49ers 26 - Raiders 21
I made a brief mention of it in the comments of the game thread, but if nothing else, the 49ers certainly have had some entertaining preseason games. After failing in the final minutes against Denver, the 49ers bounced back to SURVIVE the Oakland Raiders 26-21 in the final minute of the game. After Shaun Hill and Thomas Clayton led the 49ers on a touchdown-scoring drive, the Raiders made a last-ditch effort that would have been successful if Alvis Whitted had not dropped a sure touchdown with 5 seconds left. Thankfully this was the preseason and some relative scrubs were in. However, this is definitely not something we want to make a habit of in the future.
So we'll do a quick rundown of the game, with more analysis to come.
Delanie Walker had another really solid game, including a big 15-yard reception in the fourth quarter. Through 2 games, Walker has 70 receiving yards and a touchdown while looking quite solid as the #2 tight end.
Thomas Clayton is quickly developing into one of "my guys." He definitely has a lot to work on before he can become a legit NFL running back, but for a rookie he's showing some skills. He still dances a little bit much, but he has definitely done enough to warrant some playing time with the better components of the depth chart. I'm not saying to start him next week, but I'd love to see him get even just 3 or 4 plays with the starting offensive line.
Ashley Lelie had a very solid game earning CBS Channel 5 player of the game honors (that's up there with league MVP obviously) with 4 catches for 57 yards and a touchdown. He certainly needs to show some consistency these remaining two games, but he's definitely earning some playing time.
Alex Smith followed up Week 1 with a very solid performance. He was efficient and while he did good work in the short game, he was able to mix up in some medium-depth passes to move the team down the field. 8/12 for 106 yards a touchdown is just about perfect for a preseason Week 2 performance. Considering his short history in the NFL I really could not be happier with his performance so far in August.
The defense definitely had its ups and downs. The first quarter was a solid showing, but they reverted to form in the second quarter. Poor tackling was the main problem. For those who didn't watch, CBS had Coach Nolan miked up and it was interesting to hear him coaching the rookies on the sideline. After two different defensive series he pulled Patrick Willis and Jay Moore aside to explain some situations to them. While I like that he is hopefully giving more duties to Manusky, he's always been a defensive-oriented guy and I'm glad he takes some time to do some teaching during the game. It will only make the rookies better.
Additionally, penalties were flying all over the place for both teams as this was a rather sloppy performance by everybody.
Shaun Hill reminds of Cody Pickett somewhat. He's running all over the place and while he's clearly not the most talented guy, he's made things happen. He was 2-for-6 but throw in the big rush and it just seemed like he did more than the stats would indicate. He's obviously the clear-cut 3rd string QB, but he certainly entertains the masses.
Speaking of QBs, Trent Dilfer looked really solid this week after a so-so week 1. If Alex Smith went down it would not be good, but Dilfer at least looks like he could make the occasional play, which is more than you can say for some teams backups (Jim Sorgi anyone?)
While we don't really care about the Raiders, I do think LaMont Jordan looked really good and aside from his fumbling problems, Daunte Culpepper looked pretty sharp. I still don't think they'll be all that good this year, but they could certainly surprise some people if Jordan and Culpepper continue this trend.
Maurice Hicks and Michael Robinson turned in some real stinkers combined for 17 yards on 7 carries, so we'll look at that little battle among other things.
There didn't appear to be any injuries of significance that I could see, but I'll keep an eye out for any injury news. Otherwise, we'll be back with more analysis tomorrow.
0 recs |
7 comments
Comments
wait.........
by jtoj on Aug 18, 2007 11:15 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Team looks good
I too like Delanie Walker's catching. I wonder if his blocking is so much of a liability to keep him behind Bajema on the chart. With him and Davis on the field they can create incredible matchup problems for the other team. I got the feeling that Lelie was on a downward spiral over the spring, with the reports of his injuries keeping him out of practice, but he looked good last night. Smith is looking so much better than last year.
Overall, I think the offense will be light years ahead of last year. The defense should be better, but it also needs to be a lot better if they're going to make the playoffs.
Looks like Culpepper would fit well with the Raiders. And the Raiders' O line looked a lot better. There must have been a big upgrade in coaching for that leap.
by Bob In Pacifica on Aug 19, 2007 8:36 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Raider's OL
If their line really improves this year, their run-game could be pretty solid. Rhodes and Jordan are already a solid 1-2 punch. If you throw in Bush (who should be ready at some point early in the season) and they have a rushing attack that is both bruising and quick/fast. That improvement in the run game will make Walter's or Culpepper's job a lot easier this year.
by sfgfan on Aug 20, 2007 11:08 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
my two observations...
- another solid outing from alex smith. he's been great so far in limited preseason action but from what i'm seeing so far i'm excited about him this season. i'm hoping and can see a 20+ passing touchdown season.
- shaky run defense for the niners so far. jordan was running all over them, much like henry did the first week of the preseason. they need to really work on tightening up that run defense going into the season. but, like i've said before, i think its just going to take awhile for this team to gel defensively.
by coachAJ on Aug 19, 2007 8:08 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Alex Smith
by sfgfan on Aug 20, 2007 11:10 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Run Defense did ok considering ...
As for the run defense, you have to consider we were without our starting D-Line. (Young, Douglas, and Franklin) With that in mind, I think we did ok. Both Fields and McDonald did not occupy their blockers effectively. We will be better with our starting D-line.
On a side note, Manny played much better. Although, I still haven't seen any pass-rushing ability from him. I think I'm giving up on the idea that he'll be a Merriman.
by ALottOfSense on Aug 20, 2007 12:41 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 



















