It is a cliche that is heard repeatedly. Defense wins championships. It is tried and true. Except, it isn't anymore. We don't hear that now. In today's NFL all anybody wants to talk about is offense. Offense is what wins now, right? Look at the last few Super Bowl winners: Packers, Saints, Steelers, Giants, Colts, and Patriots. Every one of them with a with a potential Hall of Fame level quarterback. So offense wins championships, right? Nope. So if offense doesn't win championships and defense doesn't win championships what does? Teams win championships.
It is easy and simplistic to pick one side of the ball and say that is what wins. Analysts love things that are easy and simplistic. It is also catchy. And most importantly it is sexy to look at offenses. But why don't we look a little closer at these last few winners.
2010 Packers
It is the Packers with Aaron Rodgers. It must be all about the offense. He had one of the greatest seasons ever this year. Their offense was unstoppable this season. And that defense is pathetic. The difference is we aren't talking about this year. We are talking about last year. And last season the defense wasn't pathetic. It was borderline awesome.
Defense:
Points allowed: 2nd
Yards allowed: 5th
Take Aways: 3rd
Offense:
Points: 10th
Yards: 9th
Turnovers: 9th
Wow, if I knew nothing about the amazing Aaron Rodgers (which he is) and his super offense I would say that looks like a well balanced but defensive based team. A team balanced enough to win a Super Bowl and they did.
2009 Saints
This is the one team that comes the closest to ruining my entire post. They were an offensive team. They gave up a lot of points and a lot of yards on defense. But they also led the league in takeaways. Who needs a three and out when you can just get an interception or a fumble on a regular basis.
Defense:
Points allowed: 20th
Yards allowed: 25th
Take Aways: 1st
Offense:
Points: 1st
Yards: 1st
Turnovers: 9th
This team was opportunistic on defense. The defense gave the offense extra possessions by creating turnovers. And in my opinion, knowing that the defense didn't have a great chance at stopping the Colts the Saints kicked a brilliant onside kick coming out of halftime in the Super Bowl. I believe that is a special teams play, not an offensive play. That makes them a balanced team.
2008 Steelers
Now this team was way back three years ago. I know most of us don't really remember that far back. I know to an analyst that might as well have been prior to the invention of the forward pass. Because defense is dead and has been for a long time.
Defense:
Points allowed: 1st
Yards allowed: 1st
Take Aways: 4th
Offense:
Points: 20th
Yards: 22nd
Turnovers: 11th
This is clearly a defensive team. Without a doubt. But I am sure the team they played was another defensive minded team that lucked in. Oh wait they beat a top 5 offense in the Arizona Cardinals who had a bottom 3rd defense. This Steelers team is probably the most 1 dimensional defensive team to win the Super Bowl in the last 10 years. But they got hot in the playoffs and ranked 2nd in points scored in the post season that year. That makes them a well balanced team.
2007 Patriots Giants
The Patriots were an offensive juggernaut. There was no team that could beat them. Oh wait, sorry. The Giants were basically a kind of average middle of the pack team during the regular season. Balanced between offense and defense but average. Then the playoffs started. Eli jumped to another level and his stats went up in basically every category. But, they actually averaged slightly less points per game in the playoffs than they did in the regular season. However, their defense jumped up to a tie for 1st in fewest points allowed per game.
Defense:
Points allowed: 17th
Yards allowed: 7th
Take Aways: 22nd
Offense:
Points: 14th
Yards: 16th
Turnovers: 14th
The Giants were a well balanced team that had a lights out defensive run through the playoffs. Not to mention some magic from Eli and his little friend in the Super Bowl. They held the record breaking Pats offense to 14 points in the Super Bowl but it took the entire team to win it.
2006 Colts
Much like the 2009 Saints this team tried to ruin my post. They were an offensive team that had a somewhat opportunistic defense that created some turnovers. At least during the regular season they were. Then the playoffs started and something crazy happened. The Colts turned into super defense. They only gave up 6 and 8 points in their first two playoff games and averaged giving up nearly 100 yards per game less than the regular season.
Defense:
Points allowed: 23rd
Yards allowed: 21st
Take Aways: 8th
Offense:
Points: 2nd
Yards: 3rd
Turnovers: 6th
The Colts were not a well balanced team during the regular season but for the playoffs Peyton finally had a team.
2005 Steelers
Another well balanced but defensive team.
Defense:
Points allowed: 3rd
Yards allowed: 4th
Take Aways: 13th
Offense:
Points: 9th
Yards: 15th
Turnovers: 6th
2004 Patriots
Just an overall well balanced team.
Defense:
Points allowed: 2
Yards allowed: 9
Take Aways: 1
Offense:
Points: 4
Yards: 7
Turnovers: 9
2003 Patriots
Pretty balanced but clearly leaning on the defense.
Defense:
Points allowed: 1
Yards allowed: 7
Take Aways: 3
Offense:
Points: 12
Yards: 17
Turnovers: 6
2002 Bucs
Defense:
Points allowed: 1
Yards allowed: 1
Offense:
Points: 18
Yards: 24
Turnovers: *
*The place I was getting that stat from stopped at 2003
2001 Patriots
Defense:
Points allowed:6
Yards allowed: 24
Take Aways: *
Offense:
Points: 6
Yards: 19
Turnovers: *
2000 Ravens
Defense:
Points allowed: 1
Yards allowed: 2
Take Aways: *
Offense:
Points: 14
Yards: 16
Turnovers: *
Over the last 11 Super Bowls a team that was ranked #1 in one of the defensive categories won 6 times. Teams that were ranked #1 in one of the offensive categories won 1 time. Teams that I would say were clearly leaning toward the defensive side won 5. Teams that were clearly leaning offensive won 2. Teams that I would say are balanced won 4, however, I would say that all of the teams were pretty balanced in their own way. Even if they weren't balanced in the regular season they certainly picked it up in the playoffs.
2011 49ers
Clearly a defensive leaning team. But just outside the top 10 in the most important offensive category (points scored) and number 1 in another. I didn't include special teams in any of the analysis but the 49ers are number 1 in several of those categories as well. This is a very good and well balanced team.
Defense:
Points allowed: 2
Yards allowed: 4
Take Aways: 1(t)
Offense:
Points: 11
Yards: 26
Turnovers: 1
2011 Saints
Clearly an offensive team. Just outside the top 10 in the most important defensive category though (points allowed). The Saints also have a good kicker and returner.
Defense:
Points allowed: 13
Yards allowed: 24
Take Aways: 31
Offense:
Points: 2
Yards: 1
Turnovers: 7
Both the 49ers and the Saints are pretty balanced teams that do tend to favor one side of the ball. The game between the two will come down to who can execute their game plan better and probably who gets a few of the breaks to go their way. Either team can win it all by playing their game and getting improvement in just one area. If they Saints can get some turnovers a repeat of 2009 would not be surprising. If the 49ers can just execute in the red zone then they will be able to put up more than enough points to beat anybody anywhere.
In this era of the offense it takes more than a lot of yards to win a Super Bowl. But rarely do teams win it all without having all facets of the game working right. Defense doesn't win championships. Offense doesn't win championships. Teams win championships.


There are 107 Comments. Load Now.
Shortcuts to mastering the comment thread. Use wisely.
C - Next Comment
X - Mark as Read
R - Reply
Z - Mark Read & Next
Shift + C - Previous
Shift + A - Mark All Read
Comment Settings
Live comment alert: Hide it!
Comments for this post are closed.