clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

49ers vs. Baltimore Ravens: Our defense is pretty damn good

Lost in the midst of the panic, euphoria, panic, euphoria of the Alex Smith saga (as well as the plain panic of the offensive line saga), is that the 49ers defense is actually better than advertised. More importantly, I think some of the rankings out there are misleading in a sense. Statistics may not lie, but they do need to be taken in context.

According to Football Outsiders defensive team efficiency ratings, the 49ers are 21st in Total Defensive DVOA, 23rd against the pass and 16th against the run. While I don't have a statistical argument to combat those rankings, I'd like to just use my own subjective analysis. When your offense is so awful (31st overall, 32nd passing, 18th rushing), your defense tends to spend a whole lot more time on the field.

I do recognize that we have some young guys on the defense and losing Manny Lawson was a big blow. While it's nice having a very solid defense, a major difference between this defense and a defense like the 2000 Ravens or last year's Bears is the ability to create turnovers. We have 3 interceptions and four forced fumbles. The Lions on the other hand have forced 20 (11 fumbles and 9 INTs)!!!! That can be attributed in part to luck, but good defenses know how to make game-changing plays.

The only reason I mention that issue is that if we're going to win games anytime soon, we're apparently going to need to some defensive scores. You don't want to rely on that, but sometimes you have to. The Ravens are coming to town this weekend and while they're not the big play defensive threat they once were, Ray Lewis, Ed Reed and company can still make plays. Speaking of the defenses, I came across an interesting quote. Mike Tanier, from Football Outsiders, does a rundown each week over at and in his discussion about the 49ers-Ravens matchup, he had the following to say:

The best way for Dilfer to exact revenge is to do what he did during the Ravens' Super Bowl run: stand there, hand off, and let his running back and defense do the work. San Francisco's defense is much better than its points allowed indicate. It may even be as good as the Baltimore D, which showed a few fissures last week. The Niners are very capable of winning an ugly, low-scoring affair.
The Ravens bring a less than spectacular offense to Walsh Field this weekend, which makes it all the more important that our defense steps up. The Ravens bring a middle of the road offensive line and an inconsistent passing attack. McNair did manage 307 yards and Willis McGahee put up 104 yards on only 14 carries, so they can certainly make big plays. Of course, the 49ers defense is NOT the Cleveland Browns defense. As good as McNair can still be on occasion, I think our secondary has a clear edge. th key will come down to containing Willis McGahee. This will be Frank Gore's first head to head battle with his former Miami running mate, so let's hope he can take home bragging rights.

Before I post this, speaking of the secondary, I would like to throw one interesting little nugget out there. FO has a stat of DVOA vs. types of receivers. They have determined DVOA to date for each team versus other teams' #1 and #2 receiver, as well as other receivers, tight ends and running backs. The 49ers numbers aren't very pretty against #2 receivers (26th overall) or running backs (30th) or tight ends (30th). HOWEVER, against the #1 receiver? The 49ers are #1 in all the land. FO admits their selections of #1 versus #2 receivers is subjective, but nonetheless, all I have to say is Nate Clements is SOOOO money!