clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Monday Night Football shake-up might be in the works.

New, comments

This should not be at all surprising.

ESPN may have run out of patience. Andrew Marchand of the New York Post reports that Monday Night Football producer Jay Rothman will not return for 2020. So why is this news? As Marchand notes, a new producer may want their own people running things.

And yes, that includes commentary. Which means Booger McFarland and Joe Tessitore may be out.

Before we go any further, it’s important to note no one besides Rothman has been listed as being moved from MNF—and even that isn’t confirmed. So if McFarland and Tessitore were to go is speculation.

But Marchand makes a note that ESPN is looking into prying Tony Romo from CBS Sports. The move would be lucrative to Romo, who has a passion for playing golf and making the cut in PGA events. That would let him hit the links on Sunday and pick up a microphone on Monday. Plus, Romo’s contract is up soon. And you don’t need to compare Romo to McFarland on color; there is no comparison. Romo was a breath of fresh air for his knowledge of the game while McFarland has had two seasons stumbling.

As for who calls the games? ESPN has a few names, but most are under contract. If they couldn’t get Romo, Marchand notes that college gameday duo Chris Fowler and Kirk Herbstreit has been discussed as the pairing. I really don’t know how I could adjust to those two calling an NFL game, and I’m pretty sure ESPN doesn’t know either. Any discussion on that had to be a quick idea by Timmy, the intern that got a hearty laugh for five minutes. Plus, Herbstreit never played in the NFL. You go from a defensive tackle with laughably bad breakdowns on quarterbacks and replace them with a college quarterback who never played at the NFL level? At least Herbstreit would have the peace of mind not to encourage a fifth down.

McFarland’s first year was as the third voice. ESPN gave him the “Booger Mobile,” where he rode around near the sidelines, watching the game and blocking the view of paying fans. As the season went on, ESPN scrapped the contraption for good. After Jason Witten left to return to active duty in the NFL, McFarland became the No. 2 commentator next to Tessitore, and you can generate your own assessments of how it went.

Monday Night Football was originally the flagship show of the NFL. While the game itself may have been disappointing, the show had high production value, knowledgeable announcers, and a pedigree that couldn’t be matched with the Sunday games. That may have been eclipsed by Sunday Night Football. Monday Night Football now has contraptions, a halftime show with music no one asked for, and a lot of advertising opportunity. Here’s a good video on how ESPN went this route with not just Monday Night Football, but the business as a whole in case you’re curious why all the big names left.

While we don’t know the state of the announcers, moving producers means a change might be in the works. They need one.

At least get AFI for a Genesis Halftime Show. Or Megadeth.