The 49ers' Litmus Test: The Detroit Lions
A little over three weeks ago, a few of my buddies and I were walking to the local Safeway. We had just finished up a great game of Settlers of Catan (I won with Longest Road and Largest Army - Woot Woot!) and so I decided to turn the conversation to football.
"Hey guys," I said, "this game against the Eagles is the real deal. This is some sort of Litmus Test for us." I said "Litmus Test" like the words had capital letters - full of reverence and respect-y and such.
The phrase resonated. I mean, come on, it's the team that watched Inception together, right? Plus, I knew that the Eagles/Bucs/emerging-Lions three week slew was going to be tough. In that conversation, I said that if the Niners only won one game, I would be happy. Joyous even.
But that phrase, man. Litmus Test. That just sort of stuck. I noticed during the week that it lingered in my conversations: in my Arthurian Legends class, I argued that Gawain's refusal of the young maiden was a Litmus Test for his showdown with the Green Knight. Litmus Test. It was there.
So coming into the Bucs game, all week long, Litmus Test. This game was between two legit teams. Frank Gore this, Buc's defense that = Litmus Test. I even made a weird game of it in my head. There's a Family Guy episode in which Hugh Laurie just says "House" a couple of times and Peter Griffin follows it up with "Roadhouse." I started to say "Litmus Test" in my head like that. It was weird.
And once the Bucs game ended (that happened right? The game doesn't seem all that memorable to me), I looked toward the Lions game with bated breath, lips a-licked, and eyes bigger than my football stomach. Because, guess what this is.
Yup, it's a Litmus Test.
This isn't to say that neither the Eagles nor the Bucs are good. I mean, the Eagles team has all sorts of crazy talent (full disclosure, Vick is my Fantasy Football QB) and the Bucs, I think, are turning into the real deal - Sunday notwithstanding.
But Holy Hot Potato, the Lions! I mean, honestly, who doesn't see Calvin Johnson and pee themselves a little bit?Don't deny it. This ain't seeing Willis run at you full speed ahead - that's a "you say it then you do it" situation. Calvin Johnson, though. I think he could out jump gravity and steal the moon's orbit (and then put it into orbit around JaMarcus Russell, cause he so fat, amirite?!).
And the man throwing him the ball might be okay too. I guess, if you value QBs who can throw the ball really well and weird stuff like that.
Honestly, the main component of that offense I am least worried about is Jahvid Best, and that dude is a sneaky little runner. Ask Chicago if we should be worried about him.
I think our defense is very very very very very very very good. Like borderline great. Willis and Bowman can just pound Best into the ground for as long as the Lions want to run him. And, I think the Smith twins can be very disruptive in the backfield. But, if both of these things don't happen, Vic Fangio is going to have a hard time keeping things in check this game. But hey, the Lions have a lot of weapons. This is going to be a true Litmus Test.
And that is more true for Carlos Rogers (or whoever has the main responsibility of covering Johnson, though I would imagine Rogers is the logical guy for the job, though there have been even some Culliver rumblings) than anybody else. I'm calling him the Prilosec/McDonalds/Microsoft/Google/Subway Litmus Test Player of the Pre-Game. I doubt that he will be asked to cover Johnson the entire time; likely there will be all sorts of double (triple?) coverage help. But hey, Litmus Test.
On the other side of the ball, their D-line is insane. These are some big dudes we are talking about. From what I have seen watching some of the Monday Night game, they don't actually seem to blitz a ton (and a sigh of relief swept through Niners Nation), but the linemen are so big and aggressive that sometimes they get it done themselves. Plus, they have the one guy who is supposed to be good... Duh, it's Suh.
The LB corps is actually pretty talented and perhaps a bit underrated, I would say. I think the Niners core blows them out of the water (they do that to most everybody in the NFL, actually), but I was surprised to read and pretend to fully understand stats that show the Lions aren't the greatest against the run. Their front seven look good.
Their secondary looks pretty average to maybe slightly better than average, though I would say that they are probably better equipped to sack Alex Smith than cover our TEs. Regardless, I think the Litmus Test is pretty well spread around on offense. Litmus Test O-line. Litmus Test Vernon Davis. And perhaps most importantly, Litmus Test Frank Gore.
So while I'm not writing up anything new when I make the joke about this being an oh-so unexpected game from two oh-so unexpected teams, I'm going to do it anyway. Who woulda thunk that the Lions-49ers game woulda be an NFC match-up of Playoff proportions!
But, seriously, Litmus Test. Beat this team and we can hold our own against quite a few elite teams in the NFL. Litmus Test.
Litmus Test.
65 comments
|
3 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Boy, if I hear/read the term "Litmus Test" again in the foreseeable future, I'm going to turn red
(or is it blue… I can never remember…)?
After all was said and done, a lot more got said than done.
by OldJock on Oct 15, 2011 11:26 AM PDT reply actions 1 recs
It's both actually
Every time Wes mentioned Litmus Test, I couldn’t help but science nerd out and think in the back of my head, “Do you fully understand what a Litmus Test actually tests?”. As far as the pertinence to his argument/topic it’s not important. But Litmus tests actually measure pH, so it’s not actually a test that will give “positive” and or “negative” results… That being said, a typical litmus test will turn red when pH is low (acidic) and turn blue when the pH is high(basic).
So I guess my nit-picky question is, which is better in the NFL? acidity or basivity(alkalinity)?
My unneeded nit-picking aside a great read, Wes.
As a geologist, I talk to rocks. And they talk back, and they are telling me, "This year the San Fransisco 49ers are going to be some Gneiss Schist!"
by Conskies on Oct 15, 2011 1:13 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
oooor he could just mean that itll show us where were at.
if you think about it that way it makes more sense. its just an indicator.
Demarcus Dobbs is Our Future
aahh gotchia
As a geologist, I talk to rocks. And they talk back, and they are telling me, "This year the San Fransisco 49ers are going to be some Gneiss Schist!"
Conskies, so you would probably be one of those people who get annoyed...
When someone says they picked somethign up via osmosis.
Always makes me wonder how absorbing water through a semi-permeable membrane helped them learn anything…
by ColoradoNiner on Oct 15, 2011 9:16 PM PDT up reply actions
I think what people are trying to say...
is that Gore might be exposed as being over-rated. Trying to run him up the Lions gut could be a big mistake.,, just sayin’
The coolest Lion nickname ever belongs to Dick "NIGHT TRAIN" Lane.
by Gee Garold Lembach on Oct 15, 2011 4:25 PM PDT up reply actions
The Bucs game was our litmus test
Teams win and lose every Sunday, sometimes the better team, sometimes the team who gets more bounces going their way. We’ve been on both sides of that coin this very year.
But the standard for a competitor is one who can go into a game against another competitor and lay the ever loving smack down for four quarters and walk out of the stadium over their broken spirits.
We arrived last week, no matter how the Detroit game plays out.
by Ougadas on Oct 15, 2011 11:27 AM PDT reply actions 3 recs
Amen to this
If you would have told me 3 or 4 months ago that we would have a team this year that could compete at the highest levels I would have been thrilled.
We lost a game to Dallas that we could have very well won but came right back and won two tough road games.
Litmus Test my ass. We’ve got a good solid team that can play with anybody and that’s plenty good enough for me. Go Niners.
There are different levels of arrival
Just about every week will be a test of where the 49ers stand because they’ve established so little. You certainly don’t have to spend any of your time thinking about it if you don’t want to.
For me, the Bucs showed they can avoid a hangover. Just as the Eagles game showed me they can come back from a deficit, and the Bengals showed me they can win at 10am.
Now they can show us what they can do against a passing offense on turf, and what they can do against one of the premiere defensive lines in the league, and how they can handle a rockin’ dome. And perhaps, if they can beat a 2011 playoff team.
Lions, Ravens, Steelers and at least 1 of the Cowboys/Giants/Redskins will probably make the playoffs.
by whistlingmountain on Oct 15, 2011 12:41 PM PDT up reply actions
Conditioning test....
for the players. OL especially. They’ll be assigned to stop the 9-man rotation that is so ballyhooed up there in DET.
I feel like the Litmus is really all about Harbaugh. He’s got to account for 2 major mismatches with scheme alone. All the players can do, can hope to do, is execute. And if the game plan is good, the damage should be negligible, and the game will come down to the players playing.
Who is Litmus Test?
You refer to this player throughout your article without ever once telling me who he is. Someone off the practice squad? Kind of weird that you would constantly talk about this guy Test without explaining who he is or where he came from. Very poor journalism.
This is a litmus test for Gore
I’m still not sold on him being the elite back he once was
...and then Singletary opened His Book and it said "thou shalt NOT pass"
by jimisoursavior on Oct 15, 2011 11:48 AM PDT reply actions
100 plus yards and a 4.5 ypc will sell me just fine though lol
...and then Singletary opened His Book and it said "thou shalt NOT pass"
by jimisoursavior on Oct 15, 2011 11:49 AM PDT reply actions
Lions game IS their biggest test to date, for several reasons...
(1) When is the last time the 9ers won 4 in a row, plus this is a road game.
(2) The crowd noise is going to be unbearable
(3) This IS the game of the NFL week, so how will 9ers handle the NFL world watching ?
(4) This IS the 9ers O-Line most severe test against a high quality,nasty Lions D-Line.
(5) Lions Q.B. Stafford is the Best pure pocket passer 9ers have faced to date.
(6) The Lions are the come from behind score kings…they don’t panic if behind.
(7) Alex may be under more severe pressure and havoc then he has faced to date.
I agree, it's their biggest test thus far
Probably the most anticipated 49er game since 2003.
by whistlingmountain on Oct 15, 2011 12:44 PM PDT up reply actions
(1) Sadly, 2001, when they won 5 consecutive. They’ve had 3 game winning streaks under Mooch in ’02, Nolan in ’06, and four of 5 under Sing in ’08. In each case, the one loss was typical of many losses the past few seasons: play well, so close to victory late, but one play or player short. A win Sunday to make a five game streak going into the bye week would certainly prove to be quite big.
- Thank you SF Giants for an incredible 2010 season and painting the City orange & black!
You gotta bring ass to get ass.
I think the alex will get sacked less than the eagles game or the cowboys game. suh is their d-line. Niners d-line is way better than their d-line. Aldon Smith would be the sack leader if he was on the lions. lions rely on big explosive plays to win, limit or eliminate those plays and this is a easy win for the niners. A good game rushing for the niners that will limit the possessions of the lions and this will be an easy game for the niners. And statford throws literally jump balls up to johnson, pick a few of those off and again easy win for the niners. they are many ways for the niners to easily beat the lions. Habaugh put a good game plan against the bus and confident he will have one against the lions.
"You know whats funny? I always thought uhm dogs lay eggs and I learned something new today" Peter Griffin
by HUNGRY HUNTER on Oct 15, 2011 3:07 PM PDT up reply actions
This comment told me that the commenter knows nothing about the Lions D-line.
No slogans. Just win!!!
If we run no huddle then we can keep suh on the field n then attept to tire him out
by mrb24 on Oct 15, 2011 5:26 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
This game is a litmus test?
Arguably every game is a “litmus test”. Playing a crappy team is as least as much of a litmus test as playing a successful one. Lose to a crappy team and it says alot. Beat a successful one says alot. For me personally the only litmus test games are ones that are do or die for the playoffs or in the playoffs. This one is neither.
Justin Smith is something else. 100% Effort! 100% Class!
"I was just running toward the ball," Smith said. "The guys in front of him were making him slow up a little bit. I just went for the ball and, luckily, it was there."
I was going to write a post with this same title. I agree the Lions are the first team we are going to play that is a legit all around team. Yah the Cowboys and Eagles but both those teams are struggling right now, at least compared to expectations. Bucs in my opinion have always been overrated, even before week 5.
Maybe I've drank too much Kool-aid
I just can’t help from thinking the Lions are ready to put on a clinic. I think the 4 1/2 point spread is showing the 49ers a lot of respect… or perhaps a sucker bet. I’ll give the points. I don’t think this is going to be that close.
The coolest Lion nickname ever belongs to Dick "NIGHT TRAIN" Lane.
by Gee Garold Lembach on Oct 15, 2011 4:55 PM PDT up reply actions
How's putting on That Clinic going for you Gee?
get off the Kool-aid
"It's impossible to hide the fire inside" - Bob Seger
Alexmus Test
Not just the Oline, and damn I hate being the first one to comment on it but dude needs to be able to put up numbers without turnovers. This Dline is coming for him, everyone knows they are coming for him. With our secondary he is going to have to keep up with Staffy and The ‘Tron without throwing more than 1 pick. I’ll give him 1, but that’s it.
by HEXXhudd on Oct 15, 2011 1:09 PM PDT via mobile reply actions
Will you give another Gore fumble too?
The coolest Lion nickname ever belongs to Dick "NIGHT TRAIN" Lane.
by Gee Garold Lembach on Oct 15, 2011 4:34 PM PDT up reply actions
that's generous of you
Allowing two in a 6 game stretch. Downright magnanimous.
by redgolddynasty on Oct 16, 2011 12:40 AM PDT via iPhone app up reply actions
And the Lions O-Line just may be the best the 9ers have faced to date
They are a BIG physical line, and only have given up 6 sacks to date.
... and they are pretty upset about giving up that 1 sack at home.
The coolest Lion nickname ever belongs to Dick "NIGHT TRAIN" Lane.
by Gee Garold Lembach on Oct 15, 2011 4:39 PM PDT up reply actions
For the Lions...
…this game is as equal a test. While I have taken great pleasure in being 5-0 the Niners are a team that is getting a lot of respect and appears to have some credible chemistry (as their record indicates). There are some Lions fans who are still wary of the “old Lions” finding ways to lose. If the Lions can win this game it will go a long way in validating they are a team that has turned the corner.
It is shaping up to be a fantastic game!
May the best team win! Go Lions!
2011 - The Year the Roar was restored!
by West Side Lions Fan on Oct 15, 2011 1:13 PM PDT reply actions
So if it simply gets down to the better Q.B. being the difference...
what you all think?
I have not watched
Smith this year other than highlights, but have watched him in the past. I have been very impressed with Stafford and his evolution. My honest assessment is that Stafford is the better QB right now and is getting better every week given his inexperience. His accuracy and arm strength may be second only to Rodgers. Yes, he has looked that good. I have to give the edge to him. Like any inexperienced QB, mistakes may make the difference.
2011 - The Year the Roar was restored!
by West Side Lions Fan on Oct 15, 2011 2:48 PM PDT up reply actions
Which QB would you take if the game was on the line?
The one who can get the ball to a big fast receiver 50 yards downfield?
Or the one who has done well by being a checkdown artist?
No slogans. Just win!!!
well neither one has been a checkdown artist
so I’m not sure I understand this line of questioning
by Andrew9erfan on Oct 15, 2011 5:21 PM PDT up reply actions
STAAAAF-FORD!
C’mon… that’s a no-brainer. Look at all his weapons.
The coolest Lion nickname ever belongs to Dick "NIGHT TRAIN" Lane.
by Gee Garold Lembach on Oct 15, 2011 4:28 PM PDT up reply actions
We got Vernon n delanie;) watchout for Kyle n crabs to break it wide open!
by mrb24 on Oct 15, 2011 4:59 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
Kyle's got crabs?
Doesn’t Romo… I mean Smith, only throw that dinky-doo stuff? That’d be a plus for him, because if he has to stand in there to look downfield, he’s gonna get CRUSHED.
The coolest Lion nickname ever belongs to Dick "NIGHT TRAIN" Lane.
by Gee Garold Lembach on Oct 15, 2011 5:19 PM PDT up reply actions
Was that a 26 yard strike threading the needle to delanie walker while triple coverage fought as dinky dunk; I think not
by mrb24 on Oct 15, 2011 5:29 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
Not talkin' about 1 play...
I’m talkin’ about TD passes. As far as passing yardage goes, SF sucks hind titty there; comparable with McNabb.
The coolest Lion nickname ever belongs to Dick "NIGHT TRAIN" Lane.
by Gee Garold Lembach on Oct 15, 2011 7:17 PM PDT up reply actions
If a team can run into the end zone at will, who cares about passing TD's
…it’s more about getting the score than how you got it.
by ColoradoNiner on Oct 15, 2011 9:20 PM PDT up reply actions
By the way stafford is gonna spend more time on his back then Alex. Romo who?
by mrb24 on Oct 15, 2011 5:31 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
He should...
if the 49eR “D” is as tough as what I’m hearing here. Ranking 32nd in the NFL for passing attempts doesn’t provide a lot of opportunities, than an Offense ranked 4th in attempts. Good luck… Detroit is the least sacked team in the NFC. SF is near the bottom there too, despite the least among of attempts.
Behind all the blue smoke and mirrors, your OL must not be that good. This might be like taking candy away from a baby.
The coolest Lion nickname ever belongs to Dick "NIGHT TRAIN" Lane.
by Gee Garold Lembach on Oct 15, 2011 7:27 PM PDT up reply actions
32nd in attempts
Ummm … because they get the offense off the field. Come on now, gonna cite attempts?
How's that "taking candy away from a baby" going for you Gee?
wondering how those 5 sacks we hung on you will effect your least sacked team ranking…
"It's impossible to hide the fire inside" - Bob Seger
He has the most completions of 20 yds plus in the NFL ...!!
I'm your " Huckelberry "...it's just my game ...Jimmy Raye your no daisy ...!!
Well put
I think members of both fan bases have some worry that one loss might snowball into a rough streak that puts the playoffs in question and quickly turns the media affection into “they’re not that good” talk. Especially if key injuries occur with a loss.
- Thank you SF Giants for an incredible 2010 season and painting the City orange & black!
You gotta bring ass to get ass.
Losing
and handling those losses are a big part of the maturation process. Hopefully the loser of this game will treat it as just that, one loss. If they can do that then hopefully they will still not forget the end game (playoffs) and continue to have a successful season.
2011 - The Year the Roar was restored!
by West Side Lions Fan on Oct 15, 2011 2:58 PM PDT up reply actions
49ers took a tough loss to Dallas In OT
And bounced back with 3 straight wins. The first two on the road. We’ll see how the Lions handle their first loss.
"It's impossible to hide the fire inside" - Bob Seger
The 49ers can absorb quite a few losses and still win the West
Who’s gonna beat them out for the division? I’m surprised playoff tickets aren’t being sold yet.
The coolest Lion nickname ever belongs to Dick "NIGHT TRAIN" Lane.
by Gee Garold Lembach on Oct 15, 2011 4:31 PM PDT up reply actions
Our goal is as it used to be as a franchise
We’re building a team to far exceed just winning a division.
- Thank you SF Giants for an incredible 2010 season and painting the City orange & black!
You gotta bring ass to get ass.
A couple of seasons ago, nobody would have wanted to watch this matchup
Now its a legitimate contender for game of the week. How quickly fortunes can change in the NFL.
Detroit is not going to win every game and we are just the team to end their dream start. GO 9ERS!
This week is a litmus test for WesHanson.
Is he Acidic? Can he give us an interesting article week after week? Were the past five well written articles just flukes? The one with the Cowboys might have been a little sloppy and enventually might have faltered in overtime, but it was a valient effort by all invloved.
That article was very close to being a victory on a subject of legacy. I chalk this up to the challenge of adressing the current Dallas Cowboys without adressing the enigma that is Tony Romo. You can take him out of the game, but he is still capable of coming back to bite you in the rear before you have put the game away, apparently.
All in all I think your 4-1 (could be 5-0 if not for the blown call or even the missed opportunity) record is respectable given the short time you had to prepare. I hope you can continue putting out interesting and compelling articles on your way to the post season. I’m not so sure about this particular article, but this is certainly as tough of a week as any. At least Calvin Johnson has been adressed and we have a few possible strategies to address the Detriot defensive line.
This is a litmus test for you WesHanson, I wish you all the luck in the world. It certainly couldn’t hurt is a couple of bounces and calls go your way.
Play to Win!
Justin Smith is my new hero.
by Pat Willie on Oct 15, 2011 1:40 PM PDT reply actions 4 recs
Perhaps more of a statement for certain players
Win or lose, if the team plays tough and smart in losing, but Crabtree has a monster game on this stage while missing two of our top three WRs, that would be great for the maturation and confidence of the offense. Same as Alex playing well in leading his team in this environment vs a fierce D-line, the play of Snyder vs Suh, and our DBs against CJ.
One should learn about themselves in victory and defeat. I want to continue to see evidence that that zone coverage mistakes from the Dallas game were an aberration. I want to see our OL continue their improvements since the benching of Chilo. I want to see Kyle Williams and Ginn catch all passes that come their way, and use their speed to make a play down field. If these things happen, even in a tight loss, it will be useful going into the latter half of the season. Especially because, win or lose, we may see the Lions at Candlestick on WC weekend.
- Thank you SF Giants for an incredible 2010 season and painting the City orange & black!
You gotta bring ass to get ass.
Its a litmus test for both teams
Both are coming off emotional victories and now the national media are starting to pay attention to them.
Both are beginning to have real success in this league and whoever deals better with success is the team that will be able to pull out a victory. The Lions & Niners now have expectations place on their shoulders, tomorrow we get to see who lives up to those expectations
Kind of a litmus test for both teams, I think
Also, Settlers of Catan = my nerd brother for life!
I'm just a simple Giants fan trying to make my way in the universe.
by Tim Lincecum's Bong on Oct 15, 2011 2:18 PM PDT reply actions
Soap said it best
Sopoaga “…We are well-prepared, well-trained and well-ready for Sunday.”
That to me is exactly the right mind-set for going into a hostile environment on the road and coming out with a win. Love it!
Every week is kind of a Litmus Test when you don't suck
Before we were bad… there was nothing to test. Now that we’re good, it’s constantly a search of “well, are we better than this team? How about that team?” and once the bye week is over and we move on to some weaker teams, it will be more individualized tests, like “can our OL hold up against the Redskins’ fearsome OLB duo? What about the Giants’ DL?” The tests will never end. I, for one, am pretty darn excited about it.
Idolizing Robb Nen since 2002...
by Smoke on the Water on Oct 15, 2011 3:58 PM PDT reply actions
In my mind we are playing with house money
Mainly because if you told me before the lockout ended we’d be no worse than 4-2 heading into the bye I’d have walked the other direction.
At this point, I’d still be perfectly content with 4-2 (kind of depends on how the game goes too though). That said, don’t get me wrong, I want this game more than just about any in recent memory.
Obviously the team isn’t thinking anything like this, which is good, but personally, it makes me less nervous about the game and much more, just plain fired up.
bucs or lions
for me, the bucs were a test for us because i felt they were the sort of teams we should beat at home. i’m not sure i can say the same for a road game against the lions. i believe they are one of the top six teams in the NFL. i’m not sure we’re at the that level yet, despite our start.

by 














































