Isaac Bruce or no Isaac Bruce: Who will step up?
Today is the Mike Singletary imposed deadline for Isaac Bruce to make up his mind about being a 49er in 2009. We'll have continued coverage on this story as any developments break today (and going forward). For now, consider this post an Isaac Bruce thread (as well as discussion on the topic below).
Even if Isaac Bruce sticks around, it seems like he'd be taking a backseat to the rest of the crew. My question is which one steps up next season, assuming any of them do. Way back on New Years Eve, we did our long look back, brief look forward on wide receivers. Early last month we did a re-assessment of the wide receiver depth chart. It's only been a month, but I wanted to take one more look at the position as a whole, in light of the potential news today. And even if Bruce sticks around, one would hope a youngster would take the baton from Bruce.
Josh Morgan: I remain sold on the upside of Josh Morgan, but I'm not ignorant to his relative lack of production in 2008. He had some big catches, but in the end his stats weren't spectacular. That was due in large part to an assortment of injuries that kept him from truly capitalizing on an impressive training camp and preseason. Whatever happens with Bruce, it sounds more and more like Morgan will be getting the starting reps in training camp. The key remains health.
Brandon Jones: Jones is entering his fifth season in the NFL and has not had the breakout season one would like from a young receiver. He improved his numbers in 2008, but they're still less than stellar. Even with the lack of otherwise impressive WR talent in Tennessee, Jones could not become "the man." That makes me wonder if we're getting another Bryant Johnson. A player who could put together solid numbers, but not break through to the next level of receiver.
Brandon Jones lined up at flanker in practice, the same position Isaac Bruce held. An interesting comment showed up at Rotoworld, which stated that Morgan would be the deep threat and Jones would likely lead the team in receptions. The flanker is often the featured receiver on the team, which I find interesting in this case. Morgan seems to be built for that job, but maybe they figure his speed brings great ability deep.
Jason Hill: Hillis entering the ever important third year in the NFL. After one reception for six yards his rookie year, Hill improved to 30 receptions for 317 yards and two TDs his second year. It seems like he's going to go into camp as the slot receiver. He took over that role this past year once Singletary took over and excelled, with all of his stats coming under Coach Singletary. Most of us are excited about a guy like Morgan, but Hill is one guy I am really anxious to see get a full season of reps.
Arnaz Battle: Battle is definitely not long for this world as a 49er. Jones, Morgan and Hill are definitely ahead of Battle for now on the depth chart, and it's entirely possible Dominique Zeigler might surpass him as well. Battle missed much of last season with injuries, and I wonder if he'll ever return to his 50+ catch days, at least here in SF? He's stepped up for some bad teams, and for that I certainly appreciate him. Unfortunately, even though he's only 29, his best 49ers days are probably behind him. I hope for a big return, but there are only so many receptions to be had.
Dominique Zeigler: I know some folks don't expect much out of Dominique Zeigler, but given the role he's in and the money he's being paid, it seems like he'll get a chance at a bigger role in 2009. If he doesn't step up in camp, so be it. However, Zeigler seems to have some solid hands and solid abilities, based on what little we saw of him. I certainly don't think he'll have the best year among the receivers, but I do think there's some talent in there. It'll be interesting to see what opportunities he gets in 2009. He's a tough one to predict.
Not including the folks signed to futures contracts (Maurice Price/Micheal Spurlock) and Isaac Bruce, the 49ers have five receivers under contract. If Bruce retires, it will be interesting to see how the 49ers handle wide receivers in the draft. Barring them taking a Maclin or Crabtree, whomever they get is unlikely to get much of a chance to do much in 2009.
If that's the case, who on the current roster steps up as the man this year?
6 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
1 more WR
Even if Isaac Bruce returns, I think a WR should be selected in the first 3 rounds of the draft. I would prefer a pass rusher (Orakpo, Brown, Maybin) or an elite tackle (A. Smith or Oher) with the 10th pick, but I would not be dissapointed if we take Maclin (Crabtree would not be there).
If it’s in the second round, Robiskie, Britt or Juaquin Iglesias would be nice.
The thing is we still have a big question mark about production from any of our receivers besides Isaac Bruce.
If he does not return I do hope that Josh Morgan will take advantage of it, but the truth is that may very well not be the case, since he stil qualfies as a good prospect that has to realize his potential. Brandon Jones and Jason Hill are not expected to have the production of a No. 1 receiver, so the question is if we try to get that from either Josh Morgan and a rookie like Maclin or Robiskie, or if we go after Torry Holt.
Considering the focus on the running game, the recent signing of M. Smith and the announced policy of building the team through the draft instead of free agency, I do think that if I. Bruce does not return, the additional receiver will be added on the draft , but it would need to be on the first 2 or 3 rounds if we realistically expect him to compete with Josh Morgan for the # 1 spot.
In that case I just hope that whoever is throwing the passes next season does not miss too much an experience receiver.
Arnaz Battle's blocking is rarely talked about but it's part of what makes him so valuable to this team
Additionally, with fewer reps on offense he can return to doing more and more special teams duty which he excels at. I think Fooch may be right in thinking that his time as a leading or prominent receiver might be limited but I would hope that the Niners would hold onto him for other reasons. He’s a solid veteran presence, tireless worker, and probably wouldn’t draw too much overwhelming financial interest from other teams as a FA, meaning the Niners could retain him at a relatively cheap price.
Arnaz Battle = worth keeping
Bruce returning.
According to this blog entry from Maiocco, Bruce returns.
Draft.....
Draft a receiver if there’s a good one available in later rounds…. I think they should focus on a pass rusher early, then maybe a good solid CB…. then after that wuteva…
With bruce
it seems that the WR corps will be fine. Morgan is an amazing talent, and Hill has some grrreat hands. I think those 2 will be more than enough in the coming years- they are very talented.
I do not get the Brandon Jones thing at all. Why exactly is the guy worth 5 years? 5 mil up front? What the hell?
Dont underestimate Brandon Jones
He will start and put up SOLID numbers.
Other than death and taxes, only 4 things in this world are indisputable:
Brandon Roy is the BEST player in the NBA in the clutch.
Montana to Rice were the greatest to ever play the game.
The Four Horsemen of Maddux, Smoltz, Glavine and Avery were unstoppable.
No one protects the pipes like Luongo.
by GreatOden'sRaven on Apr 2, 2009 2:54 PM PDT reply actions

by 





























