I would because bottom line is: I’m buying what he’s selling.
Looking to put San Fran*six-o* here some time soon!
After Sing's notebook on the 30th of November
I can understand his process of change. It’s not a panic it has to be a collective decision going forward. The coaches and players on the same page, going forward.
Sing has had approval every week from me.
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
Yes, but for non-spread reasons
Since our HC gets blamed for most all that goes wrong, I say vote “yes” for all that went well on Sunday. We scored on our first possession. Never trailed. Allowed no TDs. Again did not allow any points on an opponents opening drive. Allowed zero sacks for the first time all season (who saw that happening this year?). Zero turnovers committed. One penalty. The latter three were very welcome and if continued, this team certainly finishes with a playoff spot.
That all sounds like good coaching to me. His also got his team to respond after a disappointing loss while playing a team looking to make the playoffs. Good for Sing and the entire staff.
You gotta bring ass to get ass.
this is a little something from an article i read...
On Monday, Davis and Morgan ran and worked out together on the field. The day after a game is typically a light day made up of meetings and film sessions. Davis is often the last one off the field, something that’s rubbing off on others. Singletary loves it and hopes Crabtree will join in the extra work.
With all the moveable parts this season on offense—a changing offensive line, Crabtree’s late arrival, a quarterback switch, a revolving receiving corps — Singletary credits Raye for handling everything so well from week to week.
"I tell Jimmy, ‘I’m proud you haven’t run over me in the parking lot,"’ Singletary said.
-————————————————————————————————————————————
I’m glad Coach Sing has a sense of humor, lol. Me thinks our offense is finally coming together.
Injuries up the waaaaahzooh
"CHILD PLEASE"......................-E. Ochocinco
Ignorance is truly bliss!!
Nolan, that (site decroum) is gonna beat us to Berry!!
I voted yes.
Nothing to do with the spread offense or opening up the playbook as it was correcting offensive planning to Jacksonville’s defense. While it could be said that we need to improve on our running, against Jacksonville it was too hard to get a good running game on them. They do have a better run defense than us, after all. If we go spread against Seattle, then it’ll be interesting to see how Gore does in the spread. Seattle’s the perfect test for this. No, I don’t see nor expect another 200 yard game. That’s an unfair criteria for determining pass or fail. However, I do expect over 100. Pass-wise, Seattle’s gonna be seeing an entirely different offense, aren’t they? Will be expecting to see much better in the pass than in week 2.

by 

























