2011 49ers and Alex Smith: If a QB Being Nice is Bad, He's the Worst
Some say that Alex Smith is just "too nice" to be a successful quarterback in the NFL. Others think he has some fire on the field that contrasts his nice-guy attitude when not playing. If there's any credence to the statement that nice guys don't make good QB's...then we're all screwed.
Yesterday, Barrows had a post detailing how Mr. Congenial (Smith) seemingly one-upped himself in the nice-guy department. Rookie draft-pick Ronald Johnson (USC) made the trip out to the Bay Area last week for "Camp Alex". He's stuck around since then, and although he didn't have a "whip" (car) to ride in, it didn't take him long to solve that problem.
According to Barrows, Alex Smith loaned Johnson a car...and not just any car, Smith's wife's car. Barrows noted that it was a decidedly nicer car than the plain-jane pickup truck that Mr. Smith drives...going as far as to say it was of German descent. I'm thinking it has to be a Benz, but BMW is a distinct possibility.
If being kind and helpful to challenger Colin Kaepernick wasn't nice enough for you, deciding to lead the player-only mini-camp and help those less-fortunate get to town, or doing all of this as a free agent with a very tumultuous past here in SF...maybe loaning your wife's Benzy to a 6th round draft pick qualifies?
Personally I like it, and it endears me to Smith even more. I have no idea what he'll do on the field this year, and while I care about that aspect, I also care about human nature and being a good dude. Besides, I really don't think being a jerkface is going to help Alex magically turn things around, anyways.
34 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
A different spin on the story
There’s a guy. He’s unemployed. He has no immediate prospects of getting into a job. He used to have one, but he was so bad at it that people literally booed him. His bosses came and went – he never had the same boss for more than a year at a time. In fact the company was in turmoil – it had some great times, long before this fella joined the organisationl, but now it’s a failing company and he was a failing employee. Then things got worse – his union went out, and now he can’t honestly say when he’ll be back in work.
Despite this background of domestic depression, he gets his wife pregnant. She doesn’t know when her husband will bring in a wage for the young family, but she trusts her husband.
Shortly after the birth, he begins squandering their savings flying his boys into town from all over the country. They have some fun, hiring a sports facility and playing some football. They even film themselves – they’re just boys having fun. All of this time, the wife is home alone with the newborn child. The husband and his boys can get nasty at times – he falls out with his most talented pal at one point. She asks when they’re gonna patch it up. “You’re asking the wrong guy. Seriously,” he shrugs. She wishes he’d communicate more.
Just when she thinks they’re getting back on track, she goes out one morning to take the child to a Mother and Baby appointment at the local clinic. There’s no car in her space. “Darling, where’s my Mercedes?” she calls out. “I gave it to Ronald,” he calls back from the kitchen, where he’s practising his throws by trying to get a football into the washing machine. Currently the washing machine has sacked him three times, and the toaster is about to punt.
“Who’s Ronald,” she asks. “You’re asking the wrong guy,” says her husband. “Seriously.”
by LondonNiner on Jun 17, 2011 12:14 PM PDT reply actions 7 recs
lmao
dude, you should guest write on the FP sometimes…
The NFL/Players are dragging me down. Sad thing is: they know I'll always keep coming back.
I just Twitter'd that
that was awesome
you didnt mention that the employee also happens to rake in millions a year lol
Not Looking For Role Models, Looking For A Superbowl
I guess if you view athletes as role models and idols, then Alex is your man. I prefer watching sports for athletic competition, and dont care much about their personal life as long as they arent criminals.
Right
I do view them as role models though so I guess we’re just different.
I mean, i’d take Alex over Big Ben and a dirty SB
What we've got here is a failure to communicate.
"I'm just like you, but 10 times better"
by SportsChicken on Jun 17, 2011 6:23 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions 2 recs
Alex Smith is also generous on the field. He donates lots of interceptions and fumbles to the other team. I rather have a turd like Michael Vick or Big Ben that can play than saint Alex.
Those are the only 2 QBs that could survive behind our line
Had you said Aaron Rodgers I’d have laughed because he wouldn’t even be in the league anymore behind the line that nearly destroyed Alex’s shoulder.
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Jun 17, 2011 1:23 PM PDT up reply actions
Alex Smith is the Warren Buffet of football
Makes big money… Gives half of it away to charity. Still has millions of bucks… Drives an everyman pickup truck. What to do with the savings? Oh I’ll use that on my jaw-dropping wife’s whip. Here rook. You can borrow it. Just don’t put any dents in it if you want playing time.
Gimme 1 round!
Too nice?
I do not see how loaning a car to a young colleague from out of town, who is yet to land a paycheck, is “too nice”. That’s a rather reasonable thing to do.
When I got to grad school, my professor did loan me a car for a week, to get my affairs together. Not a really fancy one, and it was a nice gesture – but nothing earth shattering. I would definitely do the same.
Dude can afford it, he did not bend over backwards.
Lend somebody your wifey's car and see if you're bending over backwards or not.
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Jun 17, 2011 1:52 PM PDT up reply actions
Maybe it is her ploy
..to get a new one.
She needs a bigger one anyway. My wife stopped riding her 325 after our first kid, we got a minivan, and eventually sold the coupe.
i could have read that as “she’s bending over”
"And thank you to God for making me an Atheist." - Ricky Gervais
by MichaelClutchtree on Jun 17, 2011 5:33 PM PDT up reply actions
I'm still on Alex's side
And if we’ve got football on Sundays this fall, you bet your ass I’ll be rocking #11 for every single 49ers tilt.
Please please please help Red Wave Central become the official Fresno State Bulldogs blog of SB Nation! If you're a Bulldog diehard who wants to help, check here for contact information.
by OnDeck_Matt on Jun 17, 2011 2:12 PM PDT via mobile reply actions 2 recs
Alex Smith just has bad body language when things aren't going well. My God, some of the pictures of him when Singletary was yelling at him.
When things go bad it almost seems like he is just willing to accept it as a fact of life rather than try to fight back. He can be nice off the field all he wants, but what I want to see in him on the field is a bit of nastiness, and a sense that he is going to fight the other team. When he throws a pick or two, or the team is down, he needs to be other there trying to kill somebody, and not just take that crap lying down.
restraint
You never want a player that gets too high or too low…Even keeled is what you want. Ask any coach at any level. He had every reason to cus Sing out…hell VD and Troy Smith both blew up for good reason. However, If your QB cant keep his cool, all is lost in my opinion.
Give tha guy a break...I remember losing most of our games because of mistakes by players that did not play the quarterback position.
I'm sure Norv Turner is a good judge of a good QB...even he said the guy can be good w/ quality people around him.
by NewAgecorner1 on Jun 17, 2011 4:40 PM PDT up reply actions
whawhawhawhat?
singletary was like adolf hitler..you couldnt fight him. alex was just trying to stay on the field. you dont think he knew the playbook was a joke? heck his playbook in utah was more complicated! did you watch a game? we all were throwing fits by week three and we werent blaming smith…we were blaming singletary! i am the person that will kill off a player faster than anyone, why do i keep hoping for smith to succeed? because of his character. i see the skills he has and the guy had been dealt a bad hand. im willing to give him two more years to succeed. he hasnt had one good to great coach so far and the funny part is…he hasnt given up on us!
joe montana in the house bitch!!! oh wait that was peter griffin.......
by ninerfan1964 on Jun 18, 2011 8:20 PM PDT up reply actions 2 recs
Its not nastiness you want, its competitiveness. His only responsibility is to show that to his teammates which he has done
Give tha guy a break...I remember losing most of our games because of mistakes by players that did not play the quarterback position.
I'm sure Norv Turner is a good judge of a good QB...even he said the guy can be good w/ quality people around him.
How nasty is Tom Brady, Manning, Ryan, Bradford
if you ask me, they are all similar in their demeanor on the field.
Give tha guy a break...I remember losing most of our games because of mistakes by players that did not play the quarterback position.
I'm sure Norv Turner is a good judge of a good QB...even he said the guy can be good w/ quality people around him.
Seriously
This whole “Good QBs need to be jerks” thing is pretty baseless imo.
What we've got here is a failure to communicate.
"I'm just like you, but 10 times better"
by SportsChicken on Jun 17, 2011 6:27 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
Jim Harbaugh’s NFL Career Stats
PCT—————YDS—————AVE—————-TDS—————INT—————-FUM—————RTG
58.8—————26,288———-6.7——————129—————117—————-68——————-77.61
Yep
Take the first and third (thrown to wolves/badly hurt) seasons out, and maybe a tad better.
That is – average.
And lets see how he does under Harbaugh
Considering Harbaugh’s stats above reflect his year he did fantastic as well.
Gimme 1 round!
by ItBurnzWhenIP on Jun 18, 2011 2:17 AM PDT up reply actions
My fuzzy thinking.
In the back of my mind were those who were claiming they did not want AS teaching CK anything. Harbaugh was an average QB and is apparently a very good teacher of QBs, so why be so sure that Smith cannot teach.
Bill Walsh and many others were average, slightly above average, or even below average on the field, but still managed to be great coaches.
Who wouldn't want Alex to teach Kaeperman anything?
Alex knows more about the game from a QB perspective than anyone else he could possible interact with. Alex never had a problem understanding the X’s and O’s, it was always a matter of execution. The latter part is up to the players performance, the former is pure information.
Harbaugh will find a QB and he will succeed.
I'm a huge fan of Alex the man, the person, the human being...
That having been said, do I feel that he has lived up to the expectations that come with being a #1 overall draft pick? Absolutely not.
But, because of the person he is, I find that I cannot help but hope that he will be wildly successful. If Colin Kaepernick (or David Carr??? or whomever) beat him out, well, that’s the way things happen in sports (I picked up more than my share of splinters riding the pine behind better players). But I WILL NOT HOPE THAT HE FAILS, I WILL NOT ROOT FOR HIM TO FAIL, I will send him every good vibe, every bit of good karma, that I can muster.
I want the 49ers to be successful, but I want it to be with players I respect. Even if Terrell Owens offered to come back and play for us for free, I wouldn’t want him on my team, he’s a cancer on the sidelines and in the locker room (“I LOVE ME SOME ME”!!!!). I wouldn’t want Ben Rapistberger to QB my team. I want a winner, make no mistake about that. But I’m not willing to sell my soul to bring it about. I’m not only a fan of the 49ers, I’m a fan of almost all of the fine young men who play for us, and those of whom I’m not yet a fan, that’s only because I don’t yet know enough about them to formulate such an opinion.
Stepping down off my soap box now….
After all was said and done, a lot more got said than done.
by OldJock on Jun 17, 2011 6:09 PM PDT reply actions 6 recs
Well Said
I guess a lot of people are just simply negative minded individuals. Im sure they apply the same type of negativity in other areas of their lives too.
Give tha guy a break...I remember losing most of our games because of mistakes by players that did not play the quarterback position.
I'm sure Norv Turner is a good judge of a good QB...even he said the guy can be good w/ quality people around him.
by NewAgecorner1 on Jun 19, 2011 11:01 AM PDT up reply actions
O " boy " ... it's not being nice , It's called the rite thing to do ...
… that’s part of the problem with this multi media generation …they’ve lost the human touch…!!
I'm your " Huckelberry "...it's just my game ...Jimmy Raye your no daisy ...!!
you DID read this whole thing, right?
Personally I like it, and it endears me to Smith even more. I have no idea what he’ll do on the field this year, and while I care about that aspect, I also care about human nature and being a good dude.
The NFL/Players are dragging me down. Sad thing is: they know I'll always keep coming back.
I just Twitter'd that

by 








































