clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Ranking the NFC West: San Francisco 49ers lead the way at tight end

We break down the NFC West by position, starting with the tight end position. The San Francisco 49ers lead the way with Vernon Davis and high-potential rookie Vance McDonald. Is it the right choice?

Streeter Lecka

There's nothing like a little uniformity to get us through an otherwise boring offseason. When I'm sapped of creativity, I like to make comparisons and lists, as you might be able to tell from the power rankings I posted yesterday.

My next project will be to break down the NFC West by position. The division is up for grabs, though there's really only two teams in the race for it: our San Francisco 49ers and the Seattle Seahawks. I think we're all hoping that the Seahawks crash and burn next season, and that all the hype is unwarranted, but I have to say, in my preliminary breakdowns, it's hard to make that a defensible position.

In other words, taking a look at position-by-position, you may not like what the end result looks like. But before we get ahead of ourselves, we'll start with just one position: tight end. Let's take a look at the position within the division.

1st. San Francisco 49ers with Vernon Davis, Vance McDonald, Garrett Celek, Cameron Morrah

This isn't a hard position to defend at this point, especially if McDonald pans out into half the tight end that experts believe he can. The position took a hit with the departure of Delanie Walker, but his abilities in the passing game were waning over the past couple seasons.

You don't rank the tight end position on blocking proficiency, even if Walker and Vernon Davis were among the top two tight ends in the NFL at blocking. Walker signed with the Tennessee Titans, and he'll probably have a good career there. McDonald will step into his role, with a higher ceiling, especially in the passing attack the 49ers want to employ.

But getting into it, Davis is far and away the best tight end in the division. He had something of a down year last season, but despite being kept in to block an awful lot, he had 548 yards and five touchdowns, with an average of 13.4 yards per reception. With another year of Colin Kaepernick progression, I think most of us expect Davis to re-emerge as one of the top receiving tight ends in the league.

With the NFL, leaning toward a two tight end offense, the only team really steering in that direction in the division is the 49ers.

2nd. Seattle Seahawks with Zach Miller, Anthony McCoy, Luke Wilson, Sean McGrath

When the Seahawks got Miller, there was a lot of talk about how he was one of the better tight ends in the NFL, but so far in his two seasons, he hasn't surpassed the yardage of even his rookie season with the Oakland Raiders. He had just 396 yards and three touchdowns in 16 games last season, but that doesn't mean he should be overlooked.

No, until further notice, Miller is still among the NFL's elite, provided the Seahawks actually use him. His window might be closing, but the fact remains that he is one of the more reliable targets in the division and Russell Wilson surely appreciates that.

McCoy could be on the verge of breaking out sometime soon, with 291 yards and three touchdowns last season, but for now, he's more of a backup and less of a two-tight end set kind of guy. He has the tendency to disappear at times, but who knows, this could be the year he breaks out!

3rd. St. Louis Rams with Jared Cook, Lance Kendricks, Cory Harkey, Miek McNeil

Lance Kendricks looked like he might be breaking out in 2012, and to a certain extent, he did. He had 519 yards and four touchdowns, with an average of 12.4 yards per reception. That said, he doesn't seem to have that high a ceiling, or at least, that's just my read on him. I've felt like Kendricks might be more of a No. 2 tight end than a No. 1, and if the thing works out with Jared Cook, then that will be the case.

Cook was a free agent signing this offseason, and the Rams are certainly paying him like he's a No 1 tight end. In fact, the Rams are paying him like he was one of the better tight ends in the league, which he certainly has the potential to be, but at this point, it seems a little ludicrous.

The Rams have the potential to have the best group of tight ends in the division, but until we see more from both Kendricks and Cook, this is the proper ranking for them, in my opinion.

4th. Arizona Cardinals with Rob Housler, Jeff King, Jim Dray

The Cardinals have been without serious tight end talent for some time now. For so long, that offense has been predicated solely on wide receiver Larry Fitzgerald, and the fact that Jeff King and Rob Housler are the top two tight ends is just ... sad.

Housler wasn't terrible last year. He had 417 yards and no touchdowns, while King had 129 yards behind him. Housler was a third-round pick in 2011 and could pan out to be a pretty decent tight end when its all said and done, but like Kendricks in St. Louis, he looks more like a No. 2 than a starting tight end.

Arizona hasn't been serious about the tight end position and it shows. They lack a big, consistent and reliable target to go over the middle. They have the worst group of tight ends in the division and that likely won't change one bit in 2013.