2009 NFL Draft: Final First Round Prediction
I realize it's only Thursday, but with some big stuff planned for tomorrow (1983 Year-by-Year post, big Florida Danny post), I figure now is as good a time as any for this post. I want to get everybody's final big prediction for what the 49ers do in the first round. I can't imagine much will happen in the next two days, so why not?
I actually am going to factor in the predictions I made at the NFL Pick 'Em Contest. Speaking of which, remember to join (League Name: Niners Nation; Password: 49ers). We've got 14 people involved so far.
I may change some of my later picks, but going through the first ten spots, I came up with some interesting results. I'm sure I'll end up completely wrong, but why not throw it out there. I had the 49ers selecting B.J. Raji, NT, Boston College. I was a bit surprised, but looking through things, I don't think it was a completely crazy mock of the first 10. Accordingly, I'm willing to go with that pick as my official prediction. A little crazy, but a pick I would be perfectly fine with.
My top 10 was as follows:
1. Lions - Matthew Stafford, QB
2. Rams - Jason Smith, OT
3. Chiefs - Eugene Monroe, OT
4. Seahawks - Aaron Curry, LB
5. Browns - Michael Crabtree, WR
6. Bengals - Andre Smith, OT
7. Raiders - Jeremy Maclin, WR
8. Jaguars - Mark Sanchez, QB
9. Packers - Brian Orakpo, OLB/DE
10. 49ers - B.J. Raji, DT
I don't know if the Seahawks will take Curry, but he's rated high enough that maybe they go with him. I figure in this case it would be Curry or Crabtree. Jeremy Maclin is probably also a bit of a surprise, but the Raiders have no problem shocking folks. Maclin brings enough speed that I could see him enamoring Al Davis enough to pick him. No guarantees, but would that really shock people all that much?
The Sanchez pick is actually predicated on the Broncos (or somebody else) dealing up to get him. That's followed by an Orakpo pick that might be a bit much. If anything in this mock won't work, I see it being that Orakpo pick (even more than the Maclin or Sanchez picks).
So, is my prediction way off base? Somewhat realistic or am I off my rocker?
Aside from criticizing my own prediction, use this thread to make your prediction for what the 49ers will do in the first round. If you think they'll trade down, you're more than welcome to make that prediction as well. If something happens in the next day or two to make you change your mind, reply to your own comment with an update.
0 recs |
27 comments
|
Comments
My latest mock..
1. DET – QB Matthew Stafford, Georgia
2. STL – OT Jason Smith, Baylor
3. KC – OT Eugene Monroe, Virginia
4. SEA – OLB Aaron Curry, Wake Forest
5. CLE – DT B.J. Raji, Boston College
6. CIN – OT Andre Smith, Alabama
7. OAK – WR Jeremy Maclin, Missouri
8. NYJ – QB Mark Sanchez, USC
9. GB – DE/OLB Brian Orakpo, Texas
10. SF – WR Michael Crabtree, Texas Tech
Very similar to mine, but I don’t see Mangini passing up Raji at #5. I’ve gone back and forth on that pick between Crabtree and Raji, so either could happen. If Crabtree goes at 5, then Raji goes to Cinci, Jacksonville, or Green Bay meaning Orakpo likely slips to #10.
I have faith in Oakland taking Maclin over Crabtree due to JaMarcus Russell’s huge arm. I also don’t think Sanchez makes it beyond #9 in a trade with either the Jets or Redskins.
The “swing” picks in this year’s draft seem to be KC at #3 (Monroe, Curry, or Orakpo) and CLE at #5 (Raji, Crabtree, or Orakpo).
The 49ers are likely going to be left with Orakpo, Crabtree, Maclin, or Jenkins as the BPA.
Rays in '08.... Desmond Jennings - the breakout continues.....
by youALREADYknow on Apr 23, 2009 8:17 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
other trade possibilities
I also wouldn’t be surprised if a team traded up into the top 10 to take either Raji or Crabtree given they fall beyond pick #7. Denver would probably move up for Raji. The Redskins, Eagles, and Giants would be teams likely interested in moving up for Crabtree although they might not be willing to pay the price.
Rays in '08.... Desmond Jennings - the breakout continues.....
by youALREADYknow on Apr 23, 2009 8:31 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I think yours is good...
I think you made a reach on us getting Crabtree though, just don’t foresee him falling to us. I think Sanchez is likely to go to the seagals or the jets.
by jonesin25 on Apr 23, 2009 7:30 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Draft Day Trades
It’s going to be an interesting draft day. I think KC really wants to get out of #3 but maybe they should have thought about that before they decided to suck all season. If they can’t move down I don’t know if they take Monroe there, they spent a first rounder on Brandon Albert last year and by all accounts looked pretty solid. I’m actually hoping that if they don’t move down they take Curry, because I’d hate for Seattle to end up with him, but Raji could be a very strong canindate to go there.
I find the Seattle pick pretty interesting and would like to pose a question for all of those who oppose the Niners taking Sanchez at #10. What would your reaction be to Seattle taking Sanchez at #4?
Don't sweat it. I'm illiterate.
by methodrampage on Apr 23, 2009 8:35 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
laughable
It would be comical, but would actually hurt the 49ers. I’d still see both Monroe and A. Smith going before the 49ers, but Smith to the Raiders instead of the Bengals (who would take Monroe). That means no trading down for the Jaguars and Packers who would surely take Crabtree/Raji/Orakpo depending on the Browns pick (Raji/Crabtree). The BPA would likely become Maybin or Orakpo at #10, who both would be far riskier than Raji/Crabtree and less likely to contribute next year.
Rays in '08.... Desmond Jennings - the breakout continues.....
by youALREADYknow on Apr 23, 2009 8:46 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
good short term, bad long term
The Seahawks need help at Tackle, so the fact that they’re not getting help there (with them taking Sanchez at #4) is good. But with a couple of years of Hasselbeck-run tutorials, I think Sanchez could be a bit scary. I don’t like him for the Niners because a) he’d get forced onto the field and b) he wouldn’t have the support he’d get in Seattle. That shows you what kind of confidence I have in our coaching staff.
Throwback unis? Yes. Throwback afros? YES!
by grantmp on Apr 23, 2009 9:51 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Got a feeling that they will pick Sanchez, Here's why.
Wallace didn’t anything during his time at QB and the O/C or QB coach was at USC. They know each other and during a interview on NFL, Sanchez smile when that was mention. I think he’s hoping to go there,Beside they got to groom a replacement for Hassleback.
by LASVEGASNINER on Apr 23, 2009 6:26 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I think he has a hell of a chance to get drafted by Seattle
That’s why I picked him in the first NN mock draft when I was picking for Seattle. Eventhough he’s a pick on the riskier side of the spectrum I might cringe a little if Seattle does take him just because I think he’s got some imense potential. Who’s knows if he’ll actually reach it bust but I’d still be nervous about him capitalizing on his talent.
Don't sweat it. I'm illiterate.
by methodrampage on Apr 23, 2009 8:14 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Sanchez to Seattle...
… it’s kind of a mixed bag. On one hand, it could push someone the 49ers may actually want (Crabtree) down to #10, but that’s not necessarily true. On the other hand, they also potentially lose a TON of trade partners with Sanchez off the board.
by sfgfan on Apr 24, 2009 9:43 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Mine
I’d rather have Jenkins, or Orakpo if he’s available.
I also don’t see why we’d pass on Everette Brown if neither of those guys are available. Stiff in space? Brown? Don’t you love how these media scouts draw quick conclusions jump on things? Have they ever coached the kid? He’s supposed to be a good kid and a quick learner. . . The guy is also a monster run stopper and one of the best pass rushers in the draft. He can learn to drop back with his speed. He can learn to shed blockers and mix up his moves. It’s not like he’s been in the league for 5 years. He’s going to develop.
So, enough said. My mock is:
1. Lions – Matthew Stafford, QB
2. Rams – Jason Smith, OT
3. Chiefs – Aaron Curry OLB
4. Seahawks – Sanchez QB! (New coach, old QB, gotta have “the future” in place, it’’ll make a splash with the fans in the post-Holmgren era, and they play west coast offense.) Call me crazy.
5. Browns – Eugene Monroe OL
6. Bengals – Andre Smith, OT (Adding yet another fine character to the team.)
7. Raiders – Jeremy Maclin, WR (Are they nutty enough to take him over Crabtree? Or who knows, maybe they take a kicker.)
8. Jaguars – Michael Crabtree (nice compliment to Holt)
9. Packers – Brian Orakpo DE/OLB (Deadly good move for them)
10. 49ers – Michael Jenkins CB (Leaving Raji and Oher for others)
Surprised?
I think this is the way the 49ers may go because with Orakpo off the board, they are already swamped with interior linemen. Raji just makes things more crowded, more complicated, and doesn’t fill a glaring need as a first rounder. Filling the most glaring need would be to select Everette Brown here. And they very well might.
They have so many OLinemen at the moment with the signing of Marvel Smith that taking one in the first round and paying him big bucks like they just paid Smith makes no sense. By the way, Smith is not Jennings. Jennings was injured all over his body. Smith had a bad back that’s now fine. I know there’s a chance of a recurrence, but come on, if we hadn’t been burned by Jennings wouldn’t you give him a shot at staying healthy? I’m giving him the benefit of the doubt and not playing the “Just like Jennings” card.
Why Jenkins? They lost Strickland. Harris is old and didn’t play all that great last year. Spencer is injury prone. Reggie has to try to make it at safety. Tarrel Brown is a nice player but not nec a future shut down starter. More like Strickland’s replaement. And importantly, this is a very very thin CB class. I don’t see 2nd or 3rd round CBs that are really solid picks, do you? Can anyone throw out a name or two for later rounds? I don’t see any. . . . So I think Jenkins is a good solid pick with less risk than an Everette Brown — who although I DO think he can transition to OLB, isn’t a guarantee there. And more importantly, there ARE really exciting pass rushers in round 2.
The Jenkins pick will be idiotic if they don’t then pick Cody Brown or Barwin in round 2 for the pass rush.
Round three: RB or Safety. If we pick the RB here, maybe we can pick up safety McBath in round 4.
That would be a very good, safe, strong, draft in my opinion.
PS: ………
Nose tackle: Franklin is good enough if Balmer can’t transition there. And there could be some projects later in the draft if the coaches feel they need another guy there: A Sammy Hill type maybe late? So no Raji. We’d leave too many holes to fill in rounds 2-4.
WR: Hey, we need to give Morgan and Hill playing time if they are going to develop behind Bruce. . . . .Maybe a slot guy in round 5 like Butler from Penn if he’s still there. . .
That’s mine. . . .
by Since79 on Apr 23, 2009 9:07 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Comments
- Balmer is not a 3-4 nose. He was drafted to be a 3-4 end.
- Besides QB, nose tackle is the one of the most difficult positions to find talent and is one of if not the most important player in a 3-4. Franklin in a journeyman. He is not the stud NT needed to properly run a 3-4. Raji has a chance to be that guy and could transform our defense.
- We are not as deep on the defensive line as it might appear. We currently have Smith, Sop, Balmer, Franklin, McDonald and Evans. However, McDonald just had knee surgery and Franklin is in the last year of his contract. If we pick Raji and let Franklin go, we would have Raji, Smith, Balmer and Sop locked in through 2013+, with depth from McDonald and Evans through 2011. That’s a pretty solid situation on the defensive line.
- 2nd round OLB sounds great to me.
- That said, there are a number of corners that may drop to the second. Vontae Davis is falling because of character concerns. There’s also Darius Butler, Alphonso Smith, DJ Moore, Sean Smith, Jarius Bryd, Asher Allen, and Coye Francis. In other words, if we just want depth to replace our dime DBs, its there.
- However, if we’re looking for a replacement for Harris, maybe that’s not something we can get in the 2nd or 3rd round. By all accounts, it also may not be something we can get out of Malcom Jenkins.
1. Lions – Matthew Stafford, QB
2. Rams – Jason Smith, OT
3. Chiefs – Tyson Jackson, DE
4. Seahawks – Aaron Curry, LB
5. Browns – Michael Crabtree, WR
6. Bengals – Eugene Monroe, OT
7. Raiders – Andre Smith, OT
8. Jaguars – Mark Sanchez, QB
9. Packers – Brian Orakpo, OLB/DE
10. 49ers – B.J. Raji, DT
by kiyoshi on Apr 23, 2009 10:53 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Sanchez at #8
I fully agree. Although I have the Jets moving in there.
by briandean on Apr 23, 2009 10:49 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Jags = no money.
They are trading down.
by bignerd on Apr 23, 2009 11:23 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
No, you can take that one to the bank
The Jags are cheap. Any half way decent offer for there 8th pick and their owner will force the trade. Moving from 8th to 13th pick saves Mr. Cheap $10 million in guaranteed money.
by bignerd on Apr 24, 2009 4:19 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Do you really think the Jags are done with Garrard?
They gave him a big contract and he had a down year, but I really don’t think they’re giving up on him yet – would you? There are other reasons the team had an off year, including a poor DL(despite drafting D. Harvey & Q. Groves) and injuries. My guess is that if they really are having doubts about Garrard, they’ll take another QB later in the draft. New GM Gene Smith won’t want to repeat the team’s poor drafts of recent years.
by MontanaPass on Apr 23, 2009 11:54 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
ORAKPO! ORAKPO! ORAKPO
1. Lions – Matthew Stafford, QB
2. Rams – Jason Smith, OT
3. Chiefs – Eugene Monroe, OT
4. Seahawks – Aaron Curry, LB
5. Browns – Jeremy Maclin, WR
6. Bengals – Andre Smith, OT
7. Raiders – Michael Crabtree, WR
8. Jaguars – Mark Sanchez, QB
9. Packers – B.J. Raji, DT
10. 49ers – Brian Orakpo, OLB/DE
Orakpo is a big-time playmaker. I would be more than happy if we get him.
49ers are the sh*t, the rest are poop stains.
by henrybuehrle on Apr 23, 2009 10:55 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Top 10 mockaroo!
What I really think will happen with the top 10 picks is that either the Redskins or Bucs will make a move with the Jags or 9ers to get Sanchez, but if that doesn’t happen here’s a no-trade mock:
- Lions – Matt Stafford QB – attempting to emulate Atlanta but it won’t work – Stafford is no Matt Ryan and could very well be another Alex Smith.
- Rams – Eugene Monroe OT – a better pass blocker than J. Smith to take O. Pace’s spot.
- Chiefs – A. Curry LB – GM Pioli will take BPA, especially if he’s a LB and they can’t trade down.
- Seahawks – M. Crabtree WR – they’re looking to win this year with a little help from the draft.
- Browns – Brian Orakpo DE/OLB – WR B. Edwards is staying put and they need a pass rush desperately.
- Bengals – Justin Smith OT – the Bungles OL needs 2 OTs and a C.
- Raiders – Michael Johnson DE – Crazy Al loves his freakish athleticism, and it’s Johnson’s turn this year.
- Jaguars – B.J. Raji – unless they trade, Raji plugs a big hole in the middle of the DL.
- Packers – M. Oher OT – with Raji gone, they settle for a LT.
- 49ers – A. Smith OT – solidifies the OL for 6-10 years.
by MontanaPass on Apr 23, 2009 11:43 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Its looking like there is now a decent chance Crabtree falls all the way to 10….. I find that the most exciting potential pick. Though I’d be happy with any of the top 3 OTs or Orakpo as well.
Thing A
by sam23 on Apr 23, 2009 12:06 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
why would niners trade up? to get? andre smith?
this looks bad if the niners do this, #1, why for Andre Smith? Michael Oher? but maybe Eugene Monroe, Mark Sanchez or Michael Crabtree, yes because they do need an offensive lineman to move Joe Staley to the right side, Sanchez to be the future franchise QB if Shaun Hill will leave after contract and Sanchez will battle Alex Smith, or Crabtree, the most complete WR in the draft that compares to me, Calvin Johnson, huge and very talented.
by kdogg702 on Apr 23, 2009 1:33 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
The Niners won't trade up. I didn't see anywhere where that is suggested.
McC said that most teams in the top10 would really like to trade down, including the 49ers. The only way the niners could trade down is if Stafford, Sanchez or Crabtree falls to # 10. I can then see the Jets trading up to get Sanchez. It is more than likely that the Jets will trade up to # 8 or even higher to get Sanchez.
Personally if the niners get A. Smith, Oher, Crabtree, Raji or even Orakpo it would be a good choice.
"Whether you think you can, or you think you can't, either way, YOU'RE RIGHT !"
by Eastbayjim on Apr 23, 2009 2:10 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
As much as...
… I like Crabtree, no one in this draft is worth jumping four to five spaces up in the top 10 to grab, including Crabtree.
by sfgfan on Apr 24, 2009 9:45 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
my first round for review I suppose
this is the one in “predict the pick” as well. dont you guys be stealing it. lol
1. DET- Matt Stafford
2. STL- Jason Smith
3. KC- Eugene Monroe
4. SEA- Aaron Curry
5. CLE- Michael Crabtree
6. CIN- BJ Raji
7. OAK- Jeremy Maclin
8. JAX- Mark Sanchez
9. GB- Brian Orakpo
10. SF- Andre Smith
11. BUF- Michael Oher
12. DEN- Aaron Maybin
13. WAS- Rey Malaluga
14. NO- Michael Jenkins
15. HO – Tyson Jackson
16. SD-Brian Cushing
17. NYJ- Josh Freeman
18. DEN- Peria Jerry
19. BUF- Everette Brown
20. DET- Eben Britton
21. PHI- Knowshon Moreno
22. MIN- William Beatty
23. NE- Darius Butler
24. ATL- Ron Brace
25. MIA- Vontae Davis
26. BAL- Robert Ayers
27. IND- Hakeem Nicks
28. BUF- James Laurenitis
29. NYG- Donald Brown
30. TEN- Darrius Heyward-Bey
31. ARI- Chris Wells
32. PIT- Jarron Gilbert
by GreatOden'sRaven on Apr 23, 2009 2:08 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
19 is Tampa
1. Aaron Curry- He has gone on record as saying he would take the money from last year’s number 1 overall sounds like Stafford wants more dough. They need to face the fact that they will be the worst in the division next season and the QB’s look betterl.
2. Jason Smith- Drafting too high for a WR and too high for Orakpo. Still a chance they may go Orakpo but I doubt it.
3. Tyson Jackson- Pass Rush and Run Support.
4. Mark Sanchez- They won’t plan on drafting this high next year from a better QB crop, they’ll get a LT or RT 2nd round, if not the pick is Orakpo.
5. BJ Raji- Sounds like they don’t like Crabtree’s diva attitude!!
6. Eugene Monroe
7. Michael Crabtree- Raiders will not pass on Crabtree period!!
8. If Orakpo goes to Seattle Jets trade to get here
9. Michael Oher or Everette Brown
10. Jeremy Maclin- Pleeeeease get him!! He’s no Teddy Ginn Jr., he’s more like a swolen devin hester or Ginn with a decent pair of hands. 100 plus passes with that type of speed- Offense needs a playmaker!!
LG
by rlott#42 on Apr 23, 2009 10:36 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Maclin’s highlights are ridiculous – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wzrltr66LqI
by Neon on Apr 24, 2009 12:03 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 






















