Manny Lawson report card, Week 2 (Now with pictures!)
Week 2, Seattle @ San Francisco
Final Score: 23-10, 49ers
Lawson's stat line: 3 solo tackles, 2 assisted tackles,
Brooks stat line: didn't play
Parys Haralson's stat line: 1 solo tackle, 1 assisted
Jeff Ulbrich's stat line: 1 assisted tackle
1st Series
1.) left side. Down. pushed off line of scrimmage. 5 yard gain
2.) left side. Up. drops back into coverage. ball thrown away from him
3.) right side. nickel. up. rushes and is pushed outside.
2nd Series
1.) right side. up position. rushes, gets tangled up by the tackle and makes no impact
2.) right side. down. completely blocked by the tight end. 6 yard gain by the offense
3.) lined far right (Harlason, franklin, smith, balmer, lawson) gets into the backfield untouched but misses the tackle on a 3rd and 2. Seattle converts.
4.) Left side. up position. pushed out of play by tackle
5.) Left side. Up position. Rushes, sheds blocker. Gets a hand on Jones who runs away from him but is stopped. Lawson really should've had this tackle
6.) Lined up right. Nickel. completely held up by the tackle and didn't get in on the play
3rd Series
1.) Left side. Up. Blocked by tight end on a run play.
2.) Lined up on left side. Up position outside TE. Makes it to the backfield untouched and picked up by the RB.
3.) Right side. Nickel defense. Rushes and is untouched. Gets a hand in Hasselbeck's face as he throws the ball which is incomplete.
4th Series
1.) Left side in "rover" situation. Screen set up and goes outside. Lawson comes up to make the tackle. Excellent work
2.) Lined up on left side. Pass coverage against the tight end. The TE was wide open for a huge gain. Completely negates the excellent work done on the previous play. This was a 2nd and 15 that gained 17 yards.
3.) Left side. Down position. Pushed off LOS and is completely out of the play. Haralson manages to come from the other side to make the tackle
4.) Out of play (Ulbrich in)
5.) Out of play (Ulbrich in)
6.) Right side. Nickel defense. Rushes and gets pushed out of play.
7.) Right side. Up position in pass defense on full back who comes out of the flats. Run for 2 yard gain on other side
8.) Right side. Nickel defense. Up position outside of tackle. Rushes and is pushed outside of action.
9.) Right side in up position. Does a little dance in front of the lineman which accomplishes nothing.
5th Series
1.) Left side. Up position. blocked on run play by the TE.
2.) Left side. Drops in pass protection man on the TE. Ball not thrown his way
3.) Right Side. Down. Nickel defense. Rushes but no pressure. Louosy pass-rush technique
6th Series
1.) Down on right side. Nickel defense. Lined up outside of tackle at an angle. No pressure
2.) Right side. 4 pt stance. Nickel. Actually manages a bull-rush with pressure
3.) Lined up on right side outside of tackle. Runs stunt with Justin Smith and picked up by center. Hasselbeck rushes right up the middle for an 8 yard gain and a first down
4.) Right side outside of tackle. Does a nice swim move to get past tackle but then seems to barely tap the RB.
5.) Not in play (Ulbrich subbing)
6.) Not in play (Ulbrich subbing)
7.) Not in play (Ulbrich subbing)
8.) Not in play (Ulbrich subbing)
9.) Not in play
10.) Right side. Up position. Dances with opposing tackle and gets no pressure
11.) Lined up on right side. Stunt to middle, easily blocked by the center.
12.) Right side. 3 Pt stance. Rushes and is man-handled badly by the right tackle. Thrown to the ground.
7th Series
1.) Left side. Up position. Julius Jones bounces off his right guard into Lawson
2.) Left side. Up position. Lined up outside of tackle. Rushes and barely taps the running back for no pressure. Lawson should be able to knock a RB off his feet.
3.) Stacked up on right side with both OLB on that side. Lawson tries to find a seam up the middle but doesn't get close to the QB
8th Series
1.) Left side. Up. Pushed off LOS
2.) Left side. Up. Rushes and is cut blocked by the RB
3.) Not in play. Ulbrich subbing
4.) Right side. Nickel defense. Lined up outside of tackle. Sucked in on a beautifully executed screen play
5.) Not in play. Ulbrich subbing
6.) Left side. In pass protection on slot receiver. Bad snap so no play his way
7.) Drops back into "rover" position. Run to left side. Lawson runs that way and gets tangled up with two other 49ers.
9th Series
1.) Right side. Down position. Nickel defense. Rushes and is pushed otuside of play
2.) Right side. Up position. Nickel. Makes a one-handed rush then drops back into coverage
3.) Right side. Nickel defense. Up position. Rushes, held up by tackle. Gives up on play at first contact and doesn't continue to pursue the ball.
4.) Right side. Up position. Rushes and gets past tackle. Does a really good rip move on the running back to put pressure on the QB that causes a bad throw and leads to the interception.
10th Series
1.) Right side. Up position. Tries stunt and bumps into Haralson knocking him to the ground
2.) Right side. Down. Nickel defense. Gets good pass rush with pressure on the QB
3.) Not in play. (Had Haralson, McDonald, Smith and Balmer)
11th Series
1.) Right side. Down. Off the line slow, tries to move to the middle in a stunt, that doesn't work so runs back to the other side.
2.) Lined up on right side. Down. Nickel defense. Drops back into pass coverage. Bobbled snap so no pass thrown
3.) Right side. Up. Nickel. Gets good bull-rush on tackle, pressuring Wallace
4.) Right side. Up. NIckel. Rushes one-handed and bounces off tackle. Gets lucky because Wallace scrambles to the right and Lawson runs around to sack him. This sack is caused by the pressure Haralson is bringing that forces Wallace out.
5.) Right side. Down. Nickel. Tries stunt to middle but no room so dances around until the ball is thrown
6.) Right side. Down. Gets decent bull-rush despite being double-teamed
7.) Not in play. Ulbrich in for him, Evans in for Haralson
8.) Not in play. Ulbrich and Evans in
9.) Not in play.
10.) Right side. Nickel defense. Rushes but really quick dump-off
11.) Right side. Nickel defense. Down position. Rushes gets no pressure
12.) Right side. Nickel. Down. Rushes, pushed out of play.
13.) Right side. Nickel. Down. Rushes and does a good job getting pressure but does it by tripping over the center
12th Series
1.) In middle as rover. Pass to the left side of field, Lawson chases him down for the tackle
2.) In middle as rover. Pass to Burleson on far right. Lawson chases him down and Burleson slides to end the game.
Some comments
1.) Lawson's bull-rush technique is awful. He gets absolutely no leverage which is why he's so easily pushed around.
2.) Another irritating trait is his tendency to give up on plays way too soon. As soon as he thinks the play is done (regardless of the whistle) he gives up. It happens over and over again and cost us at least one game.
3.) In this game Lawson was used more as a linebacker, but didn't have many balls thrown his way. He did give up a huge play on a critical down so I'd have to say that his pass-coverage thus far is below average.
4.) Speaking of pass coverage, Clements was on fire this game (and the AZ game). I have high hopes for him this season.
5.) Balmer and Evans got plenty of action this game and did decent.
Slightly better this week than last but still not very good. I'd give him a D for this week's work. A couple of good plays, a couple of bad plays and a whole bunch of nothing. Last week it was a whole bunch of nothing, with only one good play.
This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Niners Nation's writers or editors. It does reflect the views of this particular fan though, which is as important as the views of Niners Nation's writers or editors.
20 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
But....But....2
As I understand the 3-4 defense, it is the defensive end’s job to occupy the OT and/or TE on Lawson’s side (or the OG/C if he is rushing up the middle) to give him a free access lane to the QB or runner. You need to grade the DL in front of him on these plays to be fair. At a guess, they did not keep their OL responsibility occupied on several of these plays. If you go back and look at your pics you will see this problem on a few of them.
Lot of nickel defense these first two weeks
so it wasn’t a true 3-4. First against AZ because of how they play and then vs Seattle they got down big in a hurry so had to play catch up. In the nickel defenses Lawson is essentially lining up as a DL and doesn’t have the technique or power to do so.
None of these plays had a DL on the tackle. Mostly the DL lined up on the guard or if the DL lined up on the tackle Lawson was lined up way outside. In those situations he was easily picked up by the TE (if the TE was out there) or the running back.
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority
I was being sarcastic bud
I think Lawson might be worth a little more than Brooks got but not much.
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Jul 22, 2010 3:34 PM PDT up reply actions
Just talking contract
He’s earned maybe 1M more than the 2 M per we gave Brooks because he’s been with the team longer. As far as who I like more its Brooks
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Jul 23, 2010 10:44 AM PDT up reply actions
I'd be perfectly fine giving Lawson a similar deal to Brooks
but I don’t think Lawson wants that
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority
After week 2
Its pretty clear why Manny isn’t a top priority for the organization.
Whatever his role in the offense is, his pass rush is terrible. Speaking of pass rushing, dis anyone notice that Justin Smith will be lining up against Okung!? Man he should have a nice little day, and if not whoever benefits from the double teaming will!
I don’t think that at all… and of course this is all speculation on your behalf
by Drew K on Apr 14, 2010 2:05 PM PDT
Yeah I think Smith will have fun against Okung
especially the first week we play. By the end of the season Okung may have his feet under him a little more but he’ll still have a tough time against Smih.
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority
I'm looking forward to this
should be a great way for him to start the season, maybe even post a sack or two
I don’t think that at all… and of course this is all speculation on your behalf
by Drew K on Apr 14, 2010 2:05 PM PDT
thanks again for the break down
His pass rush technique or lack there of makes me wonder about “pass rush specialist” coach Al Harris. I’ve never been a big fan of Parys Haralson’s “moves” either. Ahmad Brooks to me has the best pass rushing moves, combo moves of the three but at this point he wasn’t playing yet.
I hope whatever techniques Manny was practicing while not at OTA’s pays off. He’s a too tall and lanky (i know he added 15lbs) to get good leverage on a bull rush. But with his speed and quickness he should have much better speed moves ala a nice spin move or good hand placement. But I’ve never seen either, maybe you’ll discover some later in the year.
But like I said before Brooks is the only one that actually displays “combo moves” and good hand placement with swim and rip moves. The one thing I do know is these guys will push eachohther to be better. But I dont see you giving Manny any higher than a B in any 1 game.
Can u c coach sing's vision? I do!......We all know PATRICK WILLIS is our future!
May 12 2010 comment of the day award winner on the nuggets!
I'll be surprised if I get that high
Regarding Brooks—I don’t think he started playing until Ulbrich went down.
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority
Well he did play better week 2 then
Still got 14 more games to prove himself and I don’t think it’s fair to say his pass coverage is below average only because of one bad play.
What we've got here is a failure to communicate.
"I'm just like you, but 10 times better"
Well I'm grading him on a game-by-game basis
and based on this game his coverage was below-average. The only time the ball was thrown his way during a coverage situation he blew it.
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority
Great Idea for a post Smileyman.
I really love this idea. Thanks for doing all of this. Do you think it would be a good idea to try to rank each play he is in on, and then average them out over a full game? It would be very subjective of course, but I think it would still be useful. Especially if you end up doing this for other players. What does everyone else think?
Pro Football Focus already does individual rankings for players
http://profootballfocus.com/home.php
They don’t describe each play though. Rather they rate each player’s contribution to a play on basis of below average, average and above average. Some of their conclusions are interesting.
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority
I'll have to dig into that a bit deeper.
Thanks I hadn’t seen that before. I still think I’d rather have a niner fan doing the rating. Call me a homer. I’m shocked that these profootballfocus guys think so little of vd and goldson.
VD gets ranked lower due to his percentage of dropped passes
and Goldson had only 1/2 a great season.
Logic merely enables one to be wrong with authority

by 

















































