NFC West Grades by Position

I read Mike Sando's grades for the NFC West recently and didn't really feel like I understood his process as to how

he came up with his grades. So, I decided to do my own grading. Table 1 shows my grades along with the stats

used to obtain those those grades shown in Table 2. I admit my analysis was not conducted using any sort of

regression analysis. I simply looked at the stats and how productive each team was last year at each position (With

the exception of obtaining Phil Dawson). Many players on each team have left and new ones have been signed. For

instance, both of the starting safeties for the Cards have left so their grades are based on players that are not even

playing for them anymore. Also, I have put the stats for the QB position in Table 3 so everyone can compare the

stats since it is hotly contested who the best in the division is. Enjoy.

It is important to remember that I looked only at productivity by each starter for each position and not talent. For example, STL was graded as having the #1 WRs in the division because of their productivity in the offense.

The most difficult grading was for the WR position due to the stats I used. I had to create a point system to determine which team obtained what grade as explained in Table 4. Also, STL has the best WR since they're receivers contributed more to the passing game than the other teams even if the player talent isn't there.

For CBs, WRs, LBs, and RBs I looked at the top 4 or so players at that position since so many players contribute.

TABLE 1. Grades per team from 1-4.

QB 1 2 3 4
RB 2 1 3 4
WR 4 3 1 2
TE 1 2 3 4
OL 1 2 3 4
DL 3 2 1 4
LB 1 4 3 2
S 2 1 3 4
CB 4 1 3 2
P 1 3 4 2
K 1 3 4 2
Coach 1 2 3 4

TABLE 2. Statistics used to obtain each positions grade.

QB Yds/Att Yds/game Yds/game QBR Rating Rush Yds/Game TD % INT % Total Yds/ Game
RB Yds/Att Tot Yds TD
WR Yds/Rec Yds/Game Total Yds TD
TE Yds/Rec Yds/Game Total Yds TD
OL Sacks Allowed Rush Avg
DL Sacks
S TOT INT FF *Pro Bowlers *All Pro
CB TOT INT FF *Pro Bowlers *All Pro
P Punt Avg # In 20
K FG %

Pro Bowlers = # of players that made pro bowl

All Pro = # of players that made All Pro team (1st or 2nd)

* I used Pro Bowlers and All Pro Team members to obtain a better understanding for each grade. I would have used these parameters for the other positions but the stats spoke for themselves whereas the Safety and CB positions were a little bit trickier.

TABLE 3. Stats for each QB position in the Division.

COMP % Yds/Att Rating QBR Pass Yds/game Rush Yds/Game TD % INT % Total Yds/ Game
SF (Kaep) 62.4 8.3 98.3 76.8 226.75 51.875 4.6 1.4 278.625
SEA (Wilson) 64.1 7.9 100 69.6 194.875 30.5625 6.6 2.5 225.4375
STL (Bradford) 59.5 6.7 82.6 51.6 231.375 7.9375 3.8 2.4 239.3125
**ARZ (all qbs) 55.6 5.65 63.5 24.9 211.4375 6.9375 55.6 55.6 218.375

**The stats for ARZ were averaged amongst all QBs.

TABLE 4. Stats for each WR position in the Division. The total WR grade was determined by grading each stat and assigning 0.25 pts per rank. For instance, SEA had the highest Yds/Rec grade so they get 1 point, whereas SF was 2nd in Yds/Rec so they get 0.75 pts. and so on. In the end SEA and ARZ were tied for 2nd place but I give the nod to Fitz (subjective but he's the best WR in the division even if stats don't show it) so ARZ WRs are graded 2nd best in the division.

Yds/Rec Yds/Game Total Yds TD
SF 12.87135 137.5625 2201 14
SEA 14.02158 121.8125 1949 18
STL 12.25116 164.625 2634 17
ARZ 10.8419 171.4375 2743 11

I understand my analysis has holes and could be better put together. But I had no idea how Sando came about his results and wanted to create my own to better understand the dynamics within the division and between positions.

This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Niners Nation's writers or editors. It does reflect the views of this particular fan though, which is as important as the views of Niners Nation's writers or editors.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Niners Nation

You must be a member of Niners Nation to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Niners Nation. You should read them.

Join Niners Nation

You must be a member of Niners Nation to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Niners Nation. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.