Niners Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Off Tackle Empire interviews Rich Rodriguez

Cream of the Crop: 1st Round (1999-2009)

This is a new segment that I talked with Fooch about and decided to roll out this evening. It was inspired from a comment by one of our regulars Eastbayjim... so thank you for the idea Jim, this one's for you.

We are approximately 35 days away until the day of the draft and have roughly five weeks to provide you with the best picks of the last ten years of each round in those years. We will begin with the first round which will be followed by the second round, and so on down the line to until we reach the seventh.

Throughout the years and history of the NFL, there have been great players to come out of each round of the draft. We wanted to narrow it down to the last ten years to consolidate the process.

I would like to preface this article and new segment by stating that these are of course just my opinions, and you certainly are  entitled to agree, disagree, or give alternative players as better options if you see fit. If I feel there is too close to the same amount of success between two or three players to be considered as the "cream of the crop" in their respective draft year, I may include a player or two that is worthy of notable mention. This process is mainly just to help us see what type of players were chosen when, where, and who got lucky enough to obtain the services of each of them.

I hope you all enjoy this new piece for the next five weeks. It will be one more thing to help us get through the stretch leading up to the much anticipated draft which begins the eve of April 22nd. Follow me after the jump to see who has made the list.

Star-divide

1999 DRAFT

Donovan McNabb (2nd pick overall, Eagles) Syracuse

I take myself back to the future in Marty McFly's time machine to 1999 and all I can see from this particular draft is the erruption of boo's that commenced once Donovan McNabb's name was announced as the 2nd overall pick for Philadelphia. Little did they know that he would indeed amount to a very successful franchise quarterback and the quarterback who was selected before him (Tim Couch) wouldn't. While some Eagles fans still are discontent with McNabb as their quarterback, I think a bunch of fans from other teams who have struggled in the past decade would have loved to have had McNabb come to their cities to play.

McNabb has led his team to the playoffs several times through the course of his career and from his selection in '99 didn't take but a couple years to become a star. His most notable season was the 2004-05 Season when he led the Eagles in to Superbowl XXXIX, which they fell short by only 3 points. It was a big disappointment to the city of Philadelphia and I don't think they've forgotten it to this day. Whether you like McNabb and think he's still got it, or think his better days are behind him, he sure has had an amazing career. He's been to the NFC Championship game 5 times and leads the Eagles in nearly every single franchise passing record. Currently McNabb is 24th on the all-time list of passing yards and will continue to climb the ladder until he decides to retire. He also ranks 22nd in all-time passing touchdowns just behind Patriots quarterback Tom Brady.

Notable Mention: Champ Bailey  (7th overall pick, Redskins) - Georgia

 

2000 DRAFT

Brian Urlacher (9th pick overall, Bears) New Mexico

Like him or hate him, Urlacher has been a modern day Dick Butkus. Up until last year, I thought of him as the ultimate team player. When he bad mouthed the new kid in town (Jay Cutler) last year, it really made me think a lot less of him as he sat on the bench with a hand injury all season, pouting. On the field though, his talent has been undeniable. He's been the heart and soul of that defense for a lot of years. Urlacher has gone to the Pro Bowl several years in his career and even if players were not doing the voting, and it was done by alternate, less flawed method, I suspect The Bears Linebacker would have still gone to just as many.

Even though he was the 9th pick overall in this draft, there was doubt as to how his game would translate by many of the pundits due to the conference and school he was coming out of. He proved to a majority of them that he was well worth the pick and the money spent. Urlacher will go down as one of the all-time greats of that franchise and there have been some phenominal talent that has played for the Bears.

Urlacher helped his team reach Superbowl XLI which ended in a disappointing loss 29-17. The Bears defense was not conditioned enough to keep up with the high octane offense of the Colts. The defense kept it close for a few quarters, but the Bears did not have enough fire power to match the Colts heavy arsenal.

Urlacher currently sits with 1000+ Tackles, 37.5 Sacks, 17 Career Interceptions for 271 Return Yards, 8 Fumbles Forced, and 67 Pass Deflections.

Notable Mention: Thomas Jones  (7th pick overall, Arizona) *29th All-Time in career rushing yards - Virginia

 

2001 DRAFT

LaDanian Tomlinson (5th pick overall, Chargers) TCU

People said that LDT could not do it. They said he would never amount to anything. They said he was destine to be a bust when the Chargers spent a first-round pick on him. The disappointment did not last long though. And his biggest critics were silenced quickly. In his rookie year, Tomlinson rushed for 1236 Yards, and scored 10 Touchdowns. From that point on, no one questioned Tomlinson's ability until this offseason when the Chargers released the best Running Back they have ever seen in San Diego. LDT had 8 consecutive season's with 1000+ Yards rushing and has had double-digit touchdowns for the duration of his 9-year career. His best season was the '06-'07 Season when he rushed for 1852 Yards and 28... (yeah, that's not a typo)... 28 Touchdowns. Even though some may consider Tomlinson as a "has-been", he certainly wasn't a "never-will-be" like some people thought initially.

LDT currently is the 8th all-time in career rushing yards (the highest of any active player). He has the 2nd most rushing touchdowns (138) behind only Emmitt Smith (164); 26 short of the record. I think it's safe to say that Tomlinson is one of the all-time greats and should be a shoe-in for the Hall of Fame when it's all said and done.

Notable Mention: Steve Hutchinson (17th pick overall, Seattle) Michigan

 

2002 DRAFT

Julius Peppers (2nd pick overall, Panthers) North Carolina

Peppers was a dream pick for a fairly new franchise in their building process. His tangibles, since entering the league, have been off the charts. He has been an amazing pass rusher since he entered the league. If you could gauge a players talent by the size of their paycheck, I think we would all know with the recent pay day that Peppers received from the Bears that he is an extremely valuable commodity.

The Panthers Defensive End was also on the losing end of a Superbowl in Superbowl XXXVIII against the Patriots. It was one of the more intense Superbowls of the decade and Peppers was a significant contrubitor to the close game. The Panthers ultimately lost by 3 when Adam Vinateri came through with a clutch field goal in the 4th quarter to seal the victory.

Julius Peppers is currently tied with Tim Harris on the all-time sack list at 48th with 81 Career Sacks. He also has 6 Career Interceptions, 30 Fumbles Forced, and 46 Passes Deflected.

Notable Mention: Ed Reed (24th pick overall, Ravens) Miami

 

2003 DRAFT

Troy Polamalu (16th pick overall, Steelers) USC

We have all grown used to seeing Troy Polamalu make dynamic plays all over the field. He gives opposing quarterbacks and offensive coordinator's fits in trying to game plan against him. There is only so much they can do to account for Polamalu. In this decade, I don't think there is another player that brings the same kind of presence to a field as the long-haired, Head and Shoulders commercial filming safety does.

Polamalu has been on the winning side of two Superbowl teams in his career so far. Superbowl XL, in which they beat Seattle 21-10 and Superbowl XLIII, a year ago, in which they beat the Arizona Cardinals 27-23.

In just 6 Season's, the gridiron warrior has racked up some heafty stats. But some of what he brings to the table is not going to be measurable on a stat line. People always ask, "what is the it-factor?", well if anyone has "it", it's got to be a player like Troy Polamalu.

Notable Mention: Andre Johnson (3rd pick overall, Texans) Miami -- Dallas Clark (24th pick overall, Colts) Iowa

 

2004 DRAFT

Larry Fitzgerald (3rd pick overall, Cardinals) Pittsburgh

Who could argue that Fitzgerald was not the best pick in this draft? I am not talking based solely on stats. This guy brings it when he brings it if you can understand that. If you put the ball in the general vicinity of Fitzgerald, nine times out of ten he's going to come up with it somehow. Now, I understand that there could be arguments to this selection here, but if the Arizona Wide Receiver keeps on the same pace he's on now, he's going to be the only guy that comes close to any of Jerry Rice's records. The one thing that sets him apart from guys like Randy Moss is his tremendous work ethic that only a select few possess.

As it stands, Larry Fitzgerald is already extremely close to breaking in to the top 100 in all-time receiving yards in only his sixth season. He also ranks 67th in all-time receiving touchdowns. He is gaining ground fast in nearly every single all-time stat line that has anything to do with receiving. He has broken franchise records left and right and been to the Pro Bowl four times in his career so far.

He won't have a future Hall of Famer throwing him passes anymore, but with the recent departure of ex-teammate Anquan Boldin, Fitzgerald should see a lot more action. On top of it all, he is an upstanding guy and does a ton of stuff in the community. A true humanitarian.

Notable Mention: Eli Manning (1st pick overall, Giants via trade) Ole Miss -- Steven Jackson (24th pick overall, Rams) Oregon State

 

2005 DRAFT

DeMarcus Ware (11th pick overall, Cowboys) Troy

Jerry Jones just recently paid this guy big bucks to stay in Dallas for a few more years. Ware is that unique type of player that doesn't come around too often. When it's all said and done, and Ware decides to hang up the cleats, I can imagine he could be considered for the Hall of Fame. It's difficult to predict something like that this early in a players career, but if he can stay healthy, I feel it's worth saying.

Ware's rookie year, he came in and played like a veteran racking up 8 Sacks and 58 Tackles. By the end of that Season, Ware had proved to be a dominating force. That was the only year that Ware did not reach double-digits in Sacks. His best year came in the 2008-'09 Season when he accrued 84 Tackles, 20 Sacks, 6 Fumbles Forced, and 2 Passes Deflected. After a season like that, a player is bound to draw the double-teams. And that is exactly what has been happening ever since.

Ware will turn 28 this year and still has a good five years at least in front of him. DeMarcus Ware currently ranks 75th on the all-time leader board for sacks and is 16th on the leader board among active players.

Notable Mention: Shawne Merriman (12th pick overall, Chargers) Maryland -- Logan Mankins (32nd pick overall, Jets) Fresno State

 

2006 DRAFT

Vernon Davis (6th pick overall) Maryland

This was a bit of an unorthidoxed pick and was questioned quite a bit by the fan base; in the earlier years of Davis' career especially. Since the blowout with Coach Singletary, Vernon Davis went from being an immature-ego-driven young player, to a respectable veteran and team leader. The particular incident where Singletary sent Davis to the showers early made him grow up in a hurry. I think that was the turning point for Vernon Davis. He owes it all to his coach and current mentor.

Davis struggled with blocking in the first few years but has come around as of late and is considered by many folks as the best active tight end in the league. Some may argue that Antonio Gates is better, but there are just some things that Vernon can do that Gates cannot. Both tight ends mentioned there are tied in receiving touchdowns (for tight ends) in a single season with 13. Davis broke the previous 49ers franchise record that was held by Brent Jones.

In the short amount of time that he has been in the league, Davis has showed he belongs. He has 181 Career Receptions, 2097 Yards, and 22 Touchdowns in just four years.

Notable Mention: Mario Williams (1st pick overall, Texans) N.C. State  -- D'Brickashaw Furgeson (4th pick overall, Jets) Virginia

 

2007 DRAFT

Patrick Willis (11th pick overall, 49ers) Ole Miss

This has by and far been the best pick for the 49ers franchise in a very long time. Three season's and three Pro Bowls. Coach Singletary had this to say in regards to Willis just recently: "I've coached two of the greatest linebackers - one that has already proven to be one of the greatest (Ray Lewis), and one who will prove to be". Coach or not, coming from a guy of Singletary's magnitude and being that he played the position himself, that is probably the best honor a young player could ever receive.

It is amazing just how much damage and havoc Willis has inflicted on the opposition. I truly believe Singletary meant what he said about Willis and I don't believe there was any puffing going on there. Willis still has a long way to go, but he entered the league in the pole position (figuratively speaking) and stayed in the lead up to this point. It is going to be very interesting to see where his career numbers end up once it's all said and done.

So far in Willis' three years, the stats speak heavily in his favor; 467 Tackles, 9 Sacks, 4 Interceptions, 2 Touchdowns, 6 Fumbles Forced, and 26 Passes Deflected.

Notable Mention: Adrian Peterson (7th overall pick, Vikings) Oklahoma

 

2008 DRAFT

Chris Johnson (24th pick overall, Titans) ECU

5'11", 200 Pounds. Too small, right? Wrong. People have criticized some of the smaller backs like DeAngelo Williams, Maurice Jones-Drew, and Jamaal Charles, among others. I think for the most part last year, Chris Johnson put to rest some of the comments of a lot of the folks that were persistant in saying that size is an issue. He ran up the middle, to the outside, wherever he could find a sliver of an opening in the defense. His rookie year he rushed for 1000+ yards and basically took on the starting role to be the primary back in Tennesee. Last year he demolished the competition and made certain players look silly. He broke in to the elite class of 2000+ yard rushers in a single season with 2,006. Only five other players have accomplished that same feat; O.J. Simpson (2,003), Terrell Davis (2,008), Barry Sanders (2,053), Jamal Lewis (2,066) and the leader Eric Dickerson (2,105).

If Johnson has a relatively long career, and stays at an even pace, he will end up destroying many records. The problem in today's NFL is that Running Backs in particular fizzle out a bit faster than they did in the 70's, 80's, and 90's. Defenses are bigger, faster, and stronger, and did I mention bigger and faster, well let me say it again... gotcha.

It will be interesting to see how Johnson's career materializes from this point forward.

Notable Mention: Jake Long (1st pick overall, Dolphins) Michigan

 

2009 DRAFT

Brian Cushing (15th pick overall, Texans) USC

Earning the Defensive Rookie of the Year Award is the best way a player could start off their career. Patrick Willis did it and he seems to be on the right track. Cushing plays a lot like Brian Urlacher, another cream of the crop player mentioned above. The Texans are doing a lot in trying to put together a solid team. The talent is certainly there and has been for some time. I can imagine that this leaves the fans scratching their heads at the end of each season.

All the pieces are there for the Texans to advance next year, and many think it will be Coach Kubiak's last year to prove he belongs. Having a center piece to a defense like Brian Cushing certainly won't hurt matters in Houston. He's still very young but seemed to have caught on extremely fast which is a rare thing at the pro level.

Cushing finished the year with an astounding 134 Tackles, 5 Sacks, 2 Forced Fumbles, and a Safety. Great way to begin a career in the NFL.

Notable Mention: Clay Mathews Jr. (26th pick overall, Packers) USC

 

I hope this new segment, and the read was worth your while. Round 2 will be coming soon so stay tuned.

Poll
Who has been the Cream of the Crop out of these 1st Rounders in the past decade?
Donovan McNabb - 1999
48 votes
Brian Urlacher - 2000
41 votes
LaDanian Tomlinson - 2001
299 votes
Julius Peppers - 2002
13 votes
Troy Polamalu - 2003
120 votes
Larry Fitzgerald - 2004
84 votes
DeMarcus Ware - 2005
22 votes
Vernon Davis - 2006
7 votes
Patrick Willis - 2007
449 votes
Chris Johnson - 2008
39 votes
Brian Cushing - 2009
5 votes

1127 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 54 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

LT.

I AM VERY MUCH ENJOYING THE HITTING OF BASEBALLS AND SCORING OF RUNS. -mikev
only an asshole quotes himself. -mikev

by mikev on Mar 18, 2010 4:16 PM PDT reply actions  

Patrick willis is a beast

49ers are the best there was the best there is and the best there ever will be

by swagger on Mar 18, 2010 4:17 PM PDT via mobile reply actions  

Also, I'd have a pretty easy time arguing against Fitzgerald in 2004.

Well, 2 really big arguments anyway: Eli and Big Ben.

I AM VERY MUCH ENJOYING THE HITTING OF BASEBALLS AND SCORING OF RUNS. -mikev
only an asshole quotes himself. -mikev

by mikev on Mar 18, 2010 4:18 PM PDT reply actions  

Yes, only crappy players win super bowls.

Turn off your attitude, man. Jesus.

I AM VERY MUCH ENJOYING THE HITTING OF BASEBALLS AND SCORING OF RUNS. -mikev
only an asshole quotes himself. -mikev

by mikev on Mar 21, 2010 12:34 PM PDT up reply actions  

I like Willis too

but I don’t think he has done enough to overshadow what LT has done in his career. He was one of the top RB’s for the better part of a decade.

by santeelj on Mar 18, 2010 4:18 PM PDT reply actions  

Champ Bailey, too.

I AM VERY MUCH ENJOYING THE HITTING OF BASEBALLS AND SCORING OF RUNS. -mikev
only an asshole quotes himself. -mikev

by mikev on Mar 18, 2010 4:22 PM PDT up reply actions  

Tomlinson and San Diego endured a lot of criticism...

and he has had a HOF career. Everyone else is too young to judge or not good enough.

by TexansDC on Mar 18, 2010 4:21 PM PDT reply actions  

Offense – LT
Defense – Troy Polamalu

LT or Troy… Troy = 2 Rings.

Hardware over stats anyday… Unless you’re Trent Dillrag Dilfer

by LADubbz45 on Mar 18, 2010 4:38 PM PDT reply actions  

lt?

LT over mcnabb? no way. mcnab’s been to the sb and probably isn’t even done yet.

"There is no pressure. Pressure only exists when you're not prepared."
-The Samurai

Alex Smith is garbage...

by redrum21225 on Mar 18, 2010 4:50 PM PDT reply actions  

Tomlinson is one of the all-time great football players ever. McNabb, though very good, isn’t.

GROUGTHINK ALERT
The first Chester Arthur fanboy ever.

by groug on Mar 18, 2010 5:21 PM PDT up reply actions  

McNabb has cost his team 4 Super Bowls

and is one of the biggest big game choke artists in all of sports. He shouldn’t even be on the list.

Gimme 1 round!

by ItBurnzWhenIP on Mar 18, 2010 6:01 PM PDT up reply actions  

So its all on Mcnabbwhen they lose, but how about being one of the winningest QB's of this era.

How about one of the best td to int ratio’s of this era. he lays down? That is debateable, that so called defense never showed up in the big game.

Scot I didn't mean to scare you, I just wanted Berry, come back!!
Alex Smith is not a bust, he is a product of poor management and coaching.

by rlott#42 on Mar 18, 2010 6:10 PM PDT up reply actions  

indeed

and i was so glad that defense laid down.

"There is no pressure. Pressure only exists when you're not prepared."
-The Samurai

Alex Smith is garbage...

by redrum21225 on Mar 18, 2010 8:46 PM PDT up reply actions  

Any team would be happy

With 5 conference title appearances.

How many people can say that about their career?

It’s like the Bills of the early 90s. 4 straight Super Bowl losses is bad, but, in retrospect, it’s still pretty impressive.

by TexansDC on Mar 18, 2010 8:29 PM PDT up reply actions  

all in all

i’d rather have mcnab’s career than lt. people, including me, hate mcnab because we hate the eagles….n well, we hate mcnab because he craps on our teams. but you can’t deny that mcnab has done more for the eagles in both the regular and postseason than lt.

where the heck is LT during the postseason?…..he’s NOWHERE TO BE FOUND! this is the running joke on LT. i refuse to let morons biggup a postseason ghost like LT over mcnab……child please.

"There is no pressure. Pressure only exists when you're not prepared."
-The Samurai

Alex Smith is garbage...

by redrum21225 on Mar 18, 2010 8:41 PM PDT up reply actions  

Except

Jim Kelly didn’t lose to teams he was heavily favored against in those games. He played GREAT GREEEEAAAAT teams and lost (generally) close games. McNabb was playing on the favorite like 4 out of 5 times and managed to choke every game away. Even when he had T.O. come out and dominate on a broken leg he still choked it up. There is a reason Terrell threw him under the bus and the philly fans agreed with it. There is a reason that nobody wanted McNabb back when Garcia was winning with the team.

Gimme 1 round!

by ItBurnzWhenIP on Mar 21, 2010 2:06 PM PDT up reply actions  

Patrick Willis??

II love the guy as a player on my favorite team, but he has never been to the playoffs.

Scot I didn't mean to scare you, I just wanted Berry, come back!!
Alex Smith is not a bust, he is a product of poor management and coaching.

by rlott#42 on Mar 18, 2010 4:50 PM PDT reply actions  

I'd probably list Revis over Willis

But it certainly isn’t because he’s been to the playoffs. It’s not Willis’ fault that he’s had JTO, Shaun Hill, Trent Dilfer, and Alex Smith as his teammates.

by Brendan Scolari on Mar 18, 2010 5:23 PM PDT up reply actions  

I understand that, but his career doesn't even cover half of the decade, so how do you consider him over players that have produced for 8-10 seasons?

Scot I didn't mean to scare you, I just wanted Berry, come back!!
Alex Smith is not a bust, he is a product of poor management and coaching.

by rlott#42 on Mar 18, 2010 5:39 PM PDT up reply actions  

Oh I see what you are saying

I thought you were saying Willis doesn’t deserve to be the best pick in 2007.

I agree, Willis is obviously not the best pick of the decade. But we’re on a blog full of Niners homers, what do you expect? ;-)

by Brendan Scolari on Mar 18, 2010 5:45 PM PDT up reply actions  

The #1 player in 2007

Was the highest draft pick on most people fantasy boards.

Gimme 1 round!

by ItBurnzWhenIP on Mar 18, 2010 6:02 PM PDT up reply actions  

Running backs aren't worth as much as corners, have much shorter shelf lives,

and Peterson was not that great last year anyways. I’d take Willis or Revis over AP without even thinking twice.

by Brendan Scolari on Mar 18, 2010 6:07 PM PDT up reply actions  

um...

are we forgetting this is NINERs nation?

"There is no pressure. Pressure only exists when you're not prepared."
-The Samurai

Alex Smith is garbage...

by redrum21225 on Mar 18, 2010 8:50 PM PDT up reply actions  

sorry

that was in response to rlott’s comment about p willis.

"There is no pressure. Pressure only exists when you're not prepared."
-The Samurai

Alex Smith is garbage...

by redrum21225 on Mar 20, 2010 11:23 AM PDT up reply actions  

Come on guys

I’m all for hometown heroes, but this is ridiculous. More votes than almost everyone else combined? Not a chance.

by thefaithful on Mar 18, 2010 4:53 PM PDT reply actions  

I'm all for BammBamm

But I have to agree I can’t go homer here. I went Polamalu here. Like what has been said above he’s got rings and when he was injured you could see a big drop off in their game. Not many players can make that much of a difference alone. McNabbs been good but when he was hurt Garcia still got them to the playoffs.

by tanos135 on Mar 18, 2010 5:01 PM PDT up reply actions  

I'm curious about a couple of your picks

Why would you pick Pepper over Dwight Freeney or Albert Haynesworth? They were picked later (11th and 15th respectively, compared to #2 for Peppers) and are both probably better players. Certainly it’s much better to get even an equal caliber player with a pick that allows you to pay a player what, half as much as the player who gets picked #2 overall? It’s also much harder to find elite players there, so I don’t understand that one.

I originally thought Vernon Davis belonged nowhere near this list but after looking it up, the 1st round of the 2006 draft was incredibly weak. Still, I think VD is pretty overrated as a player (he led the NFL in drops and penalties amongst TE’s) . I’d say Mario Williams, Jonathon Joseph, and Nick Mangold are better players and Jay Cutler is certainly a much better value (look at what the Broncos got for him), even if he played poorly last year.

by Brendan Scolari on Mar 18, 2010 5:09 PM PDT reply actions  

The only one of your points I agree with here is that Freeney should have been ahead of Peppers but Peppers defintely would have warranted a notable mention. It was late when I was sifting through the 320 players and I overlooked Freeney.

But to your second paragraph, I don’t agree with your opinion and the value and all that. Cutler hasn’t done anything special except for get a huge paycheck. VD broke a franchise record in just a few years of play. Due to his struggles early on, people (particularly some 49ers fans) still have that memory being that it’s still relatively fresh. But when it’s all said and done, I believe VD will go down as one of the best to ever play the position. That’s he he’s there, on top of what you already mentioned with it being a very weak class.

"If you're not first, you're last" -Reese Bobby.

by Drew K on Mar 18, 2010 5:23 PM PDT up reply actions  

I wasn't aware that we were forcasting their careers

If so that makes the VD selection a lot more defensible, because i also have faith that he will be a great player going forward.

However, i do think this line of reasoning is dangerous:

VD broke a franchise record in just a few years of play.

To use a baseball analogy, I would bet that Adam Dunn also broke some franchise records while he was with the Reds, but he certainly isn’t a great player. Being great at one thing makes it a lot easier to get records, but these records don’t necessarily encapsulate greatness.

Dunn is great at hitting homeruns and getting on base, and if you only look at his offensive numbers he looks like a great player, but because of his defense and baserunning deficiencies this is not the reality.

Similiarly, if you only look at VD’s ability to get open and make plays, he looks like a great player. But because of all the opportunites that he misses (dropping quite a few more passes than any other player in football) and negatives he brings to the table (more penalties than anyone in football except for a few offensive lineman) he’s clearly not great yet. If he minimizes those things (and as I said before I believe he will) then he will be a great player.

by Brendan Scolari on Mar 18, 2010 5:34 PM PDT up reply actions  

I wasn’t aware that we were forcasting their careers If so that makes the VD selection a lot more defensible, because i also have faith that he will be a great player going forward.

With guys that have less than 5 years in the league, there’s not much of a better way to do it.

Anthony Gonzales had issues with hanging on to the ball early in his career and not many people remember that because he’s done so much to overshadow that. I think the same could end up being true for Davis.

"If you're not first, you're last" -Reese Bobby.

by Drew K on Mar 18, 2010 5:55 PM PDT up reply actions  

Yep

Surely I think he can reach his potential, and hopefully he will.

by Brendan Scolari on Mar 18, 2010 6:09 PM PDT up reply actions  

Haloti Ngata and DeAngelo Williams were also both better picks than Vernon Davis from that year

by microwave donut on Mar 19, 2010 9:44 AM PDT up reply actions  

Love me some Willis

and if you ask me in another 10 years I’d put him there.

Right now I have to go with Polamalu who is one of the best safeties of all time and a sure-fire first ballot Hall of Famer and LaDanian Tomlinson who is the most consistent of the offensive players listed and also a first ballot HOFer

Member of the legendary David Carr thread, 6 March 2010

by smileyman on Mar 18, 2010 5:25 PM PDT reply actions  

overrated

I can understand the votes for LT but polamalu? really? he isn’t even the best player at his position. Rings are nice but keep in mind it takes a team to win not just one overrated safety

by Jonny B on Mar 18, 2010 6:09 PM PDT reply actions  

Overrated safety, on the league's best defense, that falls on it's face anytime he is out?

OK, makes sense.

Scot I didn't mean to scare you, I just wanted Berry, come back!!
Alex Smith is not a bust, he is a product of poor management and coaching.

by rlott#42 on Mar 18, 2010 6:13 PM PDT up reply actions  

just looking at stats

No doubt he is a good safety but his stats are no where near as impressive as Ed Reed’s and Reed only got a noticeable mention.

by Jonny B on Mar 18, 2010 6:25 PM PDT up reply actions  

you asked with your eyes, trent

by letsgoAlex on Mar 18, 2010 6:47 PM PDT up reply actions  

Polamalu has taken over some big games though.

I know what I'm talking about, I started at right guard for the 1992 College Park Falcons.

by Johnnysixnut on Mar 18, 2010 7:31 PM PDT reply actions  

I wanna say Tomlinson was the best out of these guys, in part because his career is already in the twilight and we’re able to look back already at his best years… whereas, guys like Willis and Johnson and Fitzgerald are still kind of getting their careers started… so they really don’t deserve as much respect as a guy like LT. He has played a long time, and been on the top for nearly decade as one of the top RB’s, which is tough to even have a career for more than 4 or 5 years.

The only two that I can say that has a chance to pass him is Fitzgerald because you’re talking about a guy who can become one of the greatest receivers of all time, and then Patrick Willis who has pretty much been the best MiLB since he set foot on the field.

by aBulldog on Mar 18, 2010 9:20 PM PDT reply actions  

Wow!

You accompany this article with a photo of Aaron Rodgers, and then you don’t even mention him in the article, while naming and, Shawne (steroids) Merriman and Logan (who?) Mankins as a notable mention?
You must be damned bitter about that Alex Smith pick, Drew. HaHa.

-
The glass is more than half-full.

by NorthStarr on Mar 18, 2010 11:22 PM PDT reply actions  

I'm pretty sure

it was a picture of Patrick Willis, Rodgers just happened to be in it.

by Sebaz49 on Mar 19, 2010 7:05 AM PDT up reply actions  

It may be helpful/useful

to also include the overall selection number in order to determine who may have been the best value. Those guys on the poll are all studs, can’t argue really with any of them, but it would be a more exercise in determining value if we also included the over-all pick number.

Interesting exercise tho.

Chris Cohan- YOU'RE FIRED!

by bonbrillio on Mar 19, 2010 7:08 AM PDT reply actions  

Biased poll...

Since everyone is gonna want to vote Niners, it’s easy to say Willis. Hell, I picked him because in all likelyhood, when his career is over he will be the best at his position of all time. Regardless of playoff appearances and SB rings, you can’t deny the guys talent and he still continues to improve every year.

As for the other choices, I really only see two or three you could make an arguement for: LT, Polamalu, Fitz, and maybe mcNabb.

by 9thevolution on Mar 19, 2010 7:50 AM PDT reply actions  

Tomlinson

He had a run of 5 or 6 years where he was the best at his position in the NFL. While some other guys on here could achieve that, they haven’t yet.

by microwave donut on Mar 19, 2010 9:51 AM PDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

The only blog that enjoys VD *and* Crabs!
Start posting about the 49ers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

SPONSORS

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Photo

2010 NFL Preview, New York Jets: Mark Sanchez Bears The Burden Of Expectation

Photo

2010 NFL Preview, New England Patriots: The Tom Brady Factor

FILE - This is a Sept. 27, 2009, file photo showing Arizona Cardinals defensive tackle Darnell Dockett  coming onto the field prior to an NFL football game against the Indianapolis Colts, in Glendale, Ariz.  Darnell Dockett knows there are people who don't like him, even though they don't know him as more than anything but a big, rough football player for the Arizona Cardinals. (AP Photo/Matt York, File) +1 updates

Darnell Dockett Signs Four-Year Extension With Cardinals

More from SBNation.com >


Head Ball Coach

Dave_small David Fucillo (Fooch)

Howtheyscoredcat_small howtheyscored

James-brady_small Ninjames

Pirates_small smileyman

Coordinator

Hats_small Andrew Davidson

Referee

Jackalope_card_small wjackalope