2010 Under Armour Senior Bowl Recap
This past weekend we saw the best Senior's of their class at their respective positions take the field of battle. Although there were impressive performances on both sides from specific players, the North team coached by Jim Schwartz and the Detroit Lions coaching staff beat the South team led by Tony Sparano and the Dolphins coaching staff by a score of 31-13.
There were several players that's stock fell and some that took flight. However, all eyes were on Senior Quarterback Tim Tebow and most of them were looking away or covering their eyes peaking through the crevasses of their fingers a majority of the time. Disastrous would be one way to categorize the performance this past Saturday and completely disastrous would be another way depending on how you feel about Tim Tebow. I guess it could have gone worse, but for someone trying to make a case for themselves and trying to prove the critics wrong, it didn't go as he hoped as I would imagine. To sum it up, here are a few post-game quotes after the game:
"It's simple, he's just not a very good quarterback prospect," one National Football League scout told the National Football Post this week.
With his performance at the Senior Bowl, "Tebow nearly guaranteed that he will not be drafted in the first round, or even the second round," suggested the Bleacher Report.
ESPN’s Todd McShay said he "is just not comfortable as a pro-style quarterback."
On the other side of all of this, there was Michigan's Senior Defensive End, Brandon Graham who took home the Under Armour Senior Bowl MVP Honor. Graham played relentless football and flew in on nearly every single play that he was in for. Before the game, he had mostly been projected as a second rounder or late first at best. In that game he solidified a first round pick, no doubt.
The Purpose of this article this morning is to take a look at some of the players that had games good enough to make their draft stock status' rise; on the other side of that, we'll take a look in to some that have fallen as well. With that, let's take a look at some of the other players after the jump.
TOP 5 PLAYERS WHOSE STOCK WENT UP:
1. Brandon Graham (Defensive End) Michigan:
Graham, as mentioned above had a spectacular game and won the MVP Award. He had 5 Tackles, 3 Tackles for Loss for 14 yards, 1 Fumble Forced, and 2 Sacks. Enough said, he earned the MVP hands down.
2. Patrick Robinson (Cornerback) Florida State:
Patrick Robinson had a spectacular game and showed the scouts that he has talent in both coming up and laying the big hits on guys and is just as good in defending the pass. He had 6 Tackles, and a pass break-up that he nearly intercepted.
3. Mardy Gilyard (Wide Reciever) Cincinnati:
Gilyard showed all the scouts what he had been showing his team and coaches the entire season; that he is worth mention in first round selection discussions. Gilyard stretched the field a couple times and came up with 5 Catches for 103 Yards. His best reception came on a 43 yarder which was also the Touchdown.
4. Jeremy Williams (Wide Receiver) Tulane:
I wasn't completely sold on all the hype as far as Williams was concerned until Saturday's game. Williams made some very tough catches in traffic. I am sure the scouts were as impressed as I was. Williams had 6 Catches for 87 Yards with his longest on a 37 Yarder. He also had a 27 yard run on a reverse which gave him 109 all-purpose yards.
5. Zane Beadles (Offensive Line) Utah:
I paid very close attention to the Offensive Line and for reasons in which should be obvious to Niners fan's. For others, in case you were unaware last year, our Line was abysmal at best in alot of situations. In any case, Beadles, when in, gave up nothing to the defenders in front of him. He handled himself very well, used his arms with out holding and still managed to out man the guy in front of him.
TOP 5 PLAYERS WHOSE STOCK STATUS HELD STEADY:
1. Taylor Mays (Free Safety) USC:
Mays showed improvements in the way he played his game this past Saturday. Mays managed to get a pick in the game, had a pass break up, and had 2 Tackles. His stats weren't great and he missed a couple tackles that if he would have wrapped up, would have been able to make. Other than that Mays proved to be very "coachable" and alot of the things he said lead me to believe that he can be a very solid safety in the NFL.
2. Dexter McCluster (Wide Reciever/ Running Back) Ole Miss:
The one thing that McCluster proved this past weekend is that he more than likely be a true running back in the NFL. There were a few plays that he got destroyed in the backfield. He will be effective if a team can use him in the screen pass game but I suspect he will primarily be used as a wide receiver; possibly a slot. As a Running Back, McCluster had 3 Carries for 4 Yards but was Tackled for a loss of -5 Yards with a total net of -1 Yard. Receiveing, McCluster had 3 Catches for 30 Yards. He was however somewhat impressive in the return game.
3. LeGarrette Blount (Running Back) Oregon:
Blount had his off field issues, we all know, but his play during the game was somewhat streaky. He did demonstrate that he had power and he did manage a touchdown that was led mostly by great blocking in to the endzone. At times, when he got the chance, Blount appeared to be lacking speed. There were times when he hit the edge and asked myself, "That's it?". Blount's character will have a red flag attached to it for his actions against Boise State and I think that is why his projections should remain the same. He didn't do enough to "awe" the scouts this past weekend.
4. Tony Pike (Quarterback) Cincinnati:
Pike did some good things and bad things. I think that he can be a very good Quarterback at the next level but anyone who saw the game knows that he has things that could be better. Being that he will have a Quarterback Coach at the next level, he may be able to start in the NFL someday. Pike was 5-12 for 45 Yards. He did not have much playing time so I am not sure the scouts got to see enough of him to make a sound call on his potential.
5. Sean Weatherspoon (Linebacker) Missouri:
Weatherspoon had a pretty good game with 5 Tackles, 1 for a loss, and an interception that he returned 57 Yards for a touchdown, He also had one pass deflection. What I noticed with Weatherspoon as that once an offensive lineman engaged a block on him, it was hard for him to rip away from it. Scouts I am sure didn't miss it and he will at the next level, need to learn how to get out of those quicker.
TOP 5 PLAYERS WHOSE STOCK DROPPED:
1. Tim Tebow (Quarterback) Florida:
Tebow as stated above did not have the best game. He fumbled the ball a couple times and his passes did not look great. Coach Sparano seemed to decide against giving Tebow any passes 10+ Yards. His longest pass was 11 Yards. It just wasn't his best college moment and could have very well been his worst. Playing against other guys that are going to to be playing on Sunday's, exploited Tebow's weaknesses.
2. Mike Iupati (Guard) Idaho:
Alot of folks were high on Iupati before this game but I suspect that there are some question marks after his performance (or should I say lack there of) on Saturday. Iuptati did not have a completely horrible game but he was beat more than he should have.
3. George Selvie (S. Florida) Defensive End:
Selvie only recorded 1 Tackle and for the most part, much like his season this year, he was non-existent. He could not really get off blocks and didn't have much of a motor.
4. Eric Norwood (S. Carolina) Linebacker:
Same thing as Selvie... Although he didn't have a ton of playing time, he didn't capitalize on the opportunities he got. Norwood also only recorded 1 Tackle.
5. Stafon Johnson (Running Back) USC:
As much as I wanted to see him do well, I am thinking that Johnson may go undrafted and have to work his way on to a team through a practice squad. It's unfortunate due to the accident, but if he really wants to play, he is going to have to work twice as hard as anyone else. I wish him the best. He had 4 carries for 9 Yards but had a 6 yard loss on one of the carries which left him with a net of 3 yards on 4 carries.
As much as I would like to do write ups on every single player that had playing time in this game, it would just take too long to do it for 100+ players. These were just the top players that stood out to me. Feel free to discuss other players and where you feel that they would fit in to these three categories.
54 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Jeremy Williams not a D/F afterall?
I hate to do this but I have to lol! I lobbied for a higher grade on the Willaims pick after your analysis came out and we agreed we’d hold judgement till after the Senior Bowl game where he’d be playing against better players (Brandon Ghee). He was named the Most Outstanding player for the South. His stats also didnt inlcude a nice catch on a curl in the second half where he scooped-up a low thrown ball that was called incomplete but upon replay showed he actually caught it.
Pick 61 — Jeremy Williams [WR] (Tulane) Grade = D
This is very very high for Williams here. He is projected more along the lines of a fourth to fifth round type of guy. While they do need a bit of help at the wide receiver position and Braylon Edwards possibly on the way out in to free agency, the player here just doesn’t make a ton of sense to me. This would have been an F for me if I didn’t take in to consideration of the position.
Williams
I reserved my right to with hold judgment and you ended up being correct. I had trouble seeing it in Williams because of the conference he played in asd the level of competition. I watched a bit of him in the season and he looked to be nothing more than an average wide receiver. However, after his performance against a higher level of competition, he could very well go where you had him at now after that game.
Your grade should be higher now but you have to understand where I was coming from. He wasn’t rated too highly before this. I think the highest I had seen him was 3rd round.
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
weird...
I saw him going round 2-3 in most of the mocks i looked at. However, i have noticed over the years that too often skill players like wrs are slotted higher in mocks than they actually go. This was especially apparent in 2008 mock drafts where guys like Desean Jackson, Malcom Kelly, Limas Sweed, James Hardy, Early Doucet and Mario Manningham were all regularly projected in the first round in mocks. None ended up going in the 1st.
plus Draftek
the other site youre affiliated with has him ranked as a 2nd round prospect. This is all debatable and every site will have different rankings. My only issue was with you saying it was way too early when there was no other wr available that was universally recognized as being ranked higher. Even if that was your opinion, there were other boards that had him ranked higher than Thomas, Decker, and Gilyard.
With that being said, I still think you did an excellent job organizing and running the mock draft. With our next draft to speed things up, after you say “###### is on the clock”, the person who is picking should quickly post “here” so we know immediately whether or not to have you or someone else pick for them. Sometimes we waited for 10 min only to realize the person left. If after 2 min the person doesnt say here, then you make the pick…..just a suggestion.
That is a good idea. I think for the next one, I will somewhat incorporate that. I think I will do a roll call an hour or so ahead of time. Those who do not show, their teams will be re-assigned ahead of time. The “here” thing may be incorporated as well. Thanks for the input.
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
Both are good ideas.
Roll call is good, but also a HERE reply is good as well. I may be signed in about an hour ahead of time for Roll Call, but since it was a 5 hour draft, may get distracted and miss my turn. Wouldn’t happen to me, but I’m sure SOME people.
...Players Whose Stock...
Sharlon Schoop - de favoriete Nederlandse honkbalspeler van McCovey Chronicles.
You always have to be one step ahead of your drunk friends
--Daisy Owl
I think Weatherspoon's stock rose...
D. Washington from TCU also played very well.
What we've got here is a failure to communicate.
Weatherspoon
I almost put him on the “went up” list but then I got an email from the other site I am offiliated with (DraftTek) and some of them made some valid points on whether or not Weatherspoon should move up on their big board.
The thing with Weatherspoon is that he’s the one OLB of the group who isn’t a pass rusher.
We have a process for preparing the Big Board, which I created a few years ago and Chuck currently handles on my behalf. The process involves using existing scouting services to prepare the player rankings.
Yes, Weatherspoon had 17 tackles against Navy — so did Andrew Sendejo of Rice — other future stars that had big tackle games against Navy include the following:
Andrew Sendejo (Rice) 17 tackles
Andrew Rodriguez (Army) 15 tackles
Dominique Midgett (Wake Forest) 15 tackles
Thomas Majors (Western Kentucky) 14 tackles
John Falgout (Air Force) 13 tackles
M. Wilkerson (Temple) 13 tackles
Antonio Baker (Louisiana Tech) 12 tackles
Brand Gilbeaux (Delaware) 11 tackles
Chase Kennemer (SMU) 11 tackles
I think I have explained this before, but the reason a number of seniors dropped is due to a weighting factor I placed on underclassmen, just in case they did not declare for the NFL Draft. Once they officially declared, that weighting factor was removed and underclassmen moved up — that is the reason Sean dropped from the previous #22 ranking.
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
He's ranked #22?
Well then I don’t think he needed to move up in their board.
I said his stock rose because some people thought he wasn’t a 1st round prospect.
I think he proved those people wrong.
What we've got here is a failure to communicate.
by SportsChicken on Feb 1, 2010 3:35 PM PST up reply actions
Jeff Byers
I went to high school with Jeff Byers at Loveland High so I notice when his name gets called. He played Center for the South team from USC. There was one end around play where he ended up being the lead blocker down field. Its amazing to watch a center take off running full speed down the side line leading the charge. The announcers noticed it too and said that as he stand right now he’s a 4 or 5th round pick, but if he stays there thats a steal.
Tim Tebow
I still can’t see the Jaguars passing on Tebow at #10. They need to put people in the stands. Maybe now, all the teams will agree to pass on Tebow until the Jaguars are on the clock in Round 2. However, it’s very likely Tebow ends up a Jaguar, regardless of how his stock does.
by Andrew Davidson on Feb 1, 2010 11:56 AM PST reply actions
How is a Quarterback sitting on the bench going to put people in the stands? I have never understood this argument. In case you missed the Pro Bowl, Garrard looked pretty good. They spent all that money on him just 2 years ago. I think it is highly unlikely that they select him at 10. That is a HUGE reach to put “people in the stands” for someone who most likely wont see playing time on an NFL field for a couple years or so.
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
I'm not saying it's smart
I’m not saying it would be people in the stands, but the Jaguars have made it known in various sources that they plan to select Tebow if given the chance. I think the move would be a terrible decision (taking Tebow at 10).
However, Garrard’s play in the Pro Bowl is your argument? Are you serious? Team’s aren’t allowed to blitz or play press coverage in the pro bowl. Garrard was one of the worst red zone QBs in the league this season.
by Andrew Davidson on Feb 1, 2010 12:13 PM PST up reply actions
Actually Wayne Weaver has mentioned that he would take the BPA to fill their team needs and has also stated that he likes the current Quarterback situation. He didn’t out right say that he wouldn’t take Tebow, but it does suggest they aren’t goint o waste a pick on something they are set at.
Garrard- The Jags Oline was 25th in the NFL in sacks allowed. They gave up 44 sacks. We saw it against us, they don’t really have an Oline. Their Oline makes ours look good. If he had a decent Oline (which I think they could draft high), then maybe Garrard would have better red zone stats. Not to mention, that little Hercules get’s the rock mostly inside the 20. You make a valid point about the blitzing in the Pro Bowl game, but he demonstrated that with enough time, he can deliver it with precision and on time. His TD pass looked squeaky clean to me.
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
I think we can agree
that the Jags taking Tebow at 10 is a mistake. Especially considering many of Garrard’s woes were because of a poor OL. I don’t rule out the Jags drafting Tebow, because it’s the same franchise that thought it would be a good idea to draft Matt Jones in the first round a few years back.
by Andrew Davidson on Feb 1, 2010 1:34 PM PST up reply actions
Matt Jones
Hopefully they learned their lesson. Besides, Jones ultimately ended up a WR. I think they will bank on Tebow (if they want him), being there later on.
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
Tebow is also the kind of QB they like
Big, strong, mobile (Byron Leftwich, David Garrard, Tim Tebow).
And hey Garrard made the pro-bowl this year, so he must’ve turned out ok, right?
Yes Drew K, Tim Tebow will probably get picked in the first round.
Jags can't take Tebow in the 2nd
because they don’t have a 2nd round pick this year. If they want him they have to take him in the 1st
Yes Drew K, Tim Tebow will get picked in the first round.
10th is WAY too high for Tebow. I bet they chance it (if they want him) and hope he’s there still in the 3rd.
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
It is the same?? I don’t get it I guess… did you change it to “probably”?
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
I don't think Tebow will go in the 2nd to any team outside of Florida now
He’ll be lucky to go in the 4th if the Florida teams don’t pick him in the 3rd
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Feb 2, 2010 5:46 PM PST up reply actions
is graham a sleeper now
Or if he,s goes and over achieves at that combine he might get snatch in the 2nd rd just don’t think 49ers will reach 4 him that high maybe 3rd rd need 2 see more film on him but he can lockdown that opposite side if not go get j.peppers or r.seymoure as long as they’re not trying 2 break the bank just a couple of pieces from having a truly top 5 defense we need 2 use this draft 4 OL , DB, LB, and special team game changer whether we got that with us now which i doubt wouldn’t be talking about spiller ,we had cory sheets i think from texas a&m i may be wrong but he was in punt return and kick returns and was having a good pre-season running the rock what the niners do drop him go figures and it turned around and bit them in the ass did’t get nothing 4 trading are kick returner 2 dallas didn’t really get nothing there so im hoping the niners can adress there DL need in free agency so we can use the draft 2 get younger and faster and more dept
He was probably gonna slide into the 2nd round anyways
I think after that performance he’s a solid top end of the 2nd round pick.
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Feb 2, 2010 5:47 PM PST up reply actions
You can't use Bleacher Report as a credible source though Drew...
It’s a collection of fans like those posting here, writing quasi-articles on sports. I know, I used to write a ton of baseless articles there too. There are only a few writers there who really know what they’re talking about.
"If I were to walk down a dark alley in a bad part of town, I'd want Ray Brown with me. And if I were to have a nice dinner at a fine restaurant, I'd want Ray Brown with me." The Late Great McKittrick
How about the 4 guys
on Around the Horn today on ESPN… or Jim Rome… or pretty much everybody who holds all the same opinions?
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
that's fine
i’m just saying not to cite B/R. That’s like citing the guys in the bar watching the game.
"If I were to walk down a dark alley in a bad part of town, I'd want Ray Brown with me. And if I were to have a nice dinner at a fine restaurant, I'd want Ray Brown with me." The Late Great McKittrick
Noted. I suppose I could have spent more time looking for quotes but it was just one of the first ones that popped up. I dont like refferencing them usually but in this case, I didn’t think it mattered too much.
The Tim Tebow Story "A Bust In The Making" ...Part 2 Coming After The Draft...Stay Tuned.
“It’s simple, he’s just not a very good quarterback prospect,” one National Football League scout told the National Football Post this week
ESPN’s Todd McShay said he “is just not comfortable as a pro-style quarterback.”
-———————————————————————————————————————————
Are you sure these quotes are not about Alex Smith ?,lol
Off topic again:
You constantly go out of your way to make mean comments about Smith that seldom fit the context. Do your ever get tired of dumping on Smith? Do you think that the more often you say mean things the more likely he will disappear? Do you believe your comments can influence others, especially Singletary? It gets really old very fast.
Not off topic at all.
The subject of the quotes was about Tebow. There were several articles in recent days about Tebow possibly becoming a Niner. So,to compare the two (Tebow and smith) is a natural thing. You must admit that those 2 quotes sure do sound like they are about smith and not Tebow.
(I don’t think we need Tebow and really don’t think he is going to be really good in the NFL,sort of like alex has been. (sorry if the truth hurts you)
They don’t hurt anyone, but they are mean and meaningless. The same kind of comments were made about Steve Young when he was dumped by Tampa Bay about 20 years ago. Fortunately, Bill Walsh had other ideas. I believe a better attitude toward Smith is “wait and see.”
I have seen and am very dissapointed in what I have seen and am waiting for a better QB (nate davis !).
How long should we wait,he was drafted in 2005,it’s 5 years of wasted time that we could have had a good QB . We could afford to wait until now because the roster was not all that good and we were not going anywhere anyway. BUT now we have a real chance to be a great team in the next years ahead,all we really need a QB . We can’t wait anymore,sorry. Alex will get his 4th “last” chance in 2010,and if he fails once again,Nate Davis will get his shot. Our window of opportunity is opening right now,but without a great QB,we will just be one of the average teams who make the playoffs but are defeated by teams that have a great QB. Alex is simply not a very good football player,it’s really that simple.I hope he does better,but better than his usual is not nearly good enough.
If you’re going to reinterpret or intentionally misinterpret what I write then productive debate is impossible. I did not compare Smith to Young in a favorable manner; I used Young as an example of why it is a mistake to decide too soon that a QB will not develop. But since you brought it up here is a comparison of Young and Smith at the age of 25:
Steve Young and Alex Smith’s at age 25:
………..Steve Young…Alex Smith
PA:……….. 363……….. 344
PC:……….. 195……….. 208
Pct:………..53.7…………60.5
TD:……….. 8……………17
INT:……….13………….12
QB Rating….65.5………..80.2
This, of course, proves nothing about Smith’s future.
but it does
show that people with Smith’s type of performance at 25 CAN go on to be successful. 2010, answer time.
"If I were to walk down a dark alley in a bad part of town, I'd want Ray Brown with me. And if I were to have a nice dinner at a fine restaurant, I'd want Ray Brown with me." The Late Great McKittrick
It's weird
I never liked Tebow much in college and always thought (still think) he’d be a horrible pro-QB. I liken him, being a tar heel fan, to Tyler Hansborough who, simply, was a beast in college, but just isn’t suited to the pro-game. However, like Hansborough, I think there’s a reserve-role for Tebow in the pros because of his athleticism and versatility.
I keep finding myself thinking that I wouldn’t be terribly upset to wind up with Tebow (not as a QB) with a late 3rd or 4th round pick.
I know I’m gonna get screamed at for that one…
The one thing that McCluster proved this past weekend is that he more than likely wont be a true running back in the NFL.
"If I were to walk down a dark alley in a bad part of town, I'd want Ray Brown with me. And if I were to have a nice dinner at a fine restaurant, I'd want Ray Brown with me." The Late Great McKittrick
We will have our return man
Even if we aren’t able to get Spiller in the 1st, I wouldn’t be surprised to see the other most likely PR candidates (McCluster, Arenas, Ford) dropping past the 1st round. We can easily end up with one of them.
by Mangoman1 on Feb 1, 2010 4:45 PM PST via mobile reply actions
Trindon Holliday
He should be around as late as the 4th or 5th.
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Feb 2, 2010 5:50 PM PST up reply actions
I like gilyard in the 2nd round
49ers are the best there was the best there is and the best there ever will be
by swagger on Feb 1, 2010 5:31 PM PST via mobile reply actions

by 




























