Official Jay Cutler Trade Block thread

On the Mile High Report apart of SBnation.

That has to be a record.

Kurt Warner, was worth a shot, I just don’t see this guy as a 49er, and I don’t think the 49ers are willing to give up whoever is left at #10 ++? to get a QB, that alrady is haviong a problem with a new HC, and the durrent one is smaller, Singletary would make Cutler S*** his pants.

they’ll get him.

I don’t think the #1 in the draft is worth Cutler (because of the financial implications it comes with), so I think the Lions will have to work to warm the Broncos to the idea.

The biggest problem in all of this is that now Denver essentially cannot just find a trade suitor with a starting caliber QB available for trade in return. They’ve already thrown it out there that Cutler is indeed on the block, and there are only a few teams (Browns, Redskins) that could offer a quality QB in return.

If neither of those teams express interest, whom do the Broncos turn to, to trade Cutler? They surely wouldn’t want the cost of the number 1 pick going to an unproven QB over Cutler (who is considerably more affordable present day). Would they?

Would Denver accept Mark Roman for Jay Cutler? (LOL)

i wish the niners would put up some offer like there 10th pick. a 4th or 3rd or alex smith or roman. someone haha.

alex and our 10th pick this year for cutler? i would, screw developing another player, lets get a proven qb damn it

Alex smith and a future 1st and third.

I wouldn’t give up any of the first three picks of 09 they are very key for are “NEW APPROACH”

I would give up Gore for him straight up!!
Yes Gore, after that great 1600 yd season he’s carried less and fumbled more. This past season he had his least attempts in 3 years and his most fumbles.
If they would take Gore and a future 2 I’d take hiM. I’d then trade down for Brown from UCONN and take Latrell in the later rounds and also the speedster from FSU he had 33 reps at 225. Frank Gore does equal 3 rookie RB’s with tremendous upside.

I bet we swing our first and second round to the pats so they’ll send Brady to Denver and Denver will send us Jay!

I keed.

Well Broncos are a west coast offense I believe. Are we west coast offense? Then screw #10 and maybe 4th or 5th or whatever. Cutler is proven QB. Although is record doesn’t show it but our defense is better than the Broncos. So, what number will Cutler be wearing?

Done Deal!

See the 49ers, getting rid of Lawson and expect to replace him, in this years draft, especially if they don;t get one at #10

for whatever reason, how does this effect the draft? So far as I can see, it means one less team looking to trade up. Unless Denver want to, of course.

On the other hand, should Detroit get him, then there will be two QBs considered first round worthy, so teams might be less inclined to trade up to ten to get one, if they are both dropping.

On the other hand, should a team really rate Stafford, and he falls to ten… well?

Just some thoughts

Lets see out of the teams mentioned here is handicap of their ability to land Culter:

1st.
Browns – the 5th pick would be enticing. Denver is essentially looking for BJ Raji in the draft and would land him with the 5th pick (I watched a Denver interview the other day and teams broadcaster stated Raji was at the top of their board) . They could still potentially land Mark Sanchez with their own 12 pick. Also, the Browns can throw a QB in the deal if the Broncos are interested.

2nd.
49ers – the 10th pick is also very enticing to Denver. It’s a high pick, but with reasonable price tag. Again they could get Raji. Even better they can eliminate the 49ers from taking Raji. With the 10th pick they can select Mark Sanchez than get Raji as the 12th pick.

3rd.
Jets – probably the most desperate for Cutler but the 17th pick isn’t the most attractive and not a better pick than what Denver has now. Also, Jets gave away some future picks last year getting Brett Farve and would have trouble sweetening the deal.

4th.
Bears – 18th pick and could probably offer some defensive personnel. However, the Bears blue chippers aren’t considered young anymore so I don’t know how enticing they may still be.

5th.
Lions – a trade with Denver won’t involve the 1st pick. Taking the first pick is like accepting someone’s balloon loan just as it’s about to expand. Lions best offer would be 20th pick plus a few others. Still, can the Lions afford to give up multiple picks with so many glaring holes to fill?

6th.
Bucs – 19th pick is no better than the Jet’s 17th. Problem with Tampa Bay is they cut half their team already and cannot afford to give up more picks because they desperately need them to fill the roster for 2009.

I have read that Denver would take is a starting QB in return. Remember Cutler is a problem for Denver now, not an asset. Smith for Cutler sounds about fair. I wouldn’t give up more than one draft pick for Cutler even Cassel was only worth a 2nd round pick.

because it’s out of my control.
But unless we get rid of BamBam or VP Al,
I will be impartial either way.

that me breaking out of my lurker shell and extending my SBNation membership from McCoveyChronicles to here somehow convinces Joe Pesci to get Cutler in San Francisco.

This kid is a natural athlete. He had great talent in basketball and baseball as well, so he should start for the Warriors and Giants, too.

but if there is a chance to get Cutler without breaking the bank when it comes to draft picks, I say go for it. Alex has the potential to be a very good QB. Jay already is a pro bowl caliber QB and would seem to be for years to come.

I mean, if you’re gonna bring in this primadonna how does Lil’ Jay feel about sourdough and crab?

As far as A. Smith to Denver, not if Nolan has anything to say about it. And maybe Smith would balk at it too. And Hill has no value on the open market.

As for what Denver is going to do for a quarterback, Jeff Garcia is out there. He can do a serviceable job for them for a year or two, if the team is really in a rebuilding mode. Denver needs to find a defensive line.

I don’t think that Cutler is as good as people think he is, and I don’t think that the Niners’ QB situation is as bad as people make it out to be. I’d rather see them work on the O and D lines, get a fast receiver, a decent running back and then pick up a QB for development in a later round. All of the holes in the roster will be there whether or not Cutler is under the center. Cutler won’t be the savior here, and if he’s not then expect a temper tantrum coming out of his frustration somewhere along the line.

Then again, maybe McDaniels is such an a-hole that Cutler is just the first of many off the sinking ship.

Dunno, but I don’t think that Cutler will be worth it. Would be interesting, though.

This whiny little girl just pouted his way off this team. This is the guy you want running your offense and the future of your franchise?

We’ve got our first Cutler April Fools joke. Seems real, but read through the stuff after the Cutler portion.

is worth our next 2 number 1s at least. Do you really want to pass up a proven GREAT quarterback for 2 lottery tickets? Especially this year, when there isn’t a ton of great options at 10. Of course, the Broncos are picking 12th, so that may not be a very enticing offer to them. Either way, this guy is worth whatever the niners have to do to get him.

If they get him, we win the division. It’s that simple.

HE ACTS LIKE A KID, COACH SING WANTS WINNER NOT CRY BABIES HE NEEDS TO STOP ACTING LIKE A BABY AND PICK UP THE PHONE AND TALK TO THE MAN THAT IS PAYING HIM MILLIONS OF DOLLARS AND TELL HIM HOW HE FEELS AND WAT HE WANT TO DO. STOP BEING A B**** ABOUT IT, IT THE NFL IS ALL ABOUT BUSINESS.

Great Joke Broncos!!

Thoughts?

if nothing gets done before the draft, then I think the niners could possibly work out a deal a-la Manning and Rivers a few years ago- if Sanchez drops to ten, you take him and work a deal to trade him and a couple picks to Denver for Cutler. That takes a LOT of things going right, though

you would obviously work it out in advance. The point is, if it gets to that point, then you don’t just trade them the pick, you take the player, then trade that player to them so you can maybe get something more in return

to the side opposing the trade. I’ve given this some critical thought over the last day+ while slacking off at work, and I’ve concluded the Niners should absolutely not be trying to acquire Cutler. Reasons why:

1. He wears his hat like a jackass, ya know with his hair, excuse me, his bangs coming out the front.

2. I like the guy we have, ya know, the team player who gives the ball to an O-lineman to spike the ball. The guy with a better winning percentage than d-bag Cutler… what’s his name again? oh yea, Shaun Hill, our starting QB.

3. He’s not worth the asking price, flat out. Report is multiple 1st rd picks (this yr and another’s) and an impact defensive starter is the beginning. I’m not parting with anyone considered an impact defensive player on the niners.

4. He’s a crybaby. What was Shaun Hill’s response to Martz bringing in O’sullivan last year and losing the job (yes he deserved the job from the beginning of last year)? He bucked up and still played well. Cutler, on the other hand, seems entitled and is not Joe Montana (last time I checked)- who by the way was once traded.

5. Continuity. 7 OC’s in 7 years. Now we want to bring in another QB? Not gonna do it, wouldn’t be prudent.

6. Finally. I don’t imagine Coach Singletary putting up with crybaby Cutler for too long if he decides he’s better than the situation he’s being put into. I want Humble. I want Confident. I want a Competitor. I want Continuity (as much as possible given the current situation). And I want to use these draft picks- Damnit.

Jason Campbell goes to San Francisco
Jay Cutler goes to Washington
Denver receives #13 pick in draft, #10 pick in the draft.

but I for one would have to see what the Niners give up before my final judgement on the matter. This year’s #10? Sure. Multiple draft choices? Let’s see.

Certainly, Cutler seems to be an upgrade over the two Niner QBs. But how much better? I have a lot of respect for Shanahan as an offensive coach. If Alex Smith had started out in Denver instead of being incredibly mishandled by Nolan does anyone think that he’d be on the slag heap?

So I’m not certain that Cutler will necessarily translate his numbers in Denver under Shanahan to SF and Raye.

Cutler’s attitude seems pretty immature but maybe there’s more to the story. I’ll leave it to Singletary to make the final call.

From what I understand, the Broncos are seeking for this year’s round 1 and next year’s, as well. Is he really worth all the trouble? Maybe. Here you have, obviously, a DIVA and a talented one, versus taking this year’s 10th overall and possibly another high draft pick next year.

If the trade doesn’t happen and the 49ers stink it up this year, at least they’ll have another chance next draft. But, if the trade does happen and the 49ers still doesn’t make the play-offs, they’ll be out of a high draft pick and a DIVA to deal with. He is talented, I acknowledge that, but the memory of a certain number 81 is still fresh in some fan’s memories, particularly this writer. Yet, if the 49ers make the play-offs, the risk is justified.
I guess that’s why the front office personnel are paid quite a bit and hacked when things go wrong. Wouldn’t want to be in their shoes. Good luck to these guys.

All I can say is, I hope that the 49ers get better this coming season and I am looking forward to a succesful year.

best QB= best team

I don’t think so.

It looks like the Redskins may indeed be ending this discussion abruptly. Just like I feared the Redskins seem more than willing to over pay for Cutler . . . after all it’s Daniel Synder’s MO.

Like I posted above the Redskins put no value in draft picks. This was the team who offered two 1st round picks last year for Chad “Ocho-Sucko” Johnson. You can only imagine what they have ponied up for Cutler. BTW, Bill Cowher was a great discussing that Ocho Sucko offer from the Redskins. All the analyst were telling the Bengals to refuse the offer because there wasn’t a top WR in the draft and Bill Cowher jumps in on fire calling them all crazy. I can get 2 starters I don’t have worry about for more 4 years . . . where do I make that trade!!!!

Anyways get ready for the sequel to the Herschel Walkerr trade. Dan Snyder’s masterpiece is about to be unveiled. Oh, to top it off . . . Snyder might fire Zorn ASAP to hire Mike Shanahan.