Would you rather had Matt Leinart over Troy Smith?

Or the Cowboys should have cut Romo after he lost his first 2 playoff games? I think the key to looking at Alex Smith is how he performs during the regular season. If he sucks or is barely average, but happen to get into the playoffs because of the easy schedule or because of the amazing defense, then maybe…but he performs above average and still loses his first playoff game, they should still give him another chance.

are you comparing Alex Smith to Aaron Rodgers are Tony Romo, all of the elite QB have lost a playoff game, my point is Alex is a unproven QB still, that has just recently won the starting job as the 49ers QB, and my question is, will that be enough for the 49ers to bring Alex back for 2011, someone who hasn’t had a lot of success in the NFL, remember you have Smith, Davis,Lawson ,Goldsen in the last year of their contracts

HELL NO! Troy Smith is a solid pick up and has at least as much talent as Leinart, the real difference is that Smith gets it and Leinart doesn’t. It takes real dedication and study to be a good NFL QB’. The old adage that their is no “I” in team applies in the case of Leinart. He came into this league as a premadonna and had his butt kissed at every turn at USC and believed his own hype, It has always been about him. He found out the hard way that just being a pretty boy from southern California doesn’t cut it in the the NFL!

Some of you guys act like a bunch of girls it’s just a question, and i wanted to hear your honest opinion, it’s just a game, a game that we grew up playing as children, and you’re taking someone’s opinion personal, eveybody have a right to voice their opinion, whether you like it are not, now i was express my opinion about Matt Leinart over Troy Smith , and who would be a better QB to compete for the starting job in 2011against Alex smith,and i didn’t mention anything about cutting Alex Smith, what i said was would making the playoff, and losing the first game would be enough for the 49ers to keep Alex, are would the 49ers want to go in different direction,and what would be their best option a unproven rookie are Matt Lienart , And 9thevolution , i have said this before , i like Alex Smith, i’m just not in love with the guy

can we agree if your QB plays well and don’t turn the ball over , when your QB can make plays on 3rd down and keep the drive alive, and keep the defense off the field, you have a greater chance of winning the game period, everything is on the QB and the coaches, win or lose, even though one play can’t determan a lose yes they do lose as a team, you have to remember the NFC championship game and the superbowl ,i can remember 2 interceptions that was key to the other teams victory. And i’m sorry , i believe that Matt Lienart deserves to have just as much time, as the 49ers did for Alex , All Matt wants to do is compete, have you forgotten that U.S.C produces more NFL ready QB , the any other colleges. listen i was born in San Francisco in 1954, yes thats right i’m 55yrs of age , So you can’t find a better fan, and i grew up with what is best for the team , and not some of those emotional ties that you guys share with some players. so all i’m saying is don’t take it so serious, let’s not take a open opinion, and make it nasty, it’s all in fun ,what can you possible get out of insulting another 49er fan.

First of , I say no to matt leinert, we just cut nate davis for his apparent questionable work habits. Why would you want to bring in leinert since Arizona just cut him for the same apparent reasons, that wouldn’t make a whole lot of sense to me? The more I’ve thought about it I don’t think the niners should even consider nate davis anymore at all. I liked davis and was rooting for him but I don’t think we want a Qb with a learning disability, and questionable work habits. I agree with what some have already stated if we were to rely on davis and were to go to a new offensive coordinator again davis would take too long to learn a new playbook again. Chances of another coordinator are a good possiblity too since jimmy reye has only 1 more year after this year left on his contract and is under some pressure to produce and therefore he too could be gone next year?

work on it dude, for your own sake.