Brian Bahr

Alex Smith concussion: SF QB seeks second opinion on head injury

Alex Smith suffered a concussion in the 49ers Week 10 tie with the St. Louis Rams. We break down the timeline and news related to his recovery and return to the field.

  • Live
13 Total Updates since November 12, 2012
  • Important 11
  • Updates 2
  • Articles 11
  • All Updates 13

Alex Smith officially out for MNF

The 49ers made official what was reported earlier in the day by Chris Mortensen. The 49ers will deactivate QB Alex Smith for Monday Night Football against the Chicago Bears. According to the 49ers, Smith was evaluated by team medical director Dr. Dan Garza and was not cleared to play. Colin Kaepernick will get the start in place of Smith and Scott Tolzien will be active as the backup quarterback. The emergency quarterback will likely be Kyle Williams, who filled that role last week when Smith first went down.

The reports out of practice had indicated Alex Smith was receiving most of the snaps all week long. These reports leave a couple of situations. The first is that the team really did expect Alex Smith to be cleared to play, and this has come out of nowhere, leaving them in a tough situation with a potentially somewhat unprepared Colin Kaepernick.

The other situation is that the team has been playing a game of misdirection. The media is allowed to observe practice during individual drills, but is not allowed to watch the team drills. It is possible the 49ers coaching staff has played it out as if Smith would play, but really was doing that to keep the Chicago Bears in the dark for their own preparations.

Bears head coach Lovie Smith had indicated they were more concerned with the run anyway, so the QB was not a huge deal for them. That makes a certain amount of sense. Although Kaepernick can potentially open up the offense a bit more, having his first career start come against the dominant Bears defense would seem more likely to force a more conservative game plan on the 49ers offense. It is hard to figure out exactly what will happen, but I would be a bit surprised if the 49ers did not come out looking to establish the run game in a very decisive manner. They could very well open things up, but that just does not strike me as the likely play, at least initially.

It certainly does make for an interesting matchup. The game was already plenty interesting with the playoff stakes, but getting the second year "QB of the future" into the game makes it that much more interesting for all involved. All I want is a win, but there is a certain buzz with the uncertainty of Kaep getting the start. It should make for quite the night (good or bad remaining to be seen!).


49ers declare Alex Smith OUT for MNF

We break down the news that Alex Smith will not play in Monday Night Football.


Alex Smith had one last test to pass for MNF

We take a look at the latest news about Alex Smith's concussion and the final testing protocol.


Alex Smith, Chris Culliver game status set

We break down the 49ers and Bears final injury reports before Week 11 Monday Night Football.


49ers Thursday practice participation report

We break down the 49ers Thursday practice participation report in advance of Monday Night Football vs. the Bears.


Alex Smith returns to practice in black jersey

We break down the latest news surrounding Alex Smith's concussion with word that he has been cleared to practice.


Alex Smith seeks a second opinion

We break down the latest news surrounding Alex Smith's concussion amid reports he is seeking a second opinion.


Smith threw touchdown pass with blurred vision

Alex Smith suffered a concussion versus the St. Louis Rams on Sunday.


49ers wait to learn the fate of Alex Smith

The 49ers signal caller must go through the league's concussion protocol before being cleared to play, which mean's the team will have to wait to learn the fate of their quarterback.


Alex Smith and Jay Cutler were BOTH concussed Sun

We break down the 49ers and Bears QB situations in light of concussions suffered by both Alex Smith and Jay Cutler.


Alex Smith suffers concussion in 49ers tie

We break down the 49ers latest injury news, focusing on Alex Smith's concussion.


Alex Smith suffers concussion vs. Rams

In a big turn of events, QB Colin Kaepernick has entered the game in place of Alex Smith. On the 49ers touchdown-scoring drive, Alex Smith took a couple big hits, including an instance where he dove/slid shoulder-first and took a big hit from Jo-Lonn Dunbar. We now have confirmation that Alex Smith has suffered a concussion and is out for the rest of the game.

The trainers were talking with Smith, including the team's concussion expert before he left the game for the locker room. The announcers confirmed the concussion, which means Colin Kaepernick is the 49ers quarterback the rest of the game. Kaepernick came in for his first drive and was unable to do much to move the offense. Kaepernick picked up ten yards on an early scramble, but a holding penalty a couple plays later cost the team a first down and they had to punt.

The 49ers trail 14-7 and will look for some kind of life from Kaepernick to get things going.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Niners Nation

You must be a member of Niners Nation to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Niners Nation. You should read them.

Join Niners Nation

You must be a member of Niners Nation to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Niners Nation. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.