The Cleveland Browns just released QB Derek Anderson, Who would you rather have as your back up QB Derek Anderson or David Carr. Can you really honestly say that any signing is A slam dunk , isn't the gamble just as high , As drafting A college athlete into the NFL. Some players play worst on A different team,and all fairness to the 49ers the quality of A NFL QB is limited. Whether it's A back up QB or starting QB. The talent for the NFL isn't there
[EDIT] howtheyscored's note: I added the poll because it's an interesting question. You'll see I added a few relevant options. Just because I left this thread standing, though, let's not go crazy with the Carr threads. We do have an official FanPost for general discussion on David Carr.