clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

The Tier Hunter, Week 3: The good (backup QB’s), the bad (coaching decisions), and the ugly (49ers win)

Backup QB’s are the new black, Freddie Kitchens is new Hugh Jackson, and the Dolphins actually scored points (six of them!)

NFL: New York Giants at Tampa Bay Buccaneers
From laughingstock to legend in record time.
Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

Worrying about all the marquee QB’s out with injuries is so last week. Embracing the backup QB is all the rage. No less than five backup QB’s led their teams to huge wins this week, four of them coming on the road, three the first win for 0-2 teams.

A sixth backup, Mason Rudolph, almost scored a fifth road win and fourth first win of the year, but in the end, he got Jimmy G’d. Two more, Josh Rosen and Luke Falk, also got starts for 0-2 teams, but that was more of a sacrificial lamb thing.

The first of this week’s two(!) bonus lists rank the performances of those backups.

1. Daniel Jones

23/36 336 yards, 2 TD/0 INT, 112.7 rating, two rushing TD’s

Jones didn’t put up the accuracy or TD numbers. The next two on this list did, so you can see this isn’t just about the stats. Still, look at those stats!

Jones not only led the 0-2 Giants to a huge win on the road, but he also had to engineer a comeback from 18 points without his best weapon.

It only took him one game to make Giants fans forget about Eli Manning.

It was his first NFL start after the Giants faced tons of ridicule for picking him so high. That’s a lot of pressure. He came through like a champ. Super impressive.

2. Kyle Allen

19/26 261 yards, 4 TD/0 INT, 144.4 rating

Allen engineered a huge win for an 0-2 team, on the road. That should never be taken lightly, even if it came against the Cardinals. And it may not have been a fluke: Allen also played well in his only other start -- 2018 Week 17: 20/31 266 2/0 113.1 rating. So maybe it’s not all that surprising the Panthers have already greenlit Allen’s next start. If he beats the Texans, will there be a QB controversy brewing in Carolina?

3. Jacoby Brissett

29/34 304 yards, 3 TD/1 INT, 121.1 rating

Okay, this could be considered cheating, but Brissett was the backup heading into camp, so I’m counting it. And if this was about my confidence in the backup moving forward, I might have Brissett first. But since I’m only considering Week 3, Brissett gets dinged for having much more experience than Jones or Allen. Still, his accuracy was very impressive.

4. Gardner Minshew II

20/30 204 yards, 2 TD/0 INT, 108.2 rating

Minshew commanded the Jags to a huge divisional win on the road for an 0-2 team. He might’ve done it twice in a row if his coach gave him a chance. Suddenly, Jacksonville’s lost season doesn’t seem so lost.

5. Teddy Bridgewater

19/27 177 yards, 2 TD/0 INT, 112.7 rating

Bridgewater led the Saints to a huge road win, but he didn’t throw the ball downfield all day. New Orleans only had 265 yards on offense and won mainly because they got a TD from both their defense and special teams.

Bad Coaching Olympics II

Back due to popular demand more bad coaching!

Some old favorites flirted with this list. Anthony Lynn called a timeout that could’ve cost the Chargers the game, but it turned out his team was able to lose it without his help. Mike Tomlin had a chance to call a timeout before the half to help his team, but apparently, he preferred to go in for the half. Maybe he had to pee.

But those guys didn’t rise sink to the level of the medal round. Let’s take a look at who did, including an old friend and new star on the rise.

Bronze medal: Bruce Arians

I hate to single Arians out for the second straight week, but he practically begged for it. After blowing an 18-point lead to a rookie QB making his first NFL start, the Bucs pulled off a miracle, moving the ball 66 yards in 63 seconds, the last 44 coming on a Hail Mary to Mike Evans to reach the Giants 13. Despite having a timeout left, the Bucs ran down the field and spiked the ball to leave: 13 left.

Their kicker Matt Gay had already missed two extra points on the day, so you might think Arians would take a shot or two at the end zone. Or maybe they’d be more conservative and run the ball, trying to edge a little closer, then call a timeout and kick. Instead, Tampa took a delay of game. The clock wasn’t running. There was no rush. They just didn’t run a play. And here’s the thing: That was the plan.

And with time left on the clock, Arians ordered Jameis Winston to center the ball, which he did, losing a couple more yards. So a 27-yarder became a 34-yarder, which Gay missed by, oh, I’d say about a foot.

Your kicker misses two extra points from 33 yards, so you move a 27-yarder back to 34?

Silver medal: Freddie Kitchens

Kitchens has appeared in over his head all year, but no more so than in the first fourth quarter of a close game he had to manage. After the Rams took the lead 17-13 early in the fourth quarter, Cleveland moved the ball to the Rams 40. With less than 10 minutes remaining, the Browns faced a 4th and 9. That’s when Freddie formally introduced himself to a nation. He called a draw. Nick Chubb was stopped for two yards, and the announcers immediately seized on the choice. So did the internet.

It wasn’t just a stupid decision, it was somewhat historic.

Gold medal: Freddie Kitchens

That’s right, Freddie wasn’t done yet. Not by a long shot. With: 43 left in the game and Cleveland down 20-13, the Browns drove the ball to the Rams 4-yard line, where they set up with a 1st and 10.

Despite having three timeouts, and Nick Chubb’s success on the ground (96 yards on 23 carries while being used sub-optimally) the Browns went with empty backfields and no threat of the run.

This allowed the Rams rush to tee off on Mayfield, who was backpedaling and rushing his throws throughout the series. Turns out, having three or more WR’s on the field has been a problem for Cleveland since last year.

Due to the Rams all-out rush, the QB draw was available the entire series. Had Kitchens called it, or Mayfield spotted it -- as #DannyDimes did on his game-winning TD -- Cleveland ties the game.

Making matters worse, Kitchens took a timeout before the 4th down play, so once they didn’t score he couldn’t force a punt out of the Rams end zone.

After the game, Kitchen admitted mistakes. But don’t worry; he’s not giving up yet.

32 Flavors (and then some)

Week 3 is when preconceived notions really start melting away. It becomes harder to ignore the records, and just focus on the talent.

Tier 1: Next Stop, AFC Championship Game

How good is Patrick Mahomes? His team has to be in the top tier because he’s on it.

1. New England Patriots (3-0)

2. Kansas City Chiefs (3-0)

Mahomes puts on a show even with his starting RB and best WR out with injuries.

Tier 2: Threats

They’re not as good as the Chiefs and Patriots but could conceivably beat them.

3. Los Angeles Rams (3-0)

4. Dallas Cowboys (3-0)

5. Green Bay Packers (3-0)

Aaron Rodgers and one of the best defenses in the league is a powerful combo.

Tier 3: Non-threats

They have good records. They’ll probably make the playoffs. But I don’t see these teams as true title contenders in their present state.

6. Baltimore Ravens (2-1)

7. New Orleans Saints (2-1)

The offense without Brees is still a concern moving forward.

8. Minnesota Vikings (2-1)

Tier 4: Better Than Their Record

You’ll just have to take my word for it.

9. Philadelphia Eagles (1-2)

The Eagles are already very injury-depleted, missing players all over the field. And without Alshon Jeffrey and DeSean Jackson. Nelson Agholor has picked a bad time to drop passes, of which the Eagles had seven on Sunday.

But I believe in the roster, and most of their injured players should be back before long.

Tier 5: Not Pretty, But Pretty Effective

They’ve had some ugly wins. But it beats pretty losses.

10. San Francisco 49ers (3-0)

State of the Niners: At rest.

And they need it. They’ve lost a key, hard-to-replace player from each side of the ball the last two weeks, and an extra week of rest, recovery, and practice might be just what the doctor ordered. And while the Joe Staley and Akhello Witherspoon injuries are certainly daunting, one can only be impressed with how the team has moved the ball on offense, and stopped their opponent on defense. Sure, there’s the little matter of five turnovers, but that only makes the win, and the 24 points they put up more impressive. They don’t win that game that year. And Jimmy G was a big reason for that.

But there’s also an undeniable sloppiness to the team’s play that can’t be ignored. Even before this past week, they committed 20 penalties and had four TD’s called back. Again, the fact those mistakes haven’t cost them a game or kept them from scoring enough is impressive. But that’s kind of like being good at driving drunk — it’s better than being bad at it, but you shouldn’t be doing it at all. If the 49ers keep doing it, it’s going to cost them games. So here’s to hoping Kyle Shanahan impresses that on his team over the bye week.

11. Chicago Bears (2-1)

12. Houston Texans (2-1)

Tier 6: Underrated

Nobody had these teams doing anything, at least not after Andrew Luck retired, but here they are.

13. Indianapolis Colts (2-1)

The Colts lost their starting QB just before the season, yet find themselves tied atop their division, with their only loss coming on the road in OT. Andrew who?

14. Buffalo Bills (3-0)

15. Detroit Lions (2-0-1)

Tier 7: Overrated

You thought at least one of these teams was good. Now you’re not so sure.

16. Los Angeles Chargers (1-2)

17. Cleveland Browns (1-2)

18. Atlanta Falcons (1-2)

19. Seattle Seahawks (2-1)

Thud. I’m talking about the sound of Seattle falling to earth against the Drew Brees-less Saints, not the sound of a football meeting Pete Carroll’s face.

The Seahawks looked like a soft 2-0 coming in, and then went out and proved it on the field.

Tier 8: Mediocrity At Its Finest

You could convince me one of these teams will turn it around and make the playoffs. Especially if their QB’s name rhymed with Shmardner Shminshew. I’d also accept Schmyle Schmallen.

20. Tampa Bay Buccaneers (1-2)

21. Carolina Panthers (1-2)

22. Jacksonville Jaguars (1-2)

23. Tennessee Titans (1-2)

Tennessee is one of the most feast or famine teams in the NFL. Having an inaccurate passer is one reason for that. On Thursday night, Marcus Mariota made some of the most inaccurate passes you’ll ever see in an NFL game.

Of course, Mariota was under constant attack from a rush which sacked him nine times.

I’m not confident Ryan Tannehill would be any better than Mariota, but you have to wonder when we might find out.

Tier 9: Could Still Easily Beat The Dolphins

So they’ve got that going for them. Which is nice.

24. Pittsburgh Steelers (0-3)

25. Arizona Cardinals (0-2-1)

26. Oakland Raiders (1-2)

27. New York Giants (1-2)

29. Washington Redskins (0-3)

29. Denver Broncos (0-3)

30. Cincinnati Bengals (0-3)

31. New York Jets (0-3)

Are we sure they’d be worse with a mono-stricken Darnold starting at QB?

32. Vic Fangio

I love to toot my own horn about the predictions I get right (and plan on continuing), so I have to come clean when I’m wrong. I thought Fangio and the Broncos’ defensive talent was a marriage made in heaven. But the Broncos are the first team to have zero through three weeks since the sack became a stat, with Bradley Chubb and Von Miller on the roster, and the team is 0-3. It’s early, but Fangio has the look of a one-and-done coach.

Tier 10: #FishTank

They went and did it. They made me give them their tier.

33. Miami Dolphins (0-3)

Just look at where the Dolphins are compared to the rest of the league here:

The Phins are making my survivor pool a breeze this year. We might have to split the pot 400 ways.


Which backup QB do you have the most confidence in moving forward

This poll is closed

  • 26%
    Daniel Jones
    (92 votes)
  • 9%
    Kyle Allen
    (31 votes)
  • 33%
    Jacoby Brisssett
    (115 votes)
  • 12%
    Gardner Minshew II
    (44 votes)
  • 13%
    Teddy Bridgewater
    (47 votes)
  • 4%
    Other (list in comments)
    (15 votes)
344 votes total Vote Now