Niners Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Sean Keeley's Week 12 College Football Buffet

Steelers 27 - Cardinals 23: Best Super Bowl ever?

First off, it's absolutely fitting for our boy Josh from Hollywood, the season of the safety ends with a big safety late in the Super Bowl.

I'd imagine there are plenty of columns around the Internet deeming this the greatest Super Bowl ever.  I've been thinking over this game and some of the other great games of the recent past and I definitely think this one is close to those other games.  First a quick look back at yesterday's game, followed by recaps of some of the games I found to be highly entertaining.

First off, big time props to Kurt Warner for an amazing performance.  He did just about everything he possibly could to put his team in a position to win this game.  Only one time has a player on the losing team won the game's MVP award, but if I had a real vote, I actually would have voted for him.  Obviously Larry Fitzgerald was huge.  After a quiet start, he absolutely blew up in the fourth quarter.  However, on those scoring drives, it was Warner making plays up and down the field.  Had the Cardinals won, I think it very well could have been split between Warner and Fitzgerald, but again, my vote goes to Warner, win or lose.

As for the Steelers, James Harrison definitely deserves some love for the interception returned for a touchdown.  I'm a bit surprised he didn't get MVP.  If the Cardinals had not come back to take the lead I think Harrison would have gotten the award.  Instead, my guess is that the press figured the momentum-swing didn't matter in the end.  Not my belief, but something people might have thought.

If I had to pick just among Steelers, if not Harrison, I actually think Roethlisberger should have gotten more love for MVP.  His only mistake was a batted ball INT, and he did a phenomenal job moving around in the pick to avoid the Cardinals pressure.  He showed some of the best pocket presence I've seen in some time.  He definitely redeedmed himself for that performance against the Seahawks.

All in all though, the game brought a crazy back and forth we don't get to see all that often.  As is the case in many great Super Bowls, really it's a matter of it being an exciting 4th quarter more than anything else.  The James Harrison INT is a signature moment from the game, but the Cardinals furious comeback would have made for an amazing story in and of itself.  Fitzgerald had been quiet all game, but as they say, big players make big plays in big games.  When he scored the final touchdown, most everybody agreed there was plenty of time left, and Roethlisberger made them pay for it.  Santonio Holmes tip-toe touchdown was a great cap on the game.  Although I'm somewhat surprised the booth didn't review Warner's fumble at the end.  I don't think it would have been overturned, but given the gravity of the situation, it still surprised me.

Past Super Bowls
I've included a poll and as you can see, I'm only asking about games of the past 30 years, or roughly since the 49ers started winning Super Bowls.  I could go back and include the Jets and others, but I figure the proverbial "ESPN Era" is a good time frame to use.  I'm sure I'll miss some, but for these are the most notable.

Super Bowl XXIII - 49ers 20 - Bengals 16: Montana to Taylor anybody?  Isn't that John Candy?  Even if you weren't old enough to remember that game, you've read and heard enough about the game to know how special it was.  A back and forth affair that culminated in the greatest proof of why a team should never run a prevent defense late in the game against Joe Montana.

Super Bowl XXV - Giants 20 - Bills 19: WIDE RIGHT! 49ers fans remember this game for the heartbreaking NFC title game loss to the Giants.  Bills fans remember this for something so much worse.

Super Bowl XXXII - Broncos 31 - Packers 24: I actually couldn't find game footage on YouTube so this random video will have to do (and that is a dummy being hit by the car).  At first glance this game might seem overrated because of the Elway first title storyline.  However, if you watched this game, you'll remember a back and forth affair that always makes for a fun Super Bowl.  Probably not the best one ever, but the seesaw nature of it made for a really fun game.

Super Bowl XXXIV - Rams 23 - Titans 16: There is a a large contingent of folks that consider this the gold standard of recent Super Bowls, in large part because of the Kevin Dyson just short of the goal line play.  The Rams took a 16 point lead before the Titans made a furious comeback to tie the game before Isaac Bruce took a Warner bomb to the house.  On the final play of the game, Steve McNair threw a slant to Kevin Dyson who famously reached as far as he could for the end zone, to no avail.

Super Bowl XXXVI - Patriots 20 - Rams 17: New England seemed ready to run away with this game before the Rams rallied for a late tie.  Tom Brady and Adam Vinatieri secured their legacies in the final minute and a half.  It's funny because in reality, the first 3 quarters of this game were not all that entertaining, aside from seeing the underdog punch the favorite in the mouth.  Many might not agree, but I would actually say the victory over the Panthers two years later might have been more entertaining.  I don't think either would get enough votes to make it worth separating, but feel free to comment on that topic.

Super Bowl XLII - Giants 17 - Patriots 14: Yet another game where the first three quarters were quite boring, but a furious finish made it all worth it.  You had the amazing catch of David Tyree (not to mention a great throw from Manning), you had a late exchange of touchdowns, and as with the Patriots upset of the Rams, you had a big underdog shocking the world.  Probably not the greatest Super Bowl of the last thirty years, but certainly a good one.

As my list indicates, I'm not including what I found to be highly entertaining 49er whuppings of the Broncos and Chargers.  I'm thinking more of Super Bowls most, if not all fans can agree are great.  Even if you don't think last night's was the best ever, you have to admit there was some highly entertaining football late in the game.

Poll
In the last thirty years, what was the greatest Super Bowl?
Super Bowl XXIII - 49ers 20-Bengals 16: Montana-to-Taylor
132 votes
Super Bowl XXV - Giants 20-Bills 19: Norwood wide right
4 votes
Super Bowl XXXIII - Broncos 31-Packers 24: Seesaw affair for Elway's first
4 votes
Super Bowl XXXIV - Rams 23-Titans 16: Dyson just short
20 votes
Super Bowl XXXVI - Patriots 20-Rams 17: Vinatieri and the Pats shock heavily favored Rams
3 votes
Super Bowl XLII - Giants 17-Patriots 14: Eli and company shock the heavily favored Patriots
49 votes
Super Bowl XLIII - Steelers 27-Cardinals 23: Cardinals shock...oh wait no Steelers stun Cardinals
42 votes
Other - Specify in comments
2 votes

256 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 10 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

other vote

Carolina vs Patriots + Janet Jackson’s boobie= One of the greatest Super Bowls ever

Joe and Steve were under the same system for years... don't expect Smith to be super so soon.

by bayboy on Feb 2, 2009 9:29 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

Slight Bias

Montana to Taylor was GREAT but not the best ever. Great for niners fans, my fav niner superbowl, but not the best ever.

It was realllly hard to come to a solid answer, i was trying to decide between Rams Titans and Giants Pats, and right now I’m going to say Giants. The MONUMENTAL upset that was makes it an incredible game, including 2 end of quarter drives to take the lead, and one of the most amazing plays/catches ever (Manning to Tyree)

But ask me again in a few years when I can reflect on the history of the game/watch this one a few more times.

Blind devotion.

by ProfessorBigelow on Feb 2, 2009 9:41 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

WIDE RIGHT!

Gahhhhhh…..

Buffalo Rumblings - all you care to know about the Buffalo Bills and more

by Brian Galliford on Feb 2, 2009 9:59 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

Couple thoughts

First off, the game winning TD catch by Santonio Holmes was a clean catch for the win. Last year’s Tyree catch was so lucky (and controversial? can’t remember), it made the game debatable. I’ll take the clean, decisive catch.

Second, after the game someone was asked what Roethlisberger said before that final drive. Apparently he gave the rah-rah, it’s-now-or-never standard. My first thought was, Ben gives the rah-rah, Joe asked if that’s John Candy. That’s why Ben will never be one of the greats like Joe. But really, it’s just funny that Joe’s inspirational speech during the game winning drive was, “Is that John Candy?”

Thirdly, did anyone else feel like that was the most subdued Super Bowl celebration ever? It all seemed so anticlimactic to me because they already won a Super Bowl just a couple years back. So it became a lot less interesting.

"He called the sh** POOP!" -- Adam Sandler

by JRPhillips on Feb 2, 2009 10:32 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

EXACTLY

I actually said that to a friend of mine as we were watching the celebration. The one I remember most was the big shocking grin on Tom Brady’s face after they beat the Rams.

by Fooch on Feb 2, 2009 11:18 AM PST up reply actions   0 recs

Since i've been watching Superbowls last year's was the best...

I’m sure if I was alive (and cognitive) during the 80’s I may have chosen the 49ers, but as it is the historical and dramatic conclusion of last year’s game was by far the best I’ve seen. Also I think it plays into who you were rooting for during the game. If the team you rooted for loss I’m sure you may not have thought it was one of the best games you have ever seen.

Next year will be our year! (copyright 2003*, been used each of last five years)

by StrictlyFootball on Feb 2, 2009 10:39 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

disappointed in this game

The funny thing about this game is I was very disappointed in it. I had no preference, since I am 49er fan only, but I just felt that the Cards would do something to miff it up, which they did. And that annoyed me and made the game very boring. The cards played a dumb game and because of that they lost. The turnovers where actually acceptable, but those penalties where just maddening. And the Steelers didn’t answer as crisply as I thought they would. Overall I think that was probably the best quarter of Super Bowl history, but that was no where near the best game, I prefer Denver/GB or Carolina/Pats.
  Now the 49ers just need to catch up and surpass the Steelers during the next decade of greatness.

by Gailikk on Feb 2, 2009 11:40 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

I thought i was the only one...

Due to the poll I thought I was the only one who saw the carolina/pats game by far the best superbowl game I’ve seen. I do agree that the last 2 minutes last night was the best I’ve seen (and remember) on Super Sunday. Though I am a 49er faithful, I was only 7 years old when the niners won their 4th ring.

Joe and Steve were under the same system for years... don't expect Smith to be super so soon.

by bayboy on Feb 2, 2009 12:24 PM PST up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

"We'll see them again in the playoffs." -- Coach Mike Singletary after a gut-wrenching week 3 loss to the Vikings.
Start posting about the 49ers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Dave_small
Week 11 Prediction Games
Howtheyscoredcat_small
Official Alex Smith [Over]Reaction Thread: Bears Edition
Small
Alex Smith vs Aaron Rodgers(updated)
Small
The Titans/Niners play-by-play
Dave_small
Week 10 Prediction Games

Recent FanPosts

Small
10 things the 49ers should not do
Italian_flag_small
Still think the Niners will reach the playoffs???
2305d0d49c908218_small
Packers fan with some questions
49ers_small
I have a feeling about this particular road game
Joe_and_bill_small
49ers QB - 2010
Small
Jimmy Raye - Ken Whisenhunt
Small
Niners Nation hits the big time
Shaun_hill_small
SINGLETARY WAS HIRED BECAUSE OF SHAUN HILL !!
Howtheyscoredcat_small
Week 10 Prediction Games: The Riveting Results

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Mobile Live
Garrett Wolfe Out For the Year (Updated)
Mobile Live
Friday Notes: Lions Place Stephen Peterman on IR, Sign Eric Fowler
Mobile Live
Well, Isn't That Special (Teams)?

SPONSORS


Head Ball Coach

Dave_small Fooch

Editors

Jerry_rice_small ProfessorBigelow

Assistant Coaches

Howtheyscoredcat_small howtheyscored

Pixies_logo_small Florida Danny

M_12a62905a0324d2da2f43ddaf62c630f_small Ninjames

Duct_tape_bandit_small Josh from Hollywood

Crab_tree_small briandean

Moderators

Jackalope_card_small wjackalope