Mike Singletary Approval Rating, Painful Loss Edition

While I’m sure his staff likes working with him because he’s not a micromanager, apparently he is not holding them accountable for the mistakes. The team has obviously not been as well prepared as our opponents have and has lacked a comprehensive gameplan. We have been outcoached and that falls on Sing’s watch. I’m starting to feel like it may take too long for him to develop a successful HC managerial style.

Without their schematic expertise.

does not deserve high approval anywhere.

Thinking it should be around a four or five, solely because I think every facet of this team is collapsing. Yes, that mainly falls on the HC, but maybe I’m feeling nice. Evidently not, because I voted three.

I’ve seen it with my own eyes, and clearly Sing is not our long term solution to get us #6. he’s a good person, and great football mind but simple game management mishaps and stubborn gameplans have our team lost and confused. Belichek, mike smith, even blubbering Rex Ryan are out their getting their teams in position to do one thing, win!

If we had gone at least 8-8 or better and a playoff birth, I’d have no problem with him coming back. But Sing and A. Smith have sunk their own ship.

   to be getting rid of nolan that i threw singletery not having any experience as a coordinator right out the door oh how was i wrong.This mentality of you can’t break singletery will is a load of BS cuzz last time i checked he’s not suiting up his speaches are done his over the top confidence is done n his arrogance is done.Coaching expirience has alot to do with it just look at the GIANTS across the bay bochy has expirience.It hurts me to jump of off singletery band-wagon cuzz i was one of his die-hard supporters but its not working n the sooner that jed accepts it the better this team will be.

Sign can’t be trusted to meddle in the offense or defense and is not competent to inspire. There is nothing for him to do anymore except bizarrely yell at the referees like a chained up dog. I sincerely do not understand his purpose or value to the team anymore. He doesn’t understand his own other other teams well enough to be a head coach now.

Yes, from 2003-2010 the team has been horrible. But it is still getting worse. This can change, as NFL franchises can become contenders pretty quickly today (maybe not be elite teams, but contend at the half mark of the season). Something can and should be done right now. The best move would be to hire a good GM, who would evaluate the Coach.

I just really don’t know how much a coach affects the team because I’ve never played on a proper team.

But since you don’t have to know to have an opinion, my feeling is that we can fire Sing and still not solve many problems.

I’ll keep bringing this up because it bothers me, but Wade Phillips is no better a coach than Mike Singletary, except his paycheck comes from “America’s Team”.

I thought Sing was going to be the new identity of the 49ers. Ha. After the first regular season game that dream was shattered.

You can’t win on will power and might. It also takes game planning and adjustments, which are what coaches are supposed to do. You can’t will Alex Smith to be great, or even to be healthy the full season behind an O-line with two rookies. What was your backup plan? I don’t see one. In fact, I don’t see anything besides blind faith guiding this man. That’s fine for religion, not for football.

I was actually at the game on Sunday. After Carr was put in as the starter and Smith was nowhere to be seen I checked out the sideline to see if i could find Carr meeting with the coaches to go over the offense and what they were going to do in their next drive to win the game. Every time I looked down there Carr was walking around by himself with his helmet in his hand. That is not coaching.

Doesn’t get much worse than this.

Would be a major improvement at this point…

Because I like to exaggerate

Same as last vote. 1 for 1 win.

but not the worst possible job I can imagine.

Consider that I’ve never voted below a 5 prior to this though.

Dude sucks. Team sucks. 1.

how people will defend, make excuses for, justify, and irrationally plead FOR YEARS for A Smith..

Singletary cannot make players make plays.
Clearly players from every facet have not made significant plays at signifcant times.
Are they responding to him. Yes. A.Smith’s performance is proof of it.

After watching the raiders, I’ve seen teams give up. The niners are not giving up, they are still playing hard.

He’s a young coach in his 2nd year. Give the man a chance.

Same blunders. He does not adapt, adjust or learn. My best rating last year was a 7 because he deserved to be cut some slack in his first year.

But I’ve held the rating at 3 since the middle of last quarter of the Kansas City game when he has Gore and SMith playing in a game that was over, and got Morgan hurt on a meaningless TD.

Lack of a GM is no excuse for the lousy job by the coaching staff. Team is inadequately coached and adrift.

heck even the last game goes a different direction with a bounce of the ball, an referree call, or made play—- people on here would be giving him high scores.

the fact is, us fans are emotional, and irrational.
A win the man’s a saint, All these losses the man’s the devil incarnate.

I’ll be the first to admit the stammering of I’ve got to look at the film has gotten old. But seriously, what’s he supposed to say, “Good question, our guys really stunk it up out there and we are not the confident team we started the season as, and now my mercurial starting qb is even out, and I dont know if Im getting canned by the team president next week.”

What is going on here is our reaction to how the Team is doing.

I just love clown shows, those guys crack me up. I’d like to see them wear those honking noses and juggle those yellow hankies.

My favorite drinking game is based on the 9ers. 1 drink for a dive on first down, 2 drinks for a dive on 2nd down, 3 drinks on 3rd, 4 drinks for a dive play on 3rd and long. The winner is whomever makes it past halftime.

This next Sunday is going to be brutal, the coaches don’t trust Carr to throw the ball. I’m not sure my drinking game is going to go well. The clowns should be fun to watch though. GO NINERS!!!

I still like the guy, but losing to Carolina is inexcusable.

First time the Singletary Approval shows up in ages, and the choices are divided in 10 instead of the simple Yes/No ?

That’s how I feel, right now, with the staff that we have. I guess, right now, to give you an honest answer, I’m going to have to look at the film and go from there. I mean, Mike Singletary is our guy for now. I think as coaches, they have to do a better job knowing that they have rookies, a lot of rookies, and just making sure that everybody is on the same page; and they need to do better with that. The biggest thing, right now, in the game, that they need to realize is they need to execute, hit em in the mouth with smashmouth coaching. I mean, this guy, has some of the tools but isn’t quite where we want him to be. So to answer your question, right now, how do I feel about Sing? I’m going to have to look at the film and see what was there.

But I’m thinking I should have voted 1. 10 possible points, we’re in the bottom tenth of the league. When asked earlier how much of the blame he feels he shoulders, Singletary said “all of it”. Pretty hard for me to give him any more credit than he gives himself.

I’m thinking maybe “We Look at Film”