2010 49ers Roster Projections: Safeties
Now that we've gotten through the offensive backfield in our roster projections, I thought we'd move over to the defensive backfield, starting with the safeties. Thus far, we've discussed the quarterbacks, the running backs, and the fullbacks. As we move over to the defense, we are dealing with a position that has quite a bit of talent on the depth chart, and yet also has numerous question marks. Initially I was planning on saving this one for later in case the 49ers decided to make a run at O.J. Atogwe, but at this point, I'm fairly certain the team will not be signing Atogwe this offseason.
Locks
Dashon Goldson, Michael Lewis, Taylor Mays, Reggie Smith
Bubble
Curtis Taylor
Chris Maragos
After the jump we take a look at some of the issues surrounding the safety position. Also, the poll isn't all that specific when it comes to middle and end of the season, but consider it more just a general estimation.
Last year, the 49ers initial 53-man roster included 5 safeties: Dashon Goldson, Michael Lewis, Mark Roman, Reggie Smith, and Curtis Taylor. For many 49ers fans, the removal of Mark Roman from the equation is reason enough to be happy heading into 2010. The proverbial addition by subtraction. Of course, Roman's final season with the 49ers ended up actually being better than expected due to his solid showing in replacing an injured Michael Lewis. Nonetheless, the time has come to move forward from the Mark Roman era, if you can call it that.
I know some folks are still clamoring for O.J. Atogwe, but for the purposes of roster projections, I'm operating under the assumption that he won't be around. Given that, the battle for roster spots comes down to Curtis Taylor and Reggie Smith. Some folks want to see the team unload Michael Lewis, but I remain convinced that won't happen if he stays healthy. Well, at least for this season. He remains a strength in run support, and if Dashon Goldson can continue improving in pass protection, the team will be fine at their starting safety positions. Additionally, while Taylor Mays likely won't get the starting nod, he's certainly guaranteed a roster spot.
A little over a month ago, following the rookie minicamp, I posted an article discussing the potential roster battle between Reggie Smith and Chris Maragos. In that post, and in the article it was based on, made no mention of Curtis Taylor. I suppose that would make the roster battle between all three. Personally, though, I would be pretty surprised to see Taylor or Maragos get a spot over Smith. Smith has been plagued by injury issues during his two-year career, but when healthy has shown some solid talent.
One big plus for both Taylor and Maragos is that the team could potentially stash either of them on the practice squad. If I had to make a prediction, I'd say Taylor makes the roster and Maragos ends up on the practice squad. Even though this isn't exactly a battle for roster domination, it will be one to keep an eye on as training camp gets going.
11 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I guess it depends on how long it takes Michael Lewis to get another concussion...
but I hope he can stay healthy, at least until Mays is really ready to step in there
Mays should start by mid-season
As for the safeties that’ll be on the roster, I would definitely say only four. Lewis, Goldson, Mays and Smith will make the roster, Taylor will get the nod for PS and Maragos will get cut likely at one of the early cuts. Our secondary depth has some experienced players in Paymah and James, so I don’t see why they would keep an undrafted guy unless he really shines. I doubt we keep ten players on the 53 for the secondary, so I don’t really see how either Taylor or Maragos can make the roster unless the coaches really don’t like Smith.
Curtis Taylor NEEDS to get on the practise squad.
I don’t see Lewis on this team next year. And there is the possibility that Goldson leaves in free agency as well.
So Mays needs to get starting expierence at Strong Safety this year and have Reggie Smith and Curtis Taylor ready for the possibility that Goldson will be gone next year at Free Safety.
I survived the David Carr Press Conference Thread 3/06/2010
Credit to iaalexeeff
It's official: I'm a Buster Posey fan..... Who isn't?
by Hoopers Judge on Jun 8, 2010 2:43 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
I don't think Mays starts over Lewis or Goldson this season.
and I think if Lewis gets hurt early in the season, Reggie Smith starts. It’s not that I don’t think that Mays is going to be good. I think he’s going to be great, actually. I just don’t think he necessarily leaps over a healthy Lewis. Lewis is better than some think.
"Son, I'm going to break you like a wild horse." - Mike Singletary
Not really
Not and damn sure not worth his salary. Taylor should be starting day 1 over him. If we actually had somebody good in front of Taylor I’d say he should sit and watch for a while but not with Lewis back there.
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Jun 8, 2010 10:32 AM PDT up reply actions
Who thinks it will be beyond 2011?
8 Haters right there lol jk. Just curious is it because you are big fans of Taylor? Think Lewis will stay healthy? Or just don’t think Mays has it in him to crack the starting line up? No way our 2nd round draft pick, whom in a deep draft could be considered our 3rd first rounder, will take more than a year to see the field over a guy with what 3 concussions? I like Lewis, he is hard nosed and does his job, I just think Mays is so much more athletically gifted, that half a season of learning and practice, will be enough for him to learn his assignments and take over.
i agree
I voted halfway thru 2010. Mainly because i think around the middle of the year lewis will suffer another concussion and mays will get his shot because by then he will have put the work in to make sure he gets that chance. Im also pretty curious as to why beyond 2011 is even been voted for. I can see beginning 2011 if things go extremly well with lewis and goldson but yeah..
Mays is more athletically gifted than 99.995% of the players
to ever step on an NFL field. Lewis is hard nosed but isn’t in the same galaxy of athletic ability as Taylor and doesn’t have a CHANCE to make the same kind of sideline to sideline, big-gain saving tackles against guys like Best (as proven in college) or Chris Johnson when they have everybody else beat and are about to hit the edge at speed. Taylor will be our 1 man anti-Chris Johnson spy. Taylor can almost run with him step for step as far as straight line speed. That’s ludicrous for a guy as big as him. Lewis provides none of that upside or potential.
I’ll call it now – while Mays might get beat in coverage initially, his god-given athleticism will make 1 to 2 BIG plays a game. I’m not talking INTs for TDs but more like…
(read this in the voice of the 9ers radio broadcaster)
Crucial third and 2, 3 minutes left here at Candlestick against the Cowboys down 5… Romo takes the snap, drops back under pressure fakes a WR screen then wheels and pitches the ball to a streaking Marion Barber! Barber looks like he has the edge… OHHHHHH!! Out of nowhere Mays comes flying in like a burgundy and gold streak to knock Barber out short of the sticks!!! What an incredible game saving tackle by Taylor Mays!!!
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Jun 8, 2010 10:47 AM PDT up reply actions
Preseason
If Mays doesn’t blow it too bad in preseason then he’s a Lewis concussion away. If he plays very well in preseason and appears to understand clearly his role in the defense then he will take over without a Lewis injury. I think its really that simple. Either way, I see this spot as Lewis’ to lose (more than likely due to getting burnt in coverage).
I don’t think that at all… and of course this is all speculation on your behalf
by Drew K on Apr 14, 2010 2:05 PM PDT
With Goldson a FA at the end of 2010
and Lewis on short notice due to his concussions I think Mays has a real shot at getting starting time at the start of the season (yeah I know I’ve changed my mind here). We’ll want Mays to get as much experience as possible in case we can’t get a deal done with Goldson.
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority

by 








































